I've seen some of the "both sides" posts trying to defend certain right-wing ideas done very poorly.
Anchor9 has one good "both sides" post, but I still have a few criticisms of it. I'm not an expert on politics, but I know how to understand and represent a person's ideas properly. I love learning about different viewpoints and ideas and forming my own opinions so I make sure to listen to different perspectives, even far-right ones. And since I am not as heavily biased and influenced as many people when discussing politics, I can represent the right's ideas well without mindlessly supporting or rejecting them. However, I still agree with many people here that certain "sides" and beliefs are better/smarter than others. Still, even though I believe that the right is generally "dumber/more evil/worse" doesn't mean that right-wing ideas should be dismissed, especially when they are so frequently poorly explained. I would show an example on how to properly state and defend right-wing ideas (which also applies to beliefs in general) without resorting to cheap, mainstream political arguments.
But before I start, I want to preface my post with these crucial points you should take into consideration before responding:
1. I would be steelmanning the arguments of the right. Yes many of them are bigoted, some to the point of violence. They also have many dumb people and arguments (though this is not exclusive to the right). I would be fixing and using their best arguments.
2. I am only looking at their arguments at face value. I will ignore their character, execution, or grift, and instead focus on the core of their ideas.
3. Just because the right has a point on a specific issue, doesn't mean that criticisms and counterpoints aren't any less true, nor does it mean that I support their stance.
I am simply stating the right's best arguments worthy of discussion.
There is nothing wrong with a nation wanting to restrict immigration and proritize their citizens. There is also nothing wrong with a nation securing their borders and having specific entry points. That's it. That's the argument. I don't need to expound on this with racist, fearmongering points like "immigrants are stealing our jobs" or "immigrants are criminals" because even though many conservatives say those, not all conservatives use those arguments as those arguments are not necessary in supporting anti-immigration and border security.
Going back to my preface, I don't want to see easily refutable responses like "the wall doesn't work at stopping illegal crossing"¹ or any mentions of Republican racism². Similarly, I won't be dunking on poor pro-immigration arguments like "we need immigrants to do cheap, dirty labor."³
Refutations
¹It may not completely stop illegal crossers, but it still hinders them the same way anti-theft laws don't completely stop stealing but hinders it. And if the wall is ineffective, other methods can still be explored to protect the border
²Just because there are racist Republicans that are against immigration doesn't mean that racism and anti-immigration aren't separable. In fact, I have seen a few conservatives support a near-complete ban on all immigration, even those from white countries.
³There is nothing wrong with Americans doing "dirty" labor. And whether the worker is an immigrant or not is not an excuse to underpay them.
There are two good ways to respond to this. The first is more of a philosophical response like "what gives nations the right to deny good people that want to live in their land entry? Why should your country of birth/ancestry decide where you can and can't go? Are national borders ethical?" These questions ignore present context and focuses more on the nature of immigration and borders.
The second way to answer it is to factor real-world context. But these are the more difficult questions "both sides" would have to answer and compromise their morals on, meaning neither "sides" are completely right or wrong when taking their best arguments. Those anti-immigration would have to ask themselves: "What about illegal immigrants who managed to make a good life as a citizen of that nation? Or asylum seekers who need protection from their country of origin? Is it right to deport these people back?" For those pro-immigration: "What will happen to our country if we let anyone freely enter our borders? If we continue to accept every asylum seeker and immigrant who wants to live a better life, what happens to their home countries? Is it right for people to leave their families and culture against their will and move to a new country rather than fighting for a better life in their home country?"
And this is just one issue where either the right has a serious point to consider and/or the left ignores or fails at. There are still many topics including, but not limited to abortion (I probably have the best stance on this from a bioethical standpoint), gender, crime, censorship, voter IDs, men's rights, and vaccine mandates. But for the sake of length I would instead continue it in another post if anyone wants to continue this discussion.
Modern politics, together with the people's use of statistics and other "studies" make the average person dumber. The way I see politics from the perspective of a person that doesn't really understand or overvalue the discipline is this. Humanity generally agrees on the same values. For example we can all agree that these four values of personal responsiblity, empathy, discipline, and helping the marginalized are inherently "good." You don't need "studies" to agree with this. But the truth is some of these values may go against each other, and corollary to this, we cannot execute all these values at the same time to the highest level. "Compromise" is then necessary. I placed compromise in quotation marks because if you are choosing between two values or "goods", are you really compromising when none of your morals are being violated? The right generally values personal responsibility and discipline more while the left values empathy and helping the marginalized more. Neither are wrong. Knowing when to apply personal responsiblity/discipline and empathy/helping the marginalized is what politics should be, at least for the masses. But instead a good chunk of politics has degenerated into "should we compromise with a senile, human rights violator to stop another senile, human rights violator fascist" or "how can x party/candidate secure more votes/positions of power" or "x,y,z is racist and leads to fascism".
When I say that politics should be for the masses in the previous paragraph, it is parallel to the "science for the people" movement. Apart from politics being used to serve the interests of the people, this also means that the average person's values should be mostly sufficient in making political decisuons and that the most relevant political concepts should be easily grasped by the average person. The average person shouldn't have to spend hours reading studies on why America is still racist and why many black communities are still struggling or have degrees to understand climate change or economics, especially when most media are extremely biased. The average person should instead intrinsically value helping the marginalized, reducing pollution, and working a job with a just wage. In fact, the average person who isn't that knowledgeable in politics should be asking political experts "why is it so frequent that we end up with two candidates with a realistic chance of presidency and how did it reach the point where Biden and Trump are the top 2 candidates for 2024?" Honestly, politics experts could better spend their time answering questions like this. Or focus on explaining to the masses what needs to be done by appealing to the average person's base values rather than "proving" to them that America is still racist or expanding tbe definition of racism. It doesn't matter if the average person believes that America is still racist or not, you can at the very least convince them that "struggling communities that happen to be mostly black" need more assistance to be self-sustaining. Let the political experts be in charge of the studies the same way scientists are in charge of researching climate change. Intervention is only necessary when one's beliefs lead to action that actively violates another person's rights (ex. one person believes that racism is good and starts attacking black people or one person believes that fossil fuels is good and burns fossil fuels purely for the sake of releasing harmful emissions in the air).
Philosophy, logic, and ethics > politics and handpicked studies/statistics. If you noticed the arguments I listed on immigration, they don't need sources to defend nor attack them. I did not need to research the effects of immigration of every country at every time period and understand the context of these nations to raise these points. A nation "prioritizing their own citizens" or "protecting their borders", or "is it immoral to deny entry to people" can be argued with axiomatic statements we agree on, unlike "immigrants are criminals", "the wall doesn't stop illegal crossing", or "immigrants make the economy better" which require empirical evidence and long hours of research and reviewing.
I would also love to make another more chill "politics" thread more suited to tackling political topics at a philosophical level. This thread is too application-focused and learning about modern politics is unnecessarily complex. There is a lot of human factors that affect a person's stance on an issue such as a politician's flawed character, propaganda through cherry-picked stats and resources, or playing the "political game" with leftists arguing over allying with Biden/Harris (even though I understand both "sides" of the issue). That way we can see "right-wing" ideas represented better and leftists would tone down the infighting. I would much rather discuss my views on abortion in a thread like that than in here because if I discuss it here, I might receive responses like "denying abortion would kill many women in need of it for medical reasons", which are important points to discuss in the real world, but takes away from the discussion of the morality of abortion itself. But I understand now may not be the best time with the election approaching. Having to moderate this thread with a semi-"political" thread, especially if this thread gets locked and people migrate over to the new thread, is not something I want to burden the mods with.