Grey Waves said:Thanks for the explanation. I actually thought Sablette was referring to the abolition of countries, not the abolition of governments, but both of your posts were an interesting read anyway.
Out of curiosity, for what reasons have you pegged me as a liberal? The only 2 posts I've made recently in this thread can basically be summed up as "what Hamas did on October 7th was wrong, and what Israel has been doing in Gaza since then is also wrong" and "if Hamas committed war crimes on October 7th when they had x amount of resources, then by logic they would also commit war crimes (but on a greater scale) if they had 2x (or any other multiple) amount of resources". Does calling out war crimes really count as a political take?
as sabelette and others have touched on, it is absurd for someone living thousands of miles away to be dictating the terms of the resistance of ~2 million people who have been held in a concentration camp / open air prison for their whole lives. (u also have posted false statements about widespread sexual assaults, as sabelette responded to u the first time which it seems u chose to entirely ignore, there is 0 evidence of such, regardless of the fact that the new york times hired a former-idf fascist to publish a lengthy "report" propogandizing this narrative that has no basis in reality as one example among the many ways that amerikan media have done everything in their power to spread around fantastical lies about 'hamas'.
https://theintercept.com/2024/02/28/new-york-times-anat-schwartz-october-7/ . while u and cancel cult claim that the reason for posting these comments "about hamas" is to combat misinformation when actually u are the one who is spreading misinformation).
obviously no one here is defending sexual violence, and if u want we can say we "condemn" any sexual violence that was carried out (obv the nytimes etc reports are complete inventions, but there probably were at least a few incidents of sexual violence on october 7. i say that not because "hamas is evil" or bc of anything about hamas at all, but because in the patriarchal etc world we live in, sexual assaults are / have been committed in almost every operation in armed conflict everywhere. and yes this is 'unacceptable', but the solution to it is the end of patriarchal imperial capitalism, not scapegoating specific operations that u dont like and ignoring the fact that sexual violence is endemic to all military operations everywhere (i mean obv gaza does not have an actual military so idk exactly what term to use, 'militaristic operation'? whatever).
what euroamerikans thousands of miles away "think" about what individuals and organizations in gaza who participated in the october 7 prisonbreak, is ultimately meaningless. we are not on the ground to evaluate tactics, or to evaluate alliances coalitions etc, or to engage in a criticism process of any "excesses" of the october 7 operation, or to determine that x or y segment of palestinian resistance is 'too problematic' for it to be "legitimate" for other palestinian individuals and groups to choose to work with them. it represents an extreme level of orientalism and chauvinism that over and over again people in this thread insist that actually we are #experts on all the material conditions of the concentration camp / open air prison that is gaza and of the palestinian liberation struggle, and it is our place to make declarations about what is Right and Wrong according to the allegedly universal values of euroamerikan humanism, an ideology that has been always allied with colonialism and imperialism.
the way in which u take this even further with "if hamas had 2x more resources then theyd commit 2x more violence" reveals even further how absurd the orientation of euroamerikan humanism is here. first of all, the question rly doesnt even make sense bc resources do not drop out of the sky, the material resources hamas does and doesnt have 'represent' various aspects of the conditions in gaza, if hamas were to acquire substantially more resources over x period of time there would be a cause or set of causes that enabled this to happen, relating to a change in the situation on the ground.
second, it obviously takes an "idealist" orientation, where the palestinian genocide and resistance efforts are understood not as a material history driven by various political and economic interests etc, but a bunch of "Good" or "Evil" actors who, by some sheer unexplainable coincidence, all happen to be located in palestine for whatever reason (and that these "Evil" actors would behave in the same way regardless of the material conditions or if they were somewhere else.) inevitably, and as we have seen over hundreds of years of the operations of euroamerikan humanism, the subsequent conclusion is that this "unexplainable" #Evil can only be attributed to the "Uncivilized" nature of the colonized, in this case of muslims and/or arabs, in opposition to the "Civilized" nature of white euroamerika. ofc this is all nonsense, the palestinian genocide did not begin randomly out of nowhere, the israeli state exists because it is a client state of us imperialism that carries out us interests in the region ~ altho it is not only this. israel additionally serves the ideological role of "solving the white world’s moral legitimacy crisis, which resulted from the Nazi genocide, outsourcing republican racism, and finally to be the weaponized wing of Western imperialism in the Arab world" (houria bouteldja, whites jews and us). nazism is reduced to an antisemitism that is severed from the nazi's overall white nationalist politics, which were the product of centuries of colonialism and normalization of genocides around the world; and then 'antisemitism' is projected onto colonized populations and used as a trojan horse to justify the continuation of imperialism that ofc was/is the actual source of nazism in the first place (but acknowledging this would interfere with us imperialist ambitions).
finally, "if hamas had x more resources then y" j overall reflects the deeply unserious orientation of euroamerikan humanism toward political violence. the palestinian genocide is not some abstract question of moral philosophy where our task is to roleplay as Anubis weighing souls if they are lighter than a feather or whatever, or to invent hypotheticals and speculate about what would happen if xyz which is unknowable (even if the hypothetical were 'well-defined' which as noted above this one is not).
meanwhile, the zionist state distributed pagers with bombs in them across the lebanese population and has exploded thousands of them. but lets talk nonsense about hypotheticals what if its israel 10 hamas 6 in the fourth quarter and hamas gets a level 2 shield upgrade (theres no specific material cause, it just descends from the heavens), what is hamas going to do on its next turn and should we #Condemn it.