A nomination thread would be cool, as the average UUer is pretty smart and since the Senate is decided in part by community involvement, a nominations thread should at least have symbolic significance.
Snunch said:I don't think a nomination thread would work. Lots of very good UU players don't ladder under their main account, so I wouldn't know who to nominate, and I'm willing to bet neither would most posters.
Pocket said:I like asdfrozen's idea - keeps the community more directly involved in the tiering process, while we have the Senate to intervene in certain emergency situations. I also agree with Heysup that Senate should not only be limited to veto ban decisions but also have the power to unanimously ban a mon if they find it necessary.
The only issue is the work load on Jabba and Suspect team in running both parties.
Fried Rhys said:let's go to pokemon-online
jas61292 said:Normally I respect what the decisions of the people in charge of this site, and am very appreciative of what they do. But throwing out a perfectly good system for absolutely no good reason (and if there is a good reason, not telling anyone) is ridiculous. I don't care if you run the site, a decision like this should be made through the community. Stupid moves like this that will just lose people's confidence in Somgon.
Breludicolo said:Jas, laddering meant nothing during suspect if you didn't get around top 15 or so. That's not saying much.
jas61292 said:Of course. If you weren't the very best, you didn't get anything. BUT, the very fact that the best got anything at all was a reason for all the players to strive to be the best. Without that, why should anyone strive to reach the top. What would be the point?
Insomniac. said:You don't see a difference between new players having a slim chance of directly participating and zero chance? Again, term periods with some form of election would make the senate a much better system.
Insomniac. said:You don't see a difference between new players having a slim chance of directly participating and zero chance? Again, term periods with some form of election would make the senate a much better system.
Heysup said:Intrinsic rewards are way more effective than extrinsic, so this is kind of a moot topic. The point of having a ladder is so that people have incentive. Having rankings is incentive enough for people to play.
Seeing as how we have had no real valid suggestions to replace the senate-style decision making, can we also stop talking about that? Talk about broken mons.