Robert Alfons said:So uh basically we can't express our creativity anymore? So um, couldn't we make another thread where us filthy plebeians can submit theorymons (no discussion in that thread) and then Overlord DTC decides whether or not it is worth discussing? That way you could filter out the silly ideas and provide intelligent discussion in this thread without limiting the creativity of the people.
Oh yeah, as for the theorymons right there: I really don't give a crap about Beartic, but Solrock and Lunatone seem like they could be great with Eviolite. They have good defensive movepools to work with, and unlike some walls actually pose decent offensive presence. Solrock would be the best of the two, as previously mentioned, due to the fact that he'd be able to handle special attackers with a lot of investment in his SpD, whereas Will-o-Wisp could still punish physical attackers trying to break through. It would definitely become a force to reckon with on stall teams.
I completely agree with you, for people a bit less technical or not so good players, a Theorymon thread should be open in the forum, not just irc, and that thread can be a source for this one if a good idea comes up. If that idea is good/DTC likes it, it can be expanded here in this thread. A theorymon thread where we can express our ideas, maybe bad, maybe not important for the metagame, or maybe broken, would not harm anyone and it can actually provide this thread with an interesting discussion topic sometimes.
tennisace said:They're all extremely irrelevant to the metagame though. Monferno is still frail/weak, Bellossom still doesn't have any coverage and is outclassed by literally every single offensive Grass-type (hell I'd even use Sunflora because at least it gets Earth Power), Scolipede needs Megahorn to get some 2hkos, and Phanpy is frail (your suggestion of Head Smash is silly because of the recoil taken and lack of recovery).
I had talked to DTC a few days ago when he posed a neat little change on IRC (I forget what it was though). The point of this reboot is to make one small tweak to Pokemon that have a lot of good characteristics already. Beartic has Swift Swim, high attack, and Ice-type STAB, which are all useful to rain teams looking to diversify. Solrock and Lunatone have unique typing, Levitate, (mostly) reliable healing moves, and some decent support moves (especially Will-o-Wisp on Solrock). The suggestions given don't add much or entirely change the way that the Pokemon is used, but give them a small but significant boost to their effectiveness.
Contrary Monferno can be good especially if it learns Hammer Arm, because with Eviolite, Close Combat and Slack Off it can be hard to beat (of course problems with Status, average Speed, and frailness even with Eviolite, but not a horrible Pokémon that doesn't deserve an analysis, you'd still prefer Combusken?) Quiver Dance Bellossom is a good way to improve it, and it has Sleep Powder, so a set consisting of Hidden Power X (probably Rock), Quiver Dance, Giga Drain and Sleep Powder is good, and you know, Timid Bellossom is faster than Jynx after a Quiver Dance, so it becomes one of the fastest sleep inducers in the tier after a boost. Steamroller... I didn't say "let's improve Steamroller for Scolipede!" I said that if it were more powerful and had a better distribution, it would be a nice move, and maybe Steamroller would become viable over Megahorn for Scolipede sometimes, due to perfect accuracy and neat flinch rate, but what I meant was that if Steamroller were better, which Pokémon would benefit more from learning it, not just Scolipede. And Phanpy. Did you read that after a Knock Off and a bit of residual damage, Misdreavus is KOed with a single Head Smash? Misdreavus's HP isn't very good, while Phanpy has 90 base HP, so I don't think the recoil would be that troublesome.