NOC Why is there a gun in my popcorn? GAME OVER SCUM WIN

Status
Not open for further replies.
i feel like blazade townreading me all game is something that should be making people go "hmm"

because up until like last night i feel like i've in no way warranted anything resembling faith

could be scum!blazade trying to keep a useless idler alive
 
Walrein me townreading you all game was on the understanding that DLE's scum meta involved a little more attempting to be "involved" by pinging people, plus the nice early town Yeti read was good. It's never been stable evidence but it has been strong enough for some amount of confidence
 
Wish smogon had MU-quality ISO software so building cases was easier zzz

I wanna look at everyone's interactions with flipped scum, probably Sam in particular since he was simultaneously alive for a long time and relatively inactive
 
Yeti said:
Blazade since ur here for once

where do u weigh in on this

defend yourself and rank the other 3 remaining players in order of shot and why

don't slouch on the why
Click to expand...

I mean you can call my play shit if you want I've been at least trying to point out interactions I find noteworthy and trying to dissolve shitty fights that get multiple people killed in a row. Scum don't have an agenda in this setup except to do exactly that and act like they care.

If I am shot now I will shoot Asek. It is impossible to read him based on tone for me and all game I've been looking for the shread of affirmative evidence I see from town Asek and not finding it. He is firmly in the PoE and has been for some time.

The other two of you are straight paranoia at this point. Yeti would have a good distancing game here and walrein would have to get distanced by Sam in the final hour. I think the evidence in a fight between you two would have to be against Walrein but that's like a 55-45 slant.

There isn't even the illusion of buddying anymore in this game. For copetent players it's difficult to latch onto something definitive
 
sam hasnt been mafia in a noc in legit years outside of Amnesiac which isn't really a conventional noc to determine his meta from

blazade is right in that asek's posts don't really contain anything that warrants an actual TOWN read, which has been my problem with sam tring asek, pretty hard, for quite a while. especially bc he had asek as a scumread early then inexplicably changed it.

asek hasnt been a strong scumread of mine but also not really a strong townread, just someone i've thought was a bad shot. but the people with a hard tr on asek don't really have much basis for it, imo.

regarding asek's point, i can't say much from asek's side but y'all KNOW sam gets into spats with literally everyone. i'd say he has a higher, much higher, rate of getting into pissing fights with his own teammates regardless of his being village or mafia.

i think that sam would either hard defend or hard bus his last teammate. he's not really a soft distance kind of mafia player lol...... he's gonna have a firm stance one way or another at that point in the game. the fact that his firmest stance was on tr asek (and scumread you) would put a viable shot order at 1. asek 2. walrein 3. blazade due to the relative ambivalence to blazade
 
asek was busy on vacation and easter so he has a relative lack of posts and blazade has been active lurking so he also has a lack of posts which does make it a bit hard to determinably say one over the other is scum without hardcore iso of the flipped scum.

i was way more confident that moody would flip scum (over fh) than i am in this scenario. i guess the noobtown boozle got me too hard
 
that was never my stance because i never thought it was true and i posited scenarios in which you guys were a tvt

i was almost certain moody was mafia. not that one of you had to be mafia. though it wouldn't have surprised me if you were, i was very surprised moody wasn't and the gd game didnt just end
 
or rather i never thought it HAD to be true; it could've well been true and i went through most of the game thinking it was but i have never said the moody/fh(/leet) dynamic absolutely had to have one scum in it

if you look at my posts you will note i've said your flips would only be indicative if one was actually mafia, making the other likely village. one of you flipping town had a lot less impact on the other being town or mafia.
 
my activity'll go down tonight because i have a major project to finish (and it's a group project so there'll be people to prevent my procrastination this time)

can get behind finishing by the weekend though, i'm gonna be on set which means very little posting
 
im waiting for fh to get home and answer my earlier posed question & doing rl stuff in the meantime

its a bit hard to ask blazade and asek what their shot order would be between each other because gee, i wonder. neither seems eager to build a case on anyone, either.. do they just not have a strong scumread at this point or..?

if ppl are gonna show up and engage in Some Discourse then lgi, if not tf are you doing if youre town and just sitting back waiting to be shot between?? cmon.

i want to see actual reasons and quoted or specified posts, asek has at least made an attempt towards that.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top