....so basically I took a look at everyone's posts and /mostly/ everything below is based off what they've been saying (or not saying), instead of how much they've been contributing. I also tried to remember my thought process during my previous readlist and I recall bandwagoning. lots of it. putting a stop to that rn.
Flyhn- In response to most people townreading him and/or making posts based off his own stuff, actually told them to stop buddying him/think for themselves. This is something only a town would say voluntarily I think. After dle brought up townlocking someone, I'd assume that a scum, if chosen as townlock, would immeadiately accept said position, because as long as one scum is never shot village can never win. Flyhn has actually raised objection to some others TRing him. Not something a scum would do, if you believe my sentence after "I think." Towny.
AG- Asked some good questions in the beginning, but after that it was, 'I think/don't think x is...', ':quotes post: this changes my views on x... ...' , and recently an iso of moody. conclusion of that was: don't shoot him, I think he'd act a fair bit different. why do you think so ag? my stance: basically fh (on a smaller scale) without the tunneling, and without dragging others into arguments. scum by policy, since I have fh SRed.
Josh- asking questions. lots of them. maybe you could do it, but I literally cannot formulate a real read based off /questions/ alone. maaybe policy town, since these questions are ones that proobably needed to be asked.
Me- o shit waddup
Hitmonleet- asking questions and explaining stuff for the better half of this thread. Some of his reasoning is dumb- for example, using the time between a question and a reply to townread yeti. wha? I have picked up no scumtells from him so far, excluding my tinfoil hat theory, so I'm putting him up as towny.
fcc- aside from his wallpost most of his posts are quite...reactionary. policy scum, same reason as ag.
DLE and moody- Its not all that early in the game, and at this rate I'm reading them as scum for doing jack shit.
US, yeti, fh: My reasons for scumreading them still stands.
asek and twin have been left off. at the time of writing I give literally zero shits about them and nothing they have written sticks out to me. maybe I'll do an iso of them.