No, it will turn blue like it completed the trade and then turn black. I've cloned enough to know the process. Although the thing is, your wifi would have to be the bad one to clone the vullaby, not his. So, I'm at a loss now. I don't think I'm on either side right now, so yeah, just let the mods decide. I really don't know what could have happened. Snoopy, if you had the vullaby in your party, then A. Silverknight is a liar and thief or B. your wifi was the bad one. Like I said, not on either side, so like you said, we can just let the mods decide. I just hope this is all a big misunderstanding.