NOC WikiMafia 2 Game Thread [Day 4]

[Peum]

Ok so I have to wait for the Innocent Child to die to do anything, meanwhile we have a ton of town KP running around freely

my role gets controlled every other night bruv

 

[ShyPebble]

Do you think it would be worth sharing who it casts doubt onto without going into specifics? no one has really given an elaborate claim except for tommy and peum so there are still a lot of holes that can be explained by something other than a lie

Des

 

[Peum]

who tf redirected me into psy

 

[Tommy]

What's the level of weird that it would be could to claim then? I'm not trying to be difficult I just wanna make sure I'm not neglecting to share something that could be helpful and then being told it was actually bad to share after. Like sharing that I was linked to two people and could die led to Peum kind of being Town confirmed now Ig so that helped in the long run, but at the time it was bad to post

If your claim is going to make us all go “yes this guy is probably mafia we will now vote him” you claim

If it’s like “huh I wonder why that happened, weird” or it’s “oh so this is why this is happening” you don’t claim, unless those things are going to lead into someone being obviously town or mafia

 

[Psypsypsypsypsythe]

relatedly, i think shypebbles uncertainty feels very town. the initial loverized claim and asking for advice here feels like it wouldnt happen from a new scum player. we can say its coached but scum teams never really care about coaching that thoroughly in my experience + will want you to post naturally as opposed to reading a script

 

[Tommy]

That’s true

 

[ShyPebble]

Okay then I probably won't share, I don't think cause we don't really know how des's role works

 

[Psypsypsypsypsythe]

do you think if pulsar was town mafia wouldve tried to misflip her by now

 

[Tommy]

Maybe, but then if you have 3 town wagons, if dbd is town, on d3 you don’t need to push any other options yet anyways, so like there’s no need to

 

[Psypsypsypsypsythe]

i do think its important we start solving through the bystanders of pulsar/phoopes/airc/shypebble/maybe a fairy alongside lhf like genisu and des because theres scum in here for sure and its so many players that we just arent really reading or talking about

 

[ShyPebble]

I think phoopes is town, I am wary of airc, and idk how I feel about a fairy or pulsar anymore.

 

[Tommy]

I think phoopes is town, I am wary of airc, and idk how I feel about a fairy or pulsar anymore.

Why do you think phoopes is town?

 

[Psypsypsypsypsythe]

i was willing to buy the meta reading people did of pulsar about how her talking about mechanics was town for her (when she helped discuss the n1 inconsistencies) but she hasnt done a single thing in the game since then

i cant get a read on airc at all and phoopes is constantly pinging me but just not at the forefront of my brain

i think a fairy is towny but ??

 

[ShyPebble]

Because there was no reason they had to claim part of their role D1 to figure out all of the Psy things and they were truthful about using their ability twice without HH having to come in and claim his role beforehand

 

[Tommy]

A fairy is the towniest of the 7 I don’t townread but she also is off the back of a really impressive mafia game so I’m not giving her any freebies

 

[Tommy]

Because there was no reason they had to claim part of their role D1 to figure out all of the Psy things and they were truthful about using their ability twice without HH having to come in and claim his role beforehand

I don’t exactly recall this but seems valid reasoning

 

[ShyPebble]

Also, a role that ensures your action goes through without being redirected seems goated on the maf side, and I don't see them using that on Psy the first day unless they're mafia together and Psy is town.

 

[Psypsypsypsypsythe]

i admittedly dont know why if phoopes is scum he would target me n1

 

[ShyPebble]

I typed too fast... Psy is town to me.

 

[a fairy]

A fairy is the towniest of the 7 I don’t townread but she also is off the back of a really impressive mafia game so I’m not giving her any freebies

i would love a freebie i feel like im floundering here

 

[Psypsypsypsypsythe]

Also, a role that ensures your action goes through without being redirected seems goated on the maf side, and I don't see them using that on Psy the first day unless they're mafia together and Psy is town.

im town?

 

[Tommy]

I’m going to retire for the night on that note

I think 7 town I have now are
Me
Saber
Psy
Flanders
Peum
Dbd
Pebble

Probably in that order but all are pretty towny generally id not vote any

 

[Psypsypsypsypsythe]

also kinda feels like people dont generate enough reads on flandrs in comparison to the amount he talks. a brash player like that you would expect to be a talking point but hes kind of just not

 

[ShyPebble]

That's why Phoopes is Town for me. AirC claimed something D1 with little to no reasoning saying Realiti and I visited the same person on the first day. It was unprompted, and just seemed like trying to biggie back on all the people being called town for claiming things to figure out what happened with the neighborhood, except the information had nothing to do with any of the situations going on at the time, and didn't really add anything to the discussion aside from the fact that they shared it without being asked. This was also something AirC was townread for in a previous game, so I could see them as scum trying to recreate the same thing without actually being helpful.

 

[ShyPebble]

Flandrs is like uncontestedly town in my eyes