-
Welcome to Smogon! Take a moment to read the Introduction to Smogon for a run-down on everything Smogon, and make sure you take some time to read the global rules.
-
Congrats to the winners of the 2023 Smog Awards!
Official XY OU Suspect Process, Round 5, Voting
- Thread starter haunter
- Start date
- Status
Aegislash: Do Not Ban
Aegislash: Ban
Aegislash: Ban
Aegislash: Ban
Alright, we had 93 total voters, meaning we needed 56 bans to ban Aegislash (to get the minimum 60% required).
We've crossed the threshold required for a ban, with Haunter / Gloating left to vote. Based on post history / forum activity, it is probably safe to say both will vote Do Not Ban (but I'm obviously not officially tallying until they vote).
That said, because all of
a.) this was an extraordinarily close vote
b.) so many votes changed (most from OU -> Uber, though there are a few are considering Uber -> OU)
c.) Haunter did say Sunday night
d.) If both haunter and gloating vote OU, the decision could be swung with a number less than the number of people who changed votes
I am absolutely 100% NOT comfortable with calling this right away (as we have in previous tests).
However, right away doesn't mean we have to wait forever, so I will call this 24 hours after this post.
We've crossed the threshold required for a ban, with Haunter / Gloating left to vote. Based on post history / forum activity, it is probably safe to say both will vote Do Not Ban (but I'm obviously not officially tallying until they vote).
That said, because all of
a.) this was an extraordinarily close vote
b.) so many votes changed (most from OU -> Uber, though there are a few are considering Uber -> OU)
c.) Haunter did say Sunday night
d.) If both haunter and gloating vote OU, the decision could be swung with a number less than the number of people who changed votes
I am absolutely 100% NOT comfortable with calling this right away (as we have in previous tests).
However, right away doesn't mean we have to wait forever, so I will call this 24 hours after this post.
It's been a little over 24 hours since my last post, and no votes have changed...
Aegislash is banned with 57 ban / 35 do not ban / 1 pussy ass abstention for a 62% ban supermajority.
This change will be reflected on our tournaments and ladders asap.
Thanks and look forward to the next test!
Aegislash is banned with 57 ban / 35 do not ban / 1 pussy ass abstention for a 62% ban supermajority.
This change will be reflected on our tournaments and ladders asap.
Thanks and look forward to the next test!
- Status