Why is it tragic that Holmes will never make the HOF? Shaun Alexander, Edgerrin James and Tiki Barber probably wont make the HOF either and I dont see why Holmes has a stronger case than them.
It would be more tragic if Terrell Davis never makes the HOF.
Bettis will make it, though Im not really a big fan of his. He was much more of a stat compiler than dominate and his SB victory shouldnt mean that much when he nearly fumbled it away and he was just a short yardage back at the time. Gore has no shot...
People like you not getting it is why it is tragic, thanks for proving my point as simply as fucking possible?
Priest did more in 3 years than basically almost any RBs do in 7-10. Although Barber was a great receiving guy, he was a bad goal line back & a fumble machine. Alexander never caught the ball, and is closer though. Holmes had to way too soon walk away from the sport because of a neck injury (shades of what could have happened with P. Manning), iirc neither of the other two walked away for any reason besides age. Holmes is also the only one to prove his talent on two teams, so he seems the least likely to just be the beneficiary of just a great OL.
Edgerrin James does not even deserve to be in the conversation. Sure his total yardage in his early seasons seemed "exciting" out the gate, but out of all these guys, he was the only one who was low y/a and for the amount of rushing attempts has by far the worst TDs. Total yard statistics are meaningful when they do have a number like at least 4.3 y/a attached, or
maybe if they theoretically helped lead to Super Bowl wins (a much more up in the air argument), and come on HoF you just have to have a few 4.8+ y/a seasons by now with how much stronger and faster players are in the last 20 years. No one is going to say he was not a good RB, but HoF is a different conversation.
Terrell Davis not making the HoF would be tragic, agreed, I was just generalizing about "the most recent generation of RBs" which unfortunately because of the injury he kind of missed. Based on the brief amount of time & "lol anyone could rush on that Denver team!11", I do think he might never make it in. I mean if they let him in they might have to let in guys like Portis! etc is the type of logic they could go with.