Star Wars Mafia

GP: It is just a joke... Oh and yes it is day time. So who is this games leader/Toothache/DE who is pretending to be a student/second Tooth?

And yeah, the last one was a joke.... :)
 
Well if it was up to me I would lynch Obi since I think he is very likely a mafia... I mean Obi always dies. Why would a random like El_B be killed > Obi, who is clearly a much more of a threat.

I could be wrong, and do to my mafia game history I dont want to start a lynch and turn out to lynch what cold very well be one of our most valuable rebels.

So I will leave this for someone else to decide. I am too afraid to start any lynch this game unless I know 100% that person is mafia.
 
that logic is stupid.

obi may be in faction #1 but that doesn't stop people in faction #2 from killing him. i'm not protecting obi but just putting this out there because if you're targeting him like that then you will end up targeting anyone with half a brain in this game.

this may simply be because the mafia didn't want to make the game completely shitty by removing all the good players from it or something of the sort. or maybe even a personal vendetta against el_b. stop making it an issue for no reason.
 
I know it was a poor reason and I stated so in the post before my last post. That is why I also stated that he could also easily be a Rebel.

It could be like you said, and the mafia is getting rid of the "new" players and leaving the interesting ones for later. Or, at least one of the mafia factions is doing so, because Dak isn't really new to mafia and he was killed.
 
There could also be a vigilante (since we seem to be trying to make the games go by faster), and the bodyguard protected Obi, so there were 2 kills instead of three. So Kira has some kind of point, but it would be stupid to act on it.
 
chewbacca.jpg
 
i think it was the "my mom caught me jerkin it" which then got edited to 15 other titles

Thats stretching it a little far JimBob.
Click to expand...
a bit far, but it's still somewhat plausible. When I played roles that were alone (werewolf for example), I always assumed that the regular mafia would go after the good players, and I would go after someone random. If the vigilante followed the same mindset as me, he might have killed this el_B

then again, you might be right, and I'm just dumb
 
Random?! Well then let me lynch gsumbreon... Come on, a random bandwagon? That is a pretty stupid idea. A drop in numbers is a bad thing even this early in the game... you have to be sure the lynch victim is a good one and not an ally.

Plus if anything I know how valuable a bad lynch can be for a mafia since last game every single lynch and kill meant the difference between losing and winning.
 
The problem now is that we have nothing to go upon, apart from Evan, and i'm not inclined to trust that statement this early in the game.

So... let's wait for the inspector?
 
i'd actually not be lynching the person claiming he was luke skywalker turn one.

obviously if there is an inspector they could argue against that fact but i dont see anyone doing that.
 
Ok well how is Hip ALMOST 100% sure?... why does he need the bg to pm him so badly? Why did he try and shift blame to evan so early?

All those things are common mafia type behaviors...

I just feel more inclined to trust evan. Hip is acting to mafia-ish.

I will not take back my vote. You guys have to decide whether to follow me and vote out Hip, or follow Hip and vote out evan.

I think those should be the two up for nomination tonight... Yes I know it doesnt have to be two people, but if Hip is actually telling the truth than evan is mafia.

If evan is telling the truth then Hip is likely mafia, and even if he isnt mafia I doubt he is Luke Skywalker.
 
Uhh.. I would like to point out that I dont want you to vote out evan at this point. Hence not voting for him. So you can follow Kira and lynch me, or you can follow someone else and lynch someone else.

[edit] - When I said waiting on PM, I was waiting on a PM from GP to tell me what happened at night.

Some more points. The BG hasnt PMed me. I had no expectation of being PMed by the bodyguard. It would be an extremely risky thing for the BG to do, however, I know that I am clean, so I also know that it would be a beneficial thing for the BG to do. Also I know that it would be a beneficial thing for everyone else on the rebel side to do. It was intended to be a hint that a couple of people actually did catch on to..

I never shifted any blame to evan. There was no blame to shift. I just accused evan for acting shady. I dont remember saying almost 100% sure, but if I did it was just for colour. If I was so damn sure I would have lynched him already.

And as for claiming Luke Skywalker, it would be a pretty stupid move. If you are going to false claim, then it probably isnt a good idea to claim someone that is so likely to be in the game somewhere. Then you have to deal with other people claiming your role and potentially dying and exposing you without any doubt whatsoever.

Also a message for the inspector: you targeted someone on the rebel side. They have been in touch with me. What we plan to do to get in touch with you is wait to see if anyone else refutes this claim, if not, then you can PM the person you inspected.

Have a nice day.
 
Hipmonlee said:
Uhh.. I would like to point out that I dont want you to vote out evan at this point. Hence not voting for him. So you can follow Kira and lynch me, or you can follow someone else and lynch someone else.

Have a nice day.
Click to expand...

Yes, because clearly we should follow any other person besides someone voting for you.

I wouldn't be surprised if you had a mafia go and say "lynch blank"

According to you we can either follow me, or this new person. You would obviously try and use your "role" to get people to follow the random one saying "this is the best lead we got"

I really think you are mafia. If you are not then you acted a lot like a mafia.


edit: Your message to the inspector... how can anyone refute that claim? Nobody knows who was inspected, or what side hey were on. Unless GP copied the roles out of HP mafia, the inspector should know what role the person he inspected is.


I think it would be better for the inspector to inspect Hip instead. We still dont know if Hip is truly clean just because someone supposedly contacted him from the rebel side.

I mean I had students contacting me, that didnt make me a student last game.
 
Which mafia player in any previous game has claimed a role on the first day?

As for evan, I will give you some mafia playing advice. If you havent got any information, try accusing someone, and look at how they defend themselves. In the case of evan, I got a deadpan response. It is probably the best way to deal with it, but then I have a second option, and that is to increase the pressure to see how he responds. So I posted it on the forums, and then had another go at interrogating him.

I picked evan mostly because he was there at the time. I still think he is probably a better lynch than picking someone at random, but I am not convinced a better option will not surface during discussions.

Have a nice day.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top