I've looked through the first posts and the last few pages and didn't find anyone mentioning the same problem so here goes:
Version: 9.81
Trying to breed female DW ability shiny eevee (BW international, everstone, flawless parents)
Using the 5th Gen Shiny Egg Tab: It doesn't really matter which Pokemon I am trying to breed. I was successful in hitting one seed (C94F270EB07A07E6) and getting the exact Pokemon the Reporter told me (frame 84, bold, female, perfect IVs) but it wouldn't be shiny.
In fact all the PIDs that come up in the Shiny Egg Tab as results aren't shiny. Also the frame doesn't match with the frame shown when I enter the full seed into the Reporter main window. If I look for the PID that matches the one that came up in the Shiny Egg Window, it doesn't show up as "!!!" either.
Is it some kind of misunderstanding on my end? But since I happen to get the exact result as the Reporter, it seems like haven't done anything wrong. It's just the PIDs that pop up in the Shiny Egg Window aren't exactly shiny PIDs.
Here's an example screenshot:
http://img585.imageshack.us/img585/6011/unled1ji.jpg
(It says BW and not BW International here because I tried searching for non-international ones but they're not shiny either)