Please also remove Starly and Psyduck, and possibly Azurill. I know that you said before Azurill moving down gets people out of the woodwork, so I'd understand if that's a no, but Azurill is really kinda bad.
Starly is pretty much completely outclassed. Sure, it hits pretty hard, but it's also slow for how frail it is and it doesn't hit that hard. It also murders itself incredibly fast. If it got Close Combat like its evolution then yeah, it could stay, but I can't find any reason to use it over Taillow or Fletchling or Doduo at any time.
Psyduck I'm kind of completely clueless about why it's here. Is it because of Cloud Nine? Does it have some incredibly unique set that lets it beat grass types? Is it just sneaking by because it's so bad people don't realize it's there? I am actually at a loss.
Mankey and Skiddo can stay, for the reasons cityfolk listed. They both have usable niches and can work on a serious team, and Mankey's original nomination post is still applicable. They both work, although Skiddo is worse.
Other things to consider in D- Paras and Shroomish are pretty bad, I've never seen someone use them successfully. Smoochum is something that I can see staying, but also going. It's just so frail and not very fast, although ice STAB is hard to find.
Starly is pretty much completely outclassed. Sure, it hits pretty hard, but it's also slow for how frail it is and it doesn't hit that hard. It also murders itself incredibly fast. If it got Close Combat like its evolution then yeah, it could stay, but I can't find any reason to use it over Taillow or Fletchling or Doduo at any time.
Psyduck I'm kind of completely clueless about why it's here. Is it because of Cloud Nine? Does it have some incredibly unique set that lets it beat grass types? Is it just sneaking by because it's so bad people don't realize it's there? I am actually at a loss.
Mankey and Skiddo can stay, for the reasons cityfolk listed. They both have usable niches and can work on a serious team, and Mankey's original nomination post is still applicable. They both work, although Skiddo is worse.
Other things to consider in D- Paras and Shroomish are pretty bad, I've never seen someone use them successfully. Smoochum is something that I can see staying, but also going. It's just so frail and not very fast, although ice STAB is hard to find.