FireWizard312 said:Because it has no reason to exist and goes directly against a suspect vote, as well as the wishes of the general playerbase. People don't want a ban on Tera, so I see no reason to implement a tier with one. I'm not a fan of Tera, but the push for a Teraless ladder is really frustrating to see when people are using it as a way to still get the results they wanted even though a suspect test didn't go their way.
Isn't it a bit disingenuous to say that this is only about pushback from last survey? You keep trying to paint this as a position of sore losers rather than acknowledge the fact that this isn't entirely new. Let's not pretend like a Tera-less ladder in some form hasn't been a suggestion or request for a long time now. There is a type of data you could collect that hasn't been available so far for the
entire gen, not just since last survey.
The reasons why we didn't split OU into two separate ladders were absolutely valid. But an OM is different. Why should any OM exist by your criteria? But they do.
Furthermore, it has already been brought up that said data wouldn't wouldn't necesarrily even be anti-Tera. So the claim that it is just so anti-Tera people could get their way doesn't really add up. I don't think there are many, if any, folks actually thinking this way. But if they were, it would be incredibly misguided and not at all thought through. The whole narrative of it just being sore losers who are trying to manipulate the system feels like a massive group character assassination attempt. How would you take it if I said the resistance was just pro-Tera people who were afraid of what we might find?
FireWizard312 said:We didn't create an unofficial metagame for a OU without Kyurem, we didn't create an unofficial metagame for an OU with Chien Pao, and both of those would've had more support that a Teraless ladder.
This has been covered on here before, but Tera is the generational mechanic. Not a pokemon. There are obvious differences.
And you keep talking about support. But maybe survey support would have been higher if this had been earlier in the gen when there was more engagement on the subject? The current meta is not even all that well liked, according the the most recent survey you keep citing. But what is the root cause or the optimal solution? There is some disagreement.
It seems most folks would prefer to ban what is seen as problem pokemon. Then Kyurem avoided a ban. And I'm personally fine with that, but it is still a massive threat. Now Gouging Fire may be picking up anti-ban momentum. So then how do you fix the meta nobody likes if you can't ban most of what is seen as problematic? I realize that is a big if, and I may be getting too ahead of myself here, but we could be heading that way. In that case, we would either need to find a new solution or just live with a meta most people didn't seem to like much. Popularity sure can be ironic.