boop
The team is the same Cloyster / Gliscor / Chansey "Bermuda triangle" from my
recent-ish 787 run in the Maison, and me giving Subway a proper whirl is in a sense kind of unexpected; I genuinely never really played it other than defeating Ingo + Emmet like a decade ago on White 2 with Jumpman's Suizorus and R Inanimate's Ludicolo rain and pretty much permanently abandoning those streaks at 49 after because bleh copycat teams in the same facility (this run is even on Black 2 since I like my name here better...), due to a combination of Unova being possibly my least played pre-Switch generation and the Maison being right there when I wanted to try things out with mostly the same opposition but a wider range of options on my end. Other than my 116 Suizomence run in Platinum's Tower to scoop up in-game achievements and also get my black Trainer card I've just never had a reason to go back in time before gen 6, but with a lot of my playing this year being partly fuelled by wanting to also play non-Maison facilities I also was gonna take an excuse to play older gens if one materialised. So, there are two important bits of context to this run happening.
- My Maison run; it had not escaped my notice that this team was directly backportable into here, and especially with the Subway being similar setwise but different mechanically therefore interesting to check out by default that was a gauntlet I could hardly justify not picking up after having thrown it down myself.
- Old RNG adventures when I learned how those things worked in 2014/2015 where I ended up doing a full gen 4 legendary gamut "just in case" but also ended up doing the same thing for certain rare old tutor moves; think Sucker Punch Hitmontop that I've used on some random triples trophy runs, but the real prizes are in Emerald, where I already got Counter Gengar and Soft-Boiled Cleffa a decade ago and Counter Skarmory and JEJUNUM last year. A particularly big fish though is Seismic Toss Chansey, which thankfully was given some pretty reasonable accessibility in gen 6 but before that time was pretty up there for one of the most complicated Pokemon to obtain on-cart period, and I *did* actually want one of those to have my bases covered in case I ever wanted to try out Battle Pike or Battle Pyramid, where in my noob brain Blissey seems close to mandatory for beginner teams that don't want to make do with Miltank, or get more serious about certain gen 4 facilities. I tried working on it earlier but got scared and sidetracked out of it multiple times since having to hatch a 10k steps Egg to verify every attempt at a 60fps reset plus having to pull it off three times or so to finish the IV breeding chain is just straight up masochist, and needless to say I'd already lost lots of steam after Gengar and Cleffa. Regardless, long story short, a couple months ago I finally got that Chansey done for real after it had technically been on my todo for like 9 years. Now having it finished period was of course nice for the challenge and all from some sort of trophy case pov, but ultimately this is still a battling game and even if they weren't spent on it at all consistently 9 years is quite a lot of time to get nothing out of it than just bragging rights; so, a place to actually use it and by extension a proper end goal for all that time spent breeding it is its own good to help me not question my life choices as much. It was not Pike or Pyramid or Arcade, but this still was an actual good use case to give this Chansey actual playtime and I kind of was obligated to go for it.
I've commented some more on the teambuilding process in the Maison post, but in short it follows a largely similar pattern as Peterko's Cloyster/Garchomp/Suicune except provides a slightly different take. Gliscor was the first Pokemon added to complement Cloyster, since a Ground-type is all but mandatory when leading with the biggest Thunderbolt (and by extension parahax) bait in existence and unlike in BDSP it's an actual Pokemon here, and while not quite as good at this as Mega Gyarados on Marathon on account of still not wanting to lose its Sash when setting up on weakened enemies, Cloyster would still get some +6 setups in happy matchups when Gliscor could stall enemies down to just Rest or a setup move or whatever. With Gliscor taking the Garchomp role, I also needed something in the Suicune position (bulky Water counter), and without the momentum Garchomp brings to the table Cloyster + Gliscor additionally left a hole to certain special attackers (think Starmie, and also Latios/Latias in only very moderately compromised board positions), which Chansey was a natural fit to patch up. Let's get the sets out of the way first and save the real interesting stuff, the comparison with the Maison, for after. I'll try not to repeat too much from my Maison post but still hope to keep this writeup self-contained.
:bw/cloyster:
Davy Jones (Cloyster) @ Focus Sash
Ability: Skill Link
Nature: Naughty
EVs: 252 Atk / 12 SpA / 244 Spe
IVs: 31/31/31/31/31/31
- Icicle Spear
- Surf
- Shell Smash
- Rock Blast
cloyster
The classic set, where sweeping with boosted Skill Link Icicle Spear and not caring about Sash/Sturdy or Yache Berry is the dream and we've known since Peterko's days that Naughty Surf is the optimal Water move over Adamant Razor Shell because of the perfect accuracy and, in some cases, the "mixed" coverage. The EV spread can't exactly be made less uncomplicated than this; a single Speed point cut is all that's feasible in order to keep the jump on Terrakion-2 after a boost, and Gyarados-1's existence also makes it actively superior even in the face of "why not just go for the extra Speed ties when 4 vs 12 SpA is a massive wash anyways". Underspeeding Gyarados by a single point removes the incentive it may have had to click Thunder Wave, and when having to click Smash on an unknown Gyarados set, relative Speed tiers instantly confirming if this Dragon Dance set is 1 or 3 (needs to be taken out by +1 Spear right away) or 4 (needs an extra Smash) is extremely handy as well. A potential tweak is to move two more points into Special Attack from Attack to guarantee the OHKO on Chandelure with +2 Surf, but that only comes into play anyways if it comes out second after Cloyster defeats the opposing lead with a single Smash not to mention this also narrows down the roster of potential threatening 3rd mons a lot, and cutting Attack on a main sweeper makes me nervous about overlooking any less straightforward situations on mass calcs (same reason why I don't believe in 4/244/4/4 spreads).
Rock Blast is the perpetual elephant in the room because of its awful accuracy, and there are a number of niche options to consider over it. I ran Explosion in BDSP but this is not an option I recommend without knowing full teams in advance; Substitute can be used to escape from Perish Song and at least is slightly more sane than in Maison with old Mismagius-4 existing though its issue of embracing a stalemate and effective Cloyster sack versus Lapras over a mostly-assured win remains; Protect is not half bad for messing with HJK users (notably Medicham3) and Fake Out revenge killers; and Torment can make positioning versus wallbreakers a lot easier but this team is for the most part fully capable of just killing or neutering them anyways, and Protect into unboosted Spear would be a better way of dealing with lead Medicham-3 anyways.
We are still sticking with Rock Blast though, because overall the other options are mostly based in blind inaccurate move avoidance and lose more valuable targets than they gain. The first thing to be aware of is that the list of genuine targets is short, since yes if there is any other reliable way to deal with them at all then it's by default better, so e.g. Volcarona is Chansey food instead and is just not too much of a factor in this argument; however, battles don't stop at the lead matchup, and things may come in second on a +2 Cloyster with a broken Sash that goes down to +2 Rock Blast but nothing else. Now yes of course even in a scenario where Cloyster falls I can still beat them with Gliscor + Chansey, but they might still struggle with the mystery 3rd enemy, and all that dropping Rock Blast for a random utility move accomplishes in this scenario is increase the odds of them having to face this one down alone from 10% to 100%, and with the Subway AI's increased unpredictability compared to the Maison (no more switching 1 HP Cloyster out for Gliscor into Regice's "telegraphed" Electric move) it may not be too wise to look for cute lines to avoid using Rock Blast on backups at all cost.
90% accuracy is also deceptive, since targets where you genuinely get only a single shot are rare if not nonexistent, and if you have multiple chances then that also boosts effective accuracy to 99%. I won't break down the list of actual lead targets as thoroughly as I did in the Maison post, but obvious overlapping cases include Weavile and Vanilluxe, which resist Icicle Spear and have Taunt to potentially either stop boosts outright or limit me to just one, and while Chansey can and will certainly beat them it's once again Taunt that leaves it in a pretty compromised position there. Infernape is another, since Subway AI's absurd preference towards Encore means I can actually safely click Smash on this turn 1 on this, and even if Rock Blast misses after I can simply take it out with Icicle Spear after the CC drops. The alternative would be taking the Maison line of Gliscor, which "works" but also leaves me open to just losing Gliscor to a Blaze Flare Blitz crit and best case scenario means I end up with a non-Subbed and heavily chipped Gliscor. On top of that, there is also Subway-specific dynamics in the form of heavily increased number of Trainers with set ambiguity, who may run that one set that I can't easily afford to give momentum (think Ice Workers leading with Beartic where you don't exactly want to see set 3 click SD on the switch out) so I "have to" go for the +2 Rock Blast just to cover for that one. It's not limited to lead matchups either; think Pilots or starter breeders, who are much more likely to force Smash + Spear as a middle ground turn 1 play and by extension are also much more likely to put me in similar situations where Cloyster has nothing better to do anymore anyway than just trying to simplify the battle with +2 Rock Blast. Overall yes you should always look for a different plan A in cases where you'd want to click Rock Blast (and in most cases you can find those as well), but Rock Blast still adds upside in the narrow-ish range of matchups where there is nothing better, and without it you're mostly just giving up most of those entirely for even more narrow gain.
:bw/gliscor:
Nemo (Gliscor) @ Toxic Orb
Ability: Poison Heal
Nature: Impish
EVs: 212 HP / 4 Atk / 36 Def / 164 SpD / 92 Spe
IVs: 31/31/31/10/31/31
- Earthquake
- Toxic
- Protect
- Substitute
gliscor
The Gliscor set that plays an all-round role where it also takes down enemies on its own and not just a pure PP staller. Everyone knows what this thing does, namely use SubProtect to stall down enemies with Toxic or stall out dangerous moves for teammates to take advantage of, with Earthquake hitting almost everything that isn't affected by Toxic and also letting Gliscor take down a lot of slower enemies while maintaing a Sub (e.g. things that can't break its Sub in one hit or let it get free Subs on status moves). The EV spread is simply recycled from the Maison run; the Speed still holds (notably Mismagius4 so it doesn't outspeed my entire team if it shows up at a bad time), and while the most specific bulk target used (Barbaracle4) is currently hiding away in the future, the overall angle of "mixed bulk with slightly physical lean because mixed plays most self-sufficiently but I also have a Chansey right here" is still valid. One change worth considering is adding an extra Speed point to avoid the tie with +1 Emboar3 and force it into another Flame Charge, but at that point you end up tying with Emboar4 which is arguably worse so you'd have to go even further, and I didn't really want to deal with the additional changing variables of extra bulk cuts. There is not exactly a whole lot to explain otherwise, so I'll go ahead and say a few words about Earthquake versus Bulldoze. This team in general does need the more self-sufficient Toxic Gliscor set over the pure PP staller that is Bulldoze + Double Team with Cloyster not being a good all eggs in one basket sweeper, but while in Maison I've panned the option of Bulldoze + Toxic before on account of being worst of both worlds (i.e. Bulldoze's lack of power compared to Earthquake being self-defeating when you're using a Gliscor that wants to also kill things on its own), I have considered Bulldoze more seriously here, mainly because of old crits. I'll say more about this later, but think Arcanine, which you're more or less forced to just take out with Earthquake right away just to not play with the odds of being insta-knocked out of Substitute range, with major headache consequences, and where the Speed drop taking this scenario out of the equation entirely would help a lot. Still though the Speed drop is also fundamentally at odds with "slower Gliscor is better because it has better odds of winning with an intact Sub", and here too Earthquake's extra power is not something to gloss over. While cases like Toxicroak are a bit more shrug because the Speed drop allows you to functionally "OHKO" them with Bulldoze as well, you outspeed Bisharp regardless and it's enough of a headache without getting supercharged by Defiant, and that one is not the only case of the power being important on slower targets. Two examples that come to mind right away are Belly Drummers Thick Fat Hariyama4, which is put pretty cleanly in Earthquake range after +2 Icicle Spear and a Belly Drum, and Snorlax4, which also is a guaranteed Earthquake KO after Belly Drum + Sitrus Berry + clicking Double-Edge into Sub nine times. Hariyama is pretty bs to face for this team either way tbh, but Snorlax in particular is solved as cleanly as it gets this way and would be pretty awful without access to good burst damage to finish it off. There's more where that came from too but I never have a lot of them handy off the top of my head when I'm not here on a mission to prove a point of Earthquake > Bulldoze or whatever.
:bw/chansey:
Symphony (Chansey) @ Eviolite
Ability: Natural Cure
Nature: Bold
EVs: 252 HP / 252 Def / 4 Spe
IVs: 31/0/30/24/30/31
- Seismic Toss
- Toxic
- Soft-Boiled
- Growl
chansey
Slightly imperfect IVs because my Emerald kept hitting alternate spreads when I was on the final step in the breeding chain, and this was "good enough" when I wanted to just get it over with after all those years. The 0 Attack IV is a nice bonus that of course is not in any universe more important than the defensive IVs, but it is funny to see confusion self-hits do literally 3 HP damage. In any case, this is the Growl Chansey set invented by VaporeonIce when he first showed the world team Growl / team Aegimensey, and its purpose is threefold or maybe even fourfold: of course it helps make Chansey impenetrable to physical attacks on top of its natural pseudo-immunity to special attacks, it also lets other teammates take advantage of weakened physical attackers, and it provides a "skip turn" button with nearly infinite PP for stalling down enemies in general. A special use case is pretty much fully neutering Curse boosters, which you simply sit in front of and spam down with Growl. On VaporeonIce's team it could do the same thing with Dragon Dance users, which is a lot sketchier here without Salamence's Intimidate and the additional scare factor of old crits, but lines like this are still potential options to keep in mind depending on board state. It was a pretty natural choice when I decided to pair Chansey with Gliscor; the main issue to address with Chansey is the momentum loss it leaves the team open when it KOes an opposing lead by itself, where I think something like Substitute is kind of a half-measure since it only provides a single extra free turn which may mean little to nothing in the face of an actual hard counter or dangerous booster, but Growl's ability to actually support teammates opens up a ton more potential lines of play. You know how it goes, physical attacker that might be able to break Gliscor comes out versus Chansey, Growl once or twice, and oops Gliscor handles it fine. Iirc in the Maison post I said that I kind of overestimated this particular line of play, but now that I've had to dig deeper into the team's toolkit I've once again come around on that; think using it to allow Gliscor to maintain a Sub versus a moderate-strength physical attacker, which is of course great both for preserving Gliscor's PP and for better positioning against whatever comes out next.
The set shouldn't need much explanation otherwise and a lot of things I could say would be detailed repeating of the Maison report, but I should say that I have reconsidered if I truly "need" Toxic due to a few changes in playstyle that mean I've been using it less and the fact that old crits and freeze hax really do suck enough to consider Substitute on enemies that have been weakened enough. In the Maison post I also mentioned that Toxic doubles as de facto crit protection, since once the enemy is on the counter you're just Soft-Boiled spamming your way through crits anyways, but while that's certainly still the case to an extent, with the lunacy that is old crits I'm a lot less confident in this take here. Fact of the matter remains though that Chandelure and Volcarona still exist, with their ability to boost all over Chansey that's actually even worse in this generation, plus Flame Body and Will-O-Wisp for a significant artificial extra power boost on their attacks. Yuck!
That should explain everyone's toolkits properly, and from an overall synergy pov the goal is obviously to defeat the lead while putting myself in the optimal position for any backups, where PP stalling of dangerous moves is a very important and common angle. This can go extremely far, and tools you have include Chansey's Growl, Gliscor's Sub/Protect, and switch-stalls where sheer bulk alone goes a super long way of course but immunities also help a lot, allowing Gliscor + Chansey to stall out Ghost / Ground or Ghost / Electric move users like Golurk and Drifblim without breaking a sweat. This capability is so strong that, barring certain gen 5-specific AI quirks like them preferring to use Rest before Toxic on an already statused enemy, you can for the most part just keep an eye out for sets with "stale" moves that can't touch Cloyster, like Substitute, Fake Out, recovery moves, Helping Hand, and (as long as they don't let them break through Gliscor or Chansey during the stall, like Swords Dance) boosting moves; as long as a set has one of those, odds are that you can just stall it out of everything else and set Cloyster up to +6 with an intact Sash.
Overall, the rough priority ranking of optimal lead matchup outcomes is as follows:
- Cloyster at +6 with Sash intact;
- Gliscor with a Sub;
- Cloyster outspeeds and OHKOes the opposing lead with an unboosted attack;
- Any Cloyster setup with a broken Sash;
- Gliscor KOes the opposing lead without a Sub;
- Chansey KOes the opposing lead;
- Gliscor KOes the opposing lead at the cost of a lot of Sub/Protect PP;
- Cloyster KOes the opposing lead without a boost while losing its Sash.
with Cloyster at +2 with intact Sash technically in second place ofc but that's hard to get consistently and mostly happens against predictable Encores or Protects or whatever. This priority is also not super strict; in particular, while usually a +6 Cloyster setup is overrated if it comes at the cost of its Sash (i.e. if it sets up on weakened attacks) because you may be a single Quick Claw or Brightpowder proc away from losing it and the more "neutral" state of Sub Gliscor is a very risk-free position to be in, against certain more narrow rosters this risk may be low enough to get away with this, at which point the assured-enough sweep is its own good ofc. The amount of damage Cloyster takes during setup is another thing ofc if it means it stays out of range of priority attacks, etc you name it. Normally I'd include a lead notes sample here, but for Subway that's a bit harder with all the pre-battle 40 sets surviving forever, and the one in the Maison post gives a good enough impression. Do let me know if I need to explain anything else though!
Another factor that's relevant to consider is one where we need to start moving away from talking in broad strokes and move to a more Subway-specific mechanics: old crits. Take a look at this:
252 Atk Arcanine Flare Blitz vs. 212 HP / 36+ Def Gliscor on a critical hit: 135-159 (76.3 - 89.8%); recoil damage: 45-53 (27.3 - 32.1%) -- guaranteed 2HKO after Poison Heal
In the Maison, lead Arcanine is easy; just go to Gliscor on the obvious Close Combat, Sub/Protect stall Flare Blitz, Toxic stall it down its last couple turns to win with Sub. Over here though this would leave us with a 1/16 chance of just losing Gliscor, finishing off with unboosted Surf (because lmao Close Combat with the Shell Smash Defense drop can put us into Extreme Speed range even without a crit), and praying the rest of the team isn't too bad. And not even moving all the special bulk over here as well is enough to rule this out effectively. So, instead we're just clicking an immediate Earthquake to OHKO it through the Close Combat drop, and if it comes out later in the game (e.g. on a boosted Cloyster chipped into Extreme Speed range), we don't even have that option and just kind of have to risk the crit.
Maybe I'm just not respecting Arcanine too much; one way or another this is still a 120 BP STAB move off a beefy-enough base Attack stat. But it's also a Jolly nature without a boosting item. And a neutral hit into a Pokemon with almost Suicune-level natural physical bulk plus a pretty decent amount of investment. Surely I'm not that entitled for feeling like this should be a better counter than it is in practice? While I guess a lot of newgen mechanic changes can be a matter of taste, this really just seems like a fundamentally unbalanced mechanic where the big nerf couldn't have come too soon, and one could argue that even with the multiplier drop it also required the reduction of the odds to 1/24 to truly become a positive-enough factor in this game.
Now thankfully this was a calc that I ended up running and planning around before it ever actually got nasty. Let's take a look at some that have actually happened though.
Hide
+2 252 Atk Gallade Psycho Cut vs. 212 HP / 36+ Def Gliscor on a critical hit: 172-204 (97.2 - 115.3%) -- 87.5% chance to OHKO
Part 1 of shitty Psychic / Fighting types posing a major headache for these three, a genuinely weak attack on an unfunny set that goes by Gallade-1 and runs Swords Dance, Psycho Cut, Brick Break, and Shadow Sneak, max/max Hasty @ Expert Belt. You know how these things go; Cloyster sets up on the lead while being knocked down to its Sash, it takes out the lead and the second Pokemon, then this thing comes out and picks it off with Shadow Sneak. In the interest of not getting cute and going straight for the win to limit potential hax, you try going for the 2HKO with Earthquake while it boosts, gets the textbook Murphy's law critical hit proc, and also finishes off Chansey after, and oops that's the end of that attempt. This was actually my very first loss with this team, and att you shrug it off because "lol 12 battles in, shit happens sometimes", but when it not much later bops another attempt in the exact same way when you're in the process of learning the hard way that Lansat is actually not quite as free here for this team as a somehow actually unlucky 787-1 Maison record might imply and you're also aware that no set ever entirely stops disappearing, this goes from a crappy set 1 Pokemon to something you keep a permanent warning flag for in the sheet on any Trainer that may have it, just like another Psychic / Fighting type that we'll get to later.
-2 252+ Atk Life Orb Escavalier Megahorn vs. 252 HP / 252+ Def Eviolite Chansey on a critical hit: 390-460 (109.2 - 128.9%) -- guaranteed OHKO
Escavalier-3 is yucky because it won't allow Gliscor to beat it with a Sub up; Escavalier-4 is "fine" in this regard because it has Swagger to waste turns on while Swords Dance on the other two sets means you're quite content to beat them at all. For the sake of better positioning this is a matchup where I use Growl to stop it from breaking Gliscor's Subs, and it should be noted that it tends to want to get in three Iron Defense boosts quickly, meaning the crit risk is pretty low in practice. When it does happen you get something stupid like this though, and this one actually marked the end of a 268-win streak when an unknown Haxorus set comes in after, I can't Toxic it immediately because it might be the Band set, and it's actually set 2 that ends up outplaying me with Dragon Dance vs. Outrage and ends up breaking through Gliscor when it attacks on the turn I click Toxic. Cloyster still revenge kills but without its Sash loses to lastmon Garchomp, even if that's Garchomp-1 not having the decency to miss Sand Tomb.
For what it's worth it's true that you can argue that risking this crit was a misplay after all, since Gliscor "could" have stalled down Escavalier through Life Orb recoil entirely, at the cost of most of its Sub/Protect PP and not winning with an intact Sub; basically, this is a choice between risking the crit vs facing odds of backups that can have their way with a mostly depleted Gliscor, and I don't plan to pretend that the line of play I used here is the unilaterally correct one.
0 SpA Whiscash Muddy Water vs. 212 HP / 164 SpD Gliscor on a critical hit: 182-216 (102.8 - 122%) -- guaranteed OHKO
Okay, sure, expecting Gliscor to just facetank super effective STAB crits is slightly more entitled than feeling like it should be a hard counter to Arcanine. Off of Maison muscle memory this is actually an extremely clean Cloyster setup though, when Gliscor can switch into this with complete safety, stall out Muddy Water, switch-stall Fissure, and leave the free turns from the remaining RestTalk PP to Cloyster to do its thing. In this gen though this crit ended up killing one of my runs at 120-ish, when it forced me to just go for the +2 Cloyster sweep and Whiscash clicked and hit Fissure right away, allowing followup Hariyama-4 to pick Cloyster off with Bullet Punch and have its way with Chansey. Now the existence of this crit means that this was actually a misplay, but the "right" play is a nice testament to how much more difficult this mechanic can make things, since... yes in makeshift Walrein4 fashion you actually go to Chansey first and hope all Muddy Water PP get wasted before it lands a Fissure (pretty good odds in practice fwiw but shrug), and if Chansey does get hit with Fissure then I guess there is your free switch to Gliscor to set the Maison plan in motion after all. No way to avoid risking Chansey to Fissure here, and in the battle in question even if I'd played it right Hariyama-4 would actually have taken out our +6 Cloyster with intact Sash if it was Thick Fat, at which point we have a non-Subbed Cloyster forced to take on whatever is coming in third. Granted at this point that is more of a testament to Hariyama's threat level rather than Whiscash's, but this is one 1/16th chance that makes for a major headache or two that I could do without.
-6 252+ SpA Heatran Flash Cannon vs. 212 HP / 164 SpD Gliscor on a critical hit: 157-186 (88.7 - 105.1%) -- 31.3% chance to OHKO
Okay, this one did not actually happen, but on Heatran-3's Solar Beam it did after I got my headcalcs mixed up with the Maison again, which is the exact same roll anyways except this one is the more painful example and tedious matchup. You can't at all switch Gliscor into lead Heatran's potential Fire moves or Wisp, and while Chansey beats any Heatran set one-on-one without breaking too much of a sweat, but since winning with a Gliscor Sub is categorically better with its overall absurd Veteran matchup and Chansey's risk of baiting Terrakion in second, finding any line at all for an opening is good. Heatran charging Solar Beam on the Chansey switch is good, but it getting both the crit and the roll after is less good, and after it also burns Chansey when it uses its only Fire Blast on the final Seismic Toss the way the rest of the battle goes is Chansey managing to trade itself for followup Latios4 and mystery Pokemon Regice3 falling to fresh Cloyster in a scenario that hopefully never has to happen again. Anyways, an earlier strat against Heatran2 involved switching to it after it was made safe by Overheat being gone and Chansey already having a burn active, but since like I said a Flash Cannon crit is the same roll to gamble with, that's also unwise. Soooo currently on Heatran-3 I'm Growl stalling Fire Blast and Solar Beam before I make the switch, while Heatran-2 gets stalled out of, well, everything. School of hard knocks for forcing me to make good plays I suppose.
+4 0 SpA Chandelure Heat Wave vs. 252 HP / 0 SpD Eviolite Chansey on a critical hit: 300-354 (84 - 99.2%) -- 75% chance to OHKO after burn damage
lol chande is so funny. At least this one also has not actually happened...
We need to talk about weather as well, namely gen 5 Sand Stream and Snow Cloak's permaweather, where even though Gliscor obviously doesn't care about the former and Cloyster's Sash is immune to the latter, it was very much on my radar as something that would make things Different here compared to the Maison.
see here for the loss report as well...
Tyranitar in particular I was scared of; while 99% of them are set 4 in the Maison, which is hard countered by Gliscor, here we have Sand Workers (and also Hikers), who will run any set. For reference:
377 Tyranitar-1 Impish Iron Ball Rock Slide Stealth Rock Thunder Wave Fling HP/SpD
552 Tyranitar-2 Hasty King's Rock Rock Slide Crunch Ice Beam Dragon Dance Atk/Spe
727 Tyranitar-3 Jolly Chople Berry Stone Edge Crunch Earthquake Dragon Dance Atk/Spe
902 Tyranitar-4 Brave Focus Sash Rock Slide Earthquake Superpower Dragon Tail HP/Atk
where you'll see a funny pattern that set 1 and 4 are Gliscor food but set 2 and 3 pretty much run away with the game on the spot if they click DD on the switch. So for better or worse that makes decisions a bit easier I guess and we just have to click Shell Smash turn 1. Sets 1 and 4 will either functionally or entirely take out Cloyster for the game here, but "most expendable team member" etc and Gliscor's Sand Worker matchup in particular is fine overall, and the silver lining is that sets 2 and 3 don't have a KO on Cloyster. Set 2 will "always" (knock on wood) open with Dragon Dance while set 3 does more often than not, at which point they're both simply outsped and one-shot, and even if set 3 does open with Stone Edge to take out Cloyster with sand chip, that at least means it's not boosting, and Gliscor has a decent matchup here in a neutral board state. For extra funnies sand means that even in a best case scenario Cloyster is pretty much always on a +2 kamikaze mission after turn 1, with Sash instantly being negated even if they do choose to DD. Hippowdon is not so bad in the sense that Curse sets aren't capable of breaking through Chansey even with sand's constant chip damage and you can still get a +6 Cloyster on its four remaining Curse turns and whatever Rests or Protects it may have left, except unlike in Maison it does come at the cost of Focus Sash here. That goes against the above priority brackets which would dictate winning with Gliscor here, and you can't even say that Cloyster can make do without Sash's insurance here, with Sand Veil Garchomp and Brightpowder Sand Rush Excadrill among potential backups; however, one way or another Sash is just not an item in this matchup anyway lol, so you might as well aim to reduce variance (and potential Tyranitar headaches) via sheer power and cross the miss bridge when you get to it.
Hail is worse and also less bad in the sense that there's hardly a Pokemon that hates permahail more than Gliscor does, but at the same time this is also mostly a Chansey matchup and the Abomasnow lines in particular are hardly affected. More subtle workings actually led directly to my 652 streak's loss against (Ice) Worker Valéry, who after leading with Abomasnow-3 that Chansey defeats without any major hiccups sends out Glaceon. For reference:
345 Glaceon-1 Rash Quick Claw Ice Shard Blizzard Mirror Coat Helping Hand HP/SpA
520 Glaceon-2 Bold Chesto Berry Frost Breath Shadow Ball Rest Barrier HP/Def
695 Glaceon-3 Modest Focus Sash Hail Blizzard Mirror Coat Hyper Beam Def/SpA
870 Glaceon-4 Modest BrightPowder Blizzard Shadow Ball Signal Beam Detect Def/SpA
and if you read the team's playstyle notes properly so far you'll notice Helping Hand and Rest/Barrier on sets 1 and 2 making them +6 Cloyster setup bait, while the other two sets can get stalled out of Blizzard and are beaten by Gliscor after, to the point that Glaceon actually is a lead I'm outright happy to see on Ice Workers. This time, an early Quick Claw proc reveals set 1, but with Abomasnow's permahail in place, Ice Shard / Mirror Coat's infinite PP, and the number of Soft-Boileds I already needed to take down Abomasnow, I'm actually not gonna have enough Soft-Boiled PP here to stall Glaceon all the way down to Helping Hand (and if I'm wrong and I actually do it's gonna be so drained that things backfire in other ways if anything happens to Cloyster via e.g. Walrein or Dewgong misses). So, I end up setting up Cloyster on Ice Shard instead, which still gets me to +6 except without my Sash this time. Out comes Froslass, Snow Cloak procs, and it takes me out with Hex, confirming:
429 Froslass-2 Lonely Ice Gem Ice Shard Thunder Wave Hex Taunt Atk/Spe
which is a top 2 threat to this team on account of the obviously atrocious Gliscor / Chansey matchup and forces a turn 1 Rock Blast on "any" Ice Worker Froslass lead in general. I've beaten it before with Cloyster out of the picture as well, since Subway's Taunt AI is wonky enough that I get room to squeeze in a Toxic most of the time, but today is no such day, and the one turn it does give me space is wasted to a full para. On the hail front, the big takeaway is that, even though Abomasnow itself was no major threat here, the battle would have been trivial without gen 5 hail; even with Cloyster's immunity it still cost me its Sash indirectly which on account of Ice Shard did not matter against Froslass but might have elsewhere, and of course this also would have been a win without Snow Cloak in play. Oh well.
This is where I would normally add a threatlist, but for the most part they're already covered in the examples above (yay?) For a quick recap, probably incomplete but w/e:
Hide
333 Gallade-1 Hasty Expert Belt Shadow Sneak Brick Break Psycho Cut Swords Dance Atk/Spe
Typical case of Swords Dance user therefore cannot be stalled where priority also negates Cloyster's Speed advantage if it takes too much damage during setup. If Cloyster takes a super effective hit on the Smash turn, Shadow Sneak + Swords Dance + Psycho Cut crit + Brick Break is an instant countersweep that's always lurking around the corner, and even stalling Psycho Cut doesn't help a lot when you get to deal with +6 Brick Break instead and the only thing you get out of it is a lowered crit rate at the cost of 22 Sub/Protect PP.
290 Escavalier-1 Brave Liechi Berry Megahorn Quick Guard Swords Dance Reversal HP/Atk
465 Escavalier-2 Naughty Quick Claw Pursuit Counter X-Scissor Swords Dance HP/Atk
640 Escavalier-3 Brave Life Orb Megahorn Iron Defense Poison Jab Iron Head HP/Atk
815 Escavalier-4 Adamant Custap Berry Megahorn Iron Head Swagger Reversal HP/Atk
Mostly set 2 tbh; set 1 likes Quick Guard so much that it gives you enough room to squeeze in Earthquakes quickly, set 3 can be chipped down via Life Orb and Earthquakes especially if you Growl it first, and set 4 is mostly the same thing as set 1 except with Swagger rather than Quick Guard plus inability to boost power. Set 2 is just full-on harassment though and whoever thought tossing Quick Claw + Swords Dance on a set that very much exists outside of early battles as well was a fair idea needs to reconsider their priorities building these things, and the fact that X-Scissor is not really the most powerful move ever doesn't matter a whole lot either on something with this level of bulk that still has full Attack investment. At least it falls to +6 Surf, and I've also beaten it before with Earthquake battering, but Quick Claw bs makes it perpetually unreliable and every battle not facing this is a good one. Escavalier in particular is also a big reason why Bikers are probably my least favourite Trainers to see; with their super-powerful and ambiguous rosters the other sets can make for indirect headaches as well if they stop Gliscor from successfully maintaining a Sub.
377 Tyranitar-1 Impish Iron Ball Rock Slide Stealth Rock Thunder Wave Fling HP/SpD
552 Tyranitar-2 Hasty King's Rock Rock Slide Crunch Ice Beam Dragon Dance Atk/Spe
727 Tyranitar-3 Jolly Chople Berry Stone Edge Crunch Earthquake Dragon Dance Atk/Spe
902 Tyranitar-4 Brave Focus Sash Rock Slide Earthquake Superpower Dragon Tail HP/Atk
Discussed at length in the sand section; sets 2 and 3 will run away with the game if given a free Dragon Dance boost, forcing a turn 1 Shell Smash + Icicle Spear that is a de facto Cloyster sack against sets 1 and 4 that Gliscor has to clean up after, while set 3 may also choose to attack Cloyster directly and OHKO it with help from sand chip. Thanks to the turn 1 Smash they only rarely cause an instant potential loss, but if this thing leads I'm always in an instantly compromised position, even if it's just from sand taking out Focus Sash as set 2 or 3 hits Dragon Dance turn 1.
738 Feraligatr-4 Adamant Liechi Berry Dragon Dance Waterfall Crunch Substitute Atk/Spe
By far the worst Pokemon that can come out on Gliscor with a Sub because I can't Toxic it, and Chansey hates it as well here when I can't Growl stall it through Substitute yet. On these runs minus one time I have only seen it in the lead position (or I was at +6 and it would have folded instantly), where it gets 2HKOed by +2 Icicle Spear and which makes some sense I guess with its comparative rarity compared to gen 6; one time it came out on Gliscor as a third mon where I could just brute force my way through it thanks to no longer having to care about my positioning for any followup Pokemon. If it comes out second on not-Cloyster I'd probably just have to play it by ear, and even in the lead position you're actually hoping you /don't/ get any Icicle Spear crits to avoid activating Liechi or Torrent, just for a case in point of how sick this thing is.
761 Hariyama-4 Careful Sitrus Berry Belly Drum Brick Break Ice Punch Bullet Punch Def/SpD
Physical booster + priority etc, thankfully with a fantasy EV spread, but also with potential Thick Fat to laugh at Icicle Spear and Ice Punch to annoy Gliscor. In the lead there is not really anything better to do than just go for +2 Icicle Spear, which is actually a KO if it click Belly Drum right away and isn't Thick Fat, and even if it is then Belly Drum + +2 Icicle Spear - Sitrus Berry is enough to get it into Earthquake range okay. Always instantly compromised position etc though, and Thick Fat variants get extra hate for actually being hard counters to +6 Cloyster no matter what.
429 Froslass-2 Lonely Ice Gem Ice Shard Thunder Wave Hex Taunt Atk/Spe
Taunt + Ghost typing + STAB Ice coverage even if weak is a fever dream for Gliscor + Chansey, and it can and will also seriously incapacitate Cloyster. Beatable via instant Rock Blast, folds to +2 Icicle Spear with prior setup if Cloyster was knocked down to Sash, thankfully can leave room for Toxic sometimes, second worst threat to the team overall though and was what ended my run.
One is still omitted from this, because it deserves a significant amount of discussion on its own.
575 Medicham-3 Jolly Expert Belt Hi Jump Kick Zen Headbutt Ice Punch Bullet Punch Atk/Spe
So, this thing. Only a single Trainer can run it in the Maison after battle 40, to the point that I honestly forgot it existed until it just pretty much swept me entirely on a neutral board state after I'd always expected my eventual loss to be to an infuriating and unpredictable cocktail of hax. The loss in question was to a potential misplay, since I clicked Shell Smash on it while forgetting about Bullet Punch though going for the straight Icicle Spear would at least have given me a coinflip OHKO roll, but Bullet Punch is exactly what makes this set ridiculous anyways. Looking into it closer, it obviously has Medicham STAB moves backed by Medicham's ridiculous power, where Ice Punch counters Gliscor; and while normally Focus Sash is actually good against things like this by giving you essentially a chance to 2HKO which is pretty much always enough even with neutral hits against something this frail, Bullet Punch takes that option off the table. After that yea you're facing a medium Speed turbo powerful wallbreaker with some pretty colourful coverage which indeed is the kind of thing that tends to run right through a bulky team, more at 11 I suppose. There is no sugarcoating it: if Cloyster's Sash is broken and this thing comes out against Chansey, Gliscor without a Sub, unboosted Cloyster, or boosted Cloyster in Bullet Punch range, you
will lose barring a cascade of hail Mary early HJK misses during a switch-stall. Even if Cloyster's Sash is intact, i.e. if it shows up in the lead position or after Cloyster insta-one-shots a lead where that's the best option, unboosted Icicle Spear is a 50% roll, or 60%-ish with crits taken into account, and if you start playing this team you're agreeing you might just have to flip that coin at some point and there's nothing you can do.
Now the good news is that, while it's considerably more common in Subway than in Maison, it's still rare enough that you can conceivably go hundreds of battles without seeing it at all i.e. this thing is not at all a reason to not bother with a run period especially if you're not taking it super seriously, and even if it does show up as a backup then odds mitigation is still a thing. In practice this means that, on any Trainer that might run Medicham-3, if at all possible you follow a line of play that ends with either a boosted Cloyster not in Bullet Punch range or a Gliscor behind a Sub, with the latter being more reasonable to attain of course. For a practical example, if you're facing a lead like Samurott-3 (Waterfall / X-Scissor / Aerial Ace / Aqua Jet @ Custap), you don't just go to Chansey and Toxic it, but instead you use Growl and Soft-Boiled to PP stall Waterfall and give Gliscor a clean switch plus the ability for its Subs to avoid even a 2HKO from non-crit Aqua Jet, which gives it great odds to defeat it with an intact Sub and have the safety net for a followup Medicham-3. Now, what actually comes out is Lanturn-3 (Surf / Ice Beam / Discharge / Thunder Wave), which we're in a great position to take on now, but Ice Beam's higher effective Base Power compared to Ice Punch means there might still be a Medicham-3 lurking in the wings after. So, instead of taking the tempting option and using the Sub to 2HKO Lanturn with Earthquake (though rolling the dice for the crit OHKO is still allowed!), what we actually do is yes we switch Chansey back in and once again keep spamming Growl until it's got only Electric moves left so we can safely maintain the Sub here as well. Yes it sounds absurd, and it probably is, but if Medicham3 does come out last then you're really kicking yourself for not doing this while you could have. I don't have a full list handy right now, but in general this is extremely doable versus a ton of set 3 enemies, and it might not be hyperbole to say that I could count on two hands the number of set 3 enemies (that are in the same set as Medicham) that I can't avoid KOing with Chansey or 1 HP Cloyster on lead.
Here's the real kicker though: absurd or not, in keeping with the setup priority bracket from earlier, this is an actively superior line of play over KOing enemy leads with Chansey's Toxic even without Medicham's existence. The extra time taken stalling is not a downside at all; physical time is of course mostly irrelevant, and in terms of turns spent, I mean we gave Chansey those infinite Growl PP for a reason, is there anything wrong with actually using them? Indeed, it also has ended up extending to non-set 3 Trainers, meaning I e.g. PP stall lead Froslass from Psychics, since while they're easy to take down with Chansey's Toxic as well I'd much rather have Gliscor out if they decide to send in Medicham4 next. The only thing worth mentioning is of course hax odds from facetanking all of those moves, which is why e.g. I do consider it a bit too cavalier to do it with offensively invested Ice Beam users and still go for Toxic into the likes of Porygon-Z (I did just give the Lanturn-3 example lol oops but that one doesn't count when it'll use Thunder Wave to make Chansey immune to freeze right away, also there is Blizzard but 5 PP + terrible accuracy makes me feel more safe there) and why I also don't wanna do it against Flamethrower users with a ton of PP since a burn proc there can and will make the needed Soft-Boiled PP actually explode, but you get the idea. And of course potential Medicham-3 presence is another factor to consider in decisionmaking even still.
Slightly breaking the flow of this post for a bit, but since it's important to understand the AI properly and I've been paying attention to a lot of that along the way as well, I wanna list some things I've observed here that differ from the Maison AI, which of course is where I'm mostly coming from.
Hide
-
Substitute is an obvious one that everyone knows about but I still need to address quick. We all know that the AI in this generation doesn't understand Substitute yet and will keep using status moves into it, which is something that people can and do make use of to get extra boosts on e.g. lead SubDD Dragons. For the most part, this has actually made things more annoying for me lol since I'm using Gliscor therefore using my Subs to stall out PP not grab infinite Dragon Dance boosts and all it does is make me waste more valuable PP on status moves that normally I'd just switch-stall once the damaging moves are gone, in some cases even forcing me to be content with just winning with Gliscor where in Maison a +6 Cloyster would have been attainable; sometimes though it has also worked as a black hole to absorb enemy Leech Seed where switch-stalling e.g. Poison Heal Breloom4 and having to Soft-Boiled on potential Focus Punch would have been worse, so shrug. At least I don't remember having any lines like with Marathon where I also use Substitute to force the AI into a weak attacking move on a Gyarados rather than Leech Seed or Toxic and set up another Gyarados Sub after, since those are obv impossible in this generation as well. I suppose weak Sub AI helps sometimes, but overall it's a wash to me and I would not mind having the smart AI, since you "should" be able to figure out playing around that one anyways.
-
Encore and
Taunt are different; Encore's priority is even higher than in the Maison, with the AI even using it on slower enemies turn 1, which like I think I wrote earlier allows me to Shell Smash on lead Infernape and also comes in handy versus Dewgong-2, which otherwise would be Chansey food but can actually be annoying there. Taunt AI is also weaker; while it's pretty much a guaranteed click if the enemy doesn't have super effective moves in the Maison and still common if it does, it's rarer here to the point that I can confidently enough click Shell Smash on lead Virizion and even make it out of the Toxicroak lead matchup without Gliscor being Taunted more often than not. Does take some instinctual Protect clicks, but at least it seems to rarely use it on back-to-back turns.
-
Trick has absurdly high priority in this generation, to the point that even Manectric and Alakazam will use it pretty reliably against Cloyster, and Alakazam in particular just forces a turn 1 Shell Smash and getting through the rest of the battle with a gimped Cloyster. Manectric does the same thing, but you can also go for Shell Smash and utilise Gliscor's re-found status as a good counter (unless Overheat crit, which at least does not OHKO...) once Cloyster has taken the hit on eating the Choice Scarf. Latias-3 is another one, but unlike Alakazam it can't break Chansey, meaning it's actually reasonable to map things out so that it gives Cloyster Sash back then Struggles to death, and all the other ones (Toxic Orb users that are hard countered by Gliscor, Flame Orb Lopunny that annoys Chansey) work the same way they did in the Maison.
-
Dragon Dance in combination with Growl deserves a special mention; back in 2015 I researched
the interaction between stat boosts and stat drops in the Maison, since it turned out that e.g. Curse and Bulk Up users would just stop after boosting six times even if their Attack kept dropping further, which is a behaviour that persisted into the Tree and apparently also already existed in the Subway and of course makes outstalling them with Intimidate or Growl a lot easier. Dragon Dance was an exception to this behaviour in gen 6, but over here it's not, and yes even Dragon Dance users will just stop after 6, where I have a video somewhere that I may upload later if my net doesn't get dumb about it. It's a bit harder to make actual use of in practical situations with most of them having heavy Attack investment and the Speed boosts forcing extra respect for crit odds, but it's a funny thing and also reframes the Maison conundrum from "what makes Curse and Bulk Up special or glitched" to "why was Dragon Dance singled out to have this behaviour fixed while the others were left alone". Yea!!
-
Toxic has broken AI sometimes, not sure how else to put it, but stalling out e.g. Vileplume3 will actually overboost with Double Team before starting to really dip into its Toxic pool, then treat it as roughly equal priority with Ingrain even if it already has the latter active and sometimes even in the face of a healthy Chansey. Not much to make of this other than a thing to be aware of especially when it comes to counting PP, and sometimes it may cheat you out of a Cloyster setup and leave you with a Subbed Gliscor instead.
-
Predictability is a very big one unfortunately to be aware of going into this. Barring priority revenge kills, the AI here seems pretty indifferent on which move to click if it has multiple KOs, meaning it's generally a bad idea to switch Gliscor into predicted Thunderbolts from lead special attackers and that preserving a 1HP Cloyster is not at all worth it when that Regice might as well happily click Ice Beam on the Gliscor switch. It extends to regular wallbreaking moves as well, where the Maison AI heavily works off having a singular "preferred" move out of its main 4 but the Subway does this a lot less; Magnezone4 is a big one that comes to mind, where I can normally conserve a lot of PP by switching a Gliscor partner out of predicted Thunderbolts, but over here I just might end up switching Gliscor into extra Flash Cannons, not to mention I can't keep Chansey in to Soft-Boiled either when Magnezone might as well click Volt Switch. This change in behaviour is also why NoCheese's Durant team was less forced to run Garchomp when he ported it to the Maison and probably the only buff Durant teams actually got in the generation switch. There is still some logic to it e.g. prioritisation of type effectiveness when no KOs are read, but yea overall I've had to force myself to play this more like BDSP Doubles, where I focus more on heavy momentum control than fully reading the AI like a book.
And a few replays, we're limiting it to 3 for character and net mercy reasons.
Hide
#300: vs. Pokemon Ranger Paula
Lead Medicham3 rears its head, of course at an extremely funny moment when I'd already accepted that this was gonna be my final attempt before I'd write it up. I considered doing a next level switch-stall between Cloyster and Gliscor to get rid of Ice Punch PP, but that won't work here anyways with unpredictable AI and Gliscor getting in Zen Headbutt range at some point even without HJK crit, so going for the Spear roll had to be it and I got it. Worth preserving for obvious reasons alone, but evidence that yes I did see this one and yes I did make it past it never hurts ig...
#584: vs. Hiker Kemuel
An example of the way this team would be expected to lose even without Medicham3 or Froslass2 or Gallade1 showing up, and an example of how any loss other than to those two is always gonna be next-level infuriating. Tl;dr is that Archeops is a lead where Smash + Spear is fine, then an unknown Carracosta set comes up which is Costa4 picking off Cloyster with Aqua Jet which is also "fine" especially since I don't have good switch-ins to "any" Carracosta. Now the go-to plan against Carracosta4 is to stall out Waterfall first, then go to Chansey to Growl it once to stop its moves from breaking Gliscor's Subs and win with Sub active, but that kind of goes down the drain if it uses Rock Slide on the switch then gets back-to-back flinches after to put me in range for a fourth, and suddenly I have to take on an unknown lastmon with a 60%-ish heavily depleted Gliscor and an 84 HP Chansey. Something more threatening than Aggron1 could have been yikes.
#653: vs. Worker Valéry
The ultimate loss, which I'd already gone into in the hail writeup. The tl;dr is Chansey defeats a lead Abomasnow, then stalls Blizzard on a followup Glaceon1 where constant chip damage from hail gradually draining Soft-Boiled PP too much forces me to set up Cloyster on Ice Shard rather than Helping Hand and lose its Sash in the process, then a Snow Cloak proc and for once actually smart Taunt AI usage on Froslass2, the second biggest threat after Medicham3, seals the deal. I'll never like losing but I will say that the blow always gets softened a lot when it is to a major threat without involving misplays; similarly I was just sitting on the sofa laughing when Medicham showed up in battle 300, and if that would be it then that would be it.
That was my serious Subway debut, which I never expected would actually happen tbh but fate works in mysterious ways sometimes. This run did not at all come easy though and has been in the works on and off since my Maison loss. The first post-Ingo run ended at 79 wins, in a battle that felt unlucky and I could shrug off because it was early but also was devoid of real hax; it was versus a Psychic where Chansey ended up KOing a lead Gardevoir or whatever idr well, then Medicham comes in which actually does wreck things in this position, I sack Chansey to take it out with +2 Cloyster because "surely there's not a lot around that wins in this position other than like Cloyster or Starmie dodging Rock Blast". For starters, there is Jynx... which uses Fake Out to finish off Cloyster and does not miss Blizzard into Gliscor. Anyways, I try again, get Froslass2ed and Medicham3ed before making it to Ingo again, which goes well but early-ish in the next set there is a battle that has Chansey KO the second Pokemon, idr which, and Garchomp4 shows up last and clicks SD on a Toxic miss. The second Toxic hits as Garchomp clicks +2 Earthquake, so now that I just need to stall out five more turns I go to Gliscor on the predicted followup Earthquake which ends up being a +2 Dragon Claw crit OHKO instead, after which the planned Cloyster revenge kill also gets foiled by a Rock Slide flinch (can you believe giving this thing Stone Edge in gen 6 was actually a nerf lmao), and I decide that I'm just really not having a good time with this right now. Slightly sounding like a spoiled brat here I am sorry, but I hope it's understandable that even with the Subway obviously being more difficult than the Maison for a few reasons (more on that in a sec) I couldn't help but trust a 787-1 Maison team could at least get me to Lansat on cue. Not have a 79 PB be an actual wall. The losses being to early sets didn't help either, since I have never bought into the idea of those being irrelevant crapshoots and do consider getting owned by them a skill issue. Unless you're running a specific anti-facility counterteam crippler setup, it's not like they're fundamentally different puzzles to solve than the later sets anyway.
Now, what do those losses have in common? Skill issues.... I will not deny that Jynx was a pretty nasty roll of the dice to see as a third Pokemon, but surely if my brain is properly functioning at all I should be able to figure out that Chansey is far higher value against the typical Psychic roster (and that Gliscor is the only one that at least has a shot at switching into Medicham and living to tell the tale), and that's not even getting into the fact that Gardevoir can be stalled down to Struggle to win with a Gliscor Sub quite easily. And yes it would be be pure self-bashing to claim that the luck against Garchomp was anything better than atrocious, but with a line of Chansey sack -> Gliscor Protect -> (Sash) Cloyster switch -> Cloyster sack -> Gliscor Protect I had a hax-free path to those five turns right there. I (also) blame brainrot from just spamming Growl in the Maison for 787 battles without being challenged close to as much as here ngl, which I honestly think brought down my skill level across the board for a while. I returned to this after hitting 1k in BDSP Doubles, when things went a lot better with the aforementioned 268 run into the 120 loss against the Whiscash crit, a barely pre-Lansat one right after, and finally the current dream run.
Going into this run, I knew the team would probably be functional, but that increased Medicham3 presence and old crits would be potential problems. I did also have some self-imposed pressure to deal with from pretty much openly announcing that I would be giving this a shot in the Maison post, and of course having an actually okay score to go with it would be nice even if I was gonna just make it a "okay this is how this team handles the Subway" post. Going into this my optimistic goal was 400+ which seemed to be the ballpark for a genuinely really good Subway run, but I also knew I might have to be content with Starf if things were even more hostile here than I'd expected, and the early beatdowns that I kept getting made me question things even further and I might have shelved things outright if not for the obvious underperformance-even-with-this-level-of-bad-luck vibes. I was actually gonna just do a writeup for the 268 run if this one had failed yet again because that was still a pretty okay score in the end and things were getting to me a bit ngl where having a planned writeup hanging over my head was not helping at all, so to say that 652 is beyond my wildest dreams is quite the understatement of the year.
It's actually quite the first world problem lol because with Meuhforever's Menceglischan and especially Peterko's Cloyster team as the top 2 non-crippler teams on the leaderboard some similar strategies are already documented here, and I was actually gonna phrase this section as "Mari takes the two best non-crippler teams and makes them worse" until I overshot my score into undermining my point there. Since I do think there is still value in sharing my thoughts on this though: while control-focused play is obvious facility singles play's bread and butter in general, there is such a thing as playing too reactively, which this team already struggled a bit with in the Maison sometimes and is obviously made way worse by Subway's increased set ambiguity (read: planning middle grounds against potential heavy offensive threats) and, indeed, old crits, which can easily make for a fatal momentum loss if you can't claw back from them when you might have been able to with just a x1,5 multiplier. For all its absurd strength neutralising enemies this team's offensive presence really is pretty garbage if it needs to be called upon without prior setup and the lack of speed doesn't help either (see the shoutout I gave to Aegislash's Shadow Sneak in particular in a similar section in the Maison post iirc). The other two teams do a way better job there, for more reasons than being able to just blast Medicham3 off the screen with their Dragons lol, and that's a thing I'll certainly keep in mind if I ever return here with something else. Having properly played both Tree and Subway now with ports of Maison teams of mine, I do think I like Subway better at least; while old crits mean it gets pretty punishing on the field, the Tree is pretty punishing in the builder instead with the Mega suffocation I've already said way too much about elsewhere, and punishing on the field at least means I get to play at all. The balance between rosters with and without set ambiguity is actually really nice as well, and with current gen mechanics this could actually have been my favourite facility.
Now that I've had a day or two to think between the loss and writing this up, I do think this score makes a bit more sense than I thought it did at first, with how super hard it lashes out with the context of my earlier losses; "luck" has certainly been better on this run anyways I suppose, but I think I'm also genuinely playing way better than when I first picked it up or indeed when I was doing the Maison run, as hopefully seen from the play optimisations mentioned in this post and not mentioned in this post. As always, my goal (other than Fun) has been to squeeze out a team's potential, and if I was not doing that properly at first but have gotten better at that since, then yea such an exponential increase can happen ig. As far as this team's adventures in Subway go though, unless I somehow suddenly run into a massive BP shortage before I find any new teams to play with, this is it; I am incredibly content with this score, and if I do get the urge to play it again, then it has more to win in the Maison than in here.
It's also been a really long year for me in facilities in general lol, where at the very least this is a great way of rounding out my goal of also branching out into non-Maison play and proving that I can hold my own there as well. There are still more teams and modes to try out later, but with how long a year it's been and the BDSP Doubles streak that has so far refused to die still being out there as well, I should really take advantage of not having any teams on my immediate todo right now, healthy option and stuff.
mari Christmas to those who celebrate and happy holidays!!