Hacker said:What is wrong with SS LC?
This tier has a few issues but the main one that really stands out to me is the poison-type economy. Poisons as it stands right now are basically mandatory on every viable and consistent SS team thats ever been created recently. The recent trend of Toxic Spikes Koffing basically invalidates every bit of metagame progress we have made ever since banning Vullaby like variety of fight checks, etc. The way I see it we really have three (basically 2) options to choose from if we want to make this tier better.
When you say poison-types, I assume this boils down to Koffing and Mareanie. First of all I don't think they are mandatory. Although they're probably the top 2 fight resists, there's plenty of examples of people using Morelull and Larv with success.
Toxic Spikes are great at targeting Morelull/Larv/cheese teams, but definitely not to the degree that it invalidates them. There's reasons this move has always seen limited usage. It's far from a free slot on Koffing - if you drop any one of its slots you're going to be missing out on something fairly important, and tspikes is completely useless if you're against another poison-type, which as you say, is extremely likely. This is just another move that's a decent matchup fish against some opponents - not something you should be using on over half your Koffings, and not something that's metagame defining enough to be used as a primary ban argument.
The same kind of tspikes dynamic has existed in SM since forever and has never been enough to invalidate poisonless teams. Of course that's a different metagame with different context but it's unlikely to be any different here in SS, and all the evidence points to that. If people actually become too scared to bring poisonless teams, and stop winning with them often, then we can talk about it.
I actually think Koffing has gotten marginally worse than it used to be a while back because people stack checks more often. There's some teams where opposing Koffing can't click a move without the possibility of making near-zero progress (which is why Thief is better now btw).
So no I don't think this is the issue with SS, and even if it was, banning Diglett wouldn't be my conclusion.
Colin said:My real opinion is that Diglett needs to be banned, because of what Hacker said but also I think it interacts with Ferroseed and Koffing in addition to Mienfoo in unhealthy ways. that core 4 can invalidate all teams without an untrappable poison (koffing), unless they're so fast paced that they can win before tspike (mostly just sun). Ferroseed + Diglett forces either a Natu to prevent spikes, or specific breakers such as offensive non scarf Porygon and Heat Wave Archen that can break Ferroseed quickly and not get trapped afterwards. If Diglett didn't exist, it would be more feasible to run better breakers that could win before Spikes did, since they would be able to take more than 1 KO without being trapped. Diglett setting rocks is not ideal, but Eviolite and Air Balloon sets are okay at it and Shed Shell substitute is very good at it vs Koffing teams.
I'm really anti-Diglett ban, so I feel like I need to address this argument, but it's kind of unclear.
You've provided a standard team structure (Foo / Dig / Ferro / Koffing), stated that it naturally invalidates anything that doesn't have Koffing (false), then provided some interesting counters to it. Just because you have a trappable fight resist doesn't mean you autolose to Diglett. It's just a slightly negative matchup, and with the right combination of other mons on the team, it can actually become a positive one. The team structure you mentioned is just another solid core, not an unstoppable force that's invalidating everything else, otherwise we'd see it more often by now, given it's a fully known quantity.
To be clear though, Koffing is really good and maybe even belongs on the majority of teams. It's just not mandatory, and it's not the core issue to tackle with SS.
If your goal is to diversify the fight resists, we're going end up with more Morelull and Larvestas, which a) are annoying to play against due to status and b) will create more cringe interactions where people fish with Stone Edge / Poison Jab Foo.
So what do I think is wrong with SS LC?
It's the same answer I've been giving for a long time - the games just have less depth. Important 50/50s feel more common than usual, and it's harder to make creative midground plays. This is kinda just a vibe, and Vullaby is what fixes it, from experience.
However, I think SS has gotten a fair bit better than when I last advocated for freeing Vullaby. Developments have been made and speed ties are more avoidable.
I'd still prefer an unban, but I'm okay with SS staying as it is.
(please please don't ban diglett)