lechen caaaaaaaaalm
-
Welcome to Smogon! Take a moment to read the Introduction to Smogon for a run-down on everything Smogon, and make sure you take some time to read the global rules.
NOC Working Title Mafia (Game Thread) [Mafia Wins]
- Thread starter ImaginaryNeon
- Start date
can you tell me more abt the m2h posts you find scummy
why not m dbd/t jalmont?
hmm good point, i do think its a correct criticism so i thought s/s but possible
Yes
thats not really a scumlean position more like tl really like hyhy and genisu i would be floored if they were maf, ecat and flandrs i still tr but wouldn't be super shocked if i was wrong, then pulsar red des and saber are like very weak tl, but essentially saber hasn't really kept the same energy as their open and its becoming more believable that he just had a burst of energy at the start and then tapered off as he wasn't really under any pressure from then, still don't wanna push him obv. could see jalmont with any of des/saber/genisu tbh.
I thought Jalmont was townlean at the start of the game. Then his next posts are similar to what he did in PMD game. It seems he is taking a different approach than me by picking relatively null/mixed players and certainly I could see it being done from a scum viewpoint but I think he is probably town there. His 668 post makes me think a lot, if M2H, jalmont and you are town then who is scum? Genisu is definitely in his town meta, lechen is basically confirmed town at this point... then who is trying to impact the thread as mafia? DBD? Are they all taking advantage and trying to blend with the town players with low amount of posts? I find interesting that players like Joey and Pulsar being voted or mentioned as possible scum to participate.
Honestly I didn't want to mention the jalmont read because I read it as he trying to avoid getting killed d1 by the way his first posts were. Maybe I'm seeing it backwards and he is scum frustrated with the most active players solving but then his 668 post doesn't make sense. Who knows at this point.
In term of towniness between these 5 players I'd say it's like this for me:
Lechen > Genisu > HH > Jalmont > M2H
I can see all of them being town.
That leaves the pools I mentioned before of:
Des, Ecat and Catfries
Redless, DBD, Joey, Pulsar
We can add saber and flandrs to that second pool I guess.
I don't think I'm forgetting anyone this time.
I don't like this vote. Let's find another player to vote!
I decided to vote users with low amount of post or lack of content, saw m2h voting joey and decided that it was a fine option. No other reason honestly.
It's currently showing for me, last time it didn't.
des fulfills all the categories here, and is very scummy imo
I find interesting des posts 652, 657 and 660. Why did she react that way when Jalmont voted flandrs but not on other players.
Good pages from ecat at 28-29
I'm not voting des, feel free to draw your conclusions from that.
why though?
I'd like her to play more (especially when I told her about the game
), same reason I won't vote today any of the 2 players I mentioned along her in my other post. Actually I think ecat improved so I won't consider him even for d2 unless situation changes a lot. D1 votes are the most random ones and have more chances to fail than later and well... I'm a human being before a mafia player, if des flips town I will feel awful. So yeah I'm not voting des.
I would feel awful too, but she is the scummiest player as of rn and have done nothing to defend herself when accused.I'd like her to play more (especially when I told her about the game