On the matter of Kyurem, I'm just... incredibly disappointed in how this entire suspect played out. This was a giant shitshow. I don't just want to pretend as if I dislike the DNB crowd, although there was a plethora and arguably dominance of poor argumentation, although near the end this was eclipsed by some more solid and even some very strong arguments. There was also some very poor conduct on the pro-ban side as well, both in terms of some incessant posting and fearmongering of its own, but also in terms of some pro-ban posters feeling the need to prefer being civil over actually disagreeing with prominent dnb posters. It is hard to describe my frustration at seeing some very prominent Ban posters make posts on the line of 'omg [insert DNB poster here] those are some very strong arguments even if i disagree' rather then actually taking the time and effort to disagree and rebut these posts,
which they very well should've! Given how influential some of these posters were, the fact that they did not bother countering these arguments at all is tantamount to throwing, and I'm incredibly disappointed in that conduct when this suspect test had real ramifications and was very important. I'm also disappointed at the number of people who allowed DNB posters to essentially flood the latter half of the suspect thread, especially considering that it was still a very sound majority that voted to ban Kyurem. I understand the hesitance; this thread was the worst thing I've ever seen on this site and has radically influenced the way I view smogon, but given that some ban voters were literally willing to cheat to see Kyurem banned, I am beyond frustrated that these people never actually voiced their thoughts. Even Akalli put in ridiculous amounts of effort to do this and never actually mentioned his support for or against Kyurem, which is ridiculous when if the prominent players who cheated actually put in the effort to combat a lot of the DNB posters, we may not be in this scenario today. That there was cheating was ridiculous, especially from people skilled enough to get reqs. I'm as pro-ban as the next asshole and I think it's borderline disgraceful that a lot of these people not only didn't bother sucking it up and laddering like the rest of the voters, but didn't bother posting or voicing their support, especially in the wake of such a large DNB movement.
Similarly, the fact that this suspect devolved into being about anything other then Kyurem, from shitty smogon politics to whatever the fuck CTC had going on. This suspect was hijacked yet again and became the CTC show. I respect that influential players will always have disproportionate influence but CTC's in general is just ridiculous, especially considering that unlike in the Gouging suspect he was probably the worst of the prominent DNB posters this time around while also being the worst in conduct of them. I guess he died for another mon's sins. I can't wait for Kyu to get suspected again like last time he got banned so a mon stayed in the tier.
I think there's a lot that could be done to change things in the wake of this, namely reducing the threshold for a ban needed. It's pretty ridiculous that a clear majority voted for a ban and yet still lost by 1 vote, and maybe not now, but close to gen 10, this is what needs to be looked at. I also think there's a pretty big culture of deference to influential players that should be looked at. I wholeheartedly recognize and appreciate that good players are going to have better insights on the tier then most others, and I also agree that these viewpoints need to be respected but I think this got taken to pretty extreme degrees here; people seem pretty quick to forget that good players disagree literally all the time and that good players are not objective gods or whatever. People are very afraid to disagree with influential voices and i think that needs to be remedied. There are definitely other cultural problems with Smogon that need to be looked at, as well as other tiering problems, but I don't have any other answers.
In the wake of this, what happens? Well, as much as I am disappointed, and honestly way moreso then i would've been if Kyurem just wasn't banned in the first place, there's nothing that can be done. Maybe in the future it will get looked at but I'm not going to hope for anything and given how awful this test was in the first place, I'm very happy to wait awhile. In the near future, I would pretty heavily support a tera blast ban (watch
ausma's video) and potentially a volc retest. Both would have the capacity to keep kyurem in check pretty nicely given that especially near the end of the suspect, I thought Kyu's best set by far was actually physical dd w tera blast.
I'm also very against a gliscor suspect test. I was on the fence on scor when Kyu was gone, but now that it's back I think a suspect on scor is a non-starter and I actually think would make the tier much worse, esp given that tera spdef scor is one of the best counters to subtect in the tier. Other then that, I'm not sure. Kyurem didn't really limit that much -- the stuff that Kyurem beats was still very good with it in the tier (grounds, zapdos, grasses like pons, teapot and apple) and was very good before it got banned so they're not getting worse. Stuff that was used to beat it like moltres, gking, tinkaton and steels in general were very good even with it gone too, so as to how much actually changes, I'm not sure besides stuff running more niche teras to check kyu and more explicit teching (i.e, pnoise gking, alluring voice clef, whatever).
It's a shame this went down the way it did. I barely mentioned the cheating but I'm more upset at the cheaters then most other folks because um, what the hell. OU will move on and i thought the meta was alright with Kyurem in it, but would be better without it. I'm just incredibly disappointed with a lot of people here however, and I think a lot of the folks involved should really look at themselves.