UltraSword said:it is easily revenge killed by either faster pokemon pokemon with priority moves and the pokemon that straight up wall it.
if your only reliable counterplay is being revenge killed that is a tell-tale sign of utter brokenness
UltraSword said:In the case of pokemon that are actual dedicated counters there are 2 pokemon that wall it completely in keldeo (who resists every move weavile normally runs and weighs enough for low kick to only have 60 bp against it) and scizor (both but especially mega scizor since both shake off all of weavile's moves fairly well threaten it with bullet punch and in the case of mega scizor can't have its item knocked off). There are other checks too like clefable (especially if you used pursuit or ice shard) breloom (Mach punch go brrrr) landorus therian (if you didn't use an ice move obviously) azumarill (honestly this borders on being a genuine counter as well but it doesn't like knock off that much) thundurus incarnate (who also doesn't like ice type moves and doesn't even one shot without focus blast but has priority thunder wave) and plenty of others that may be even better than the ones I mentioned.
keldeo? hates knock and dies in 3
azumarill? see above
thundurus? can never switch in and dies to the faster ice shard after rocks
clefable? is dead to a single flinch or is straight up 2hko'd if it has special defense investment for alakazam and diancie, etc
breloom? is dead to ice shard after rocks
landorus? can only come in on knock off and still takes huge damage, stuff in 3
you've missed bullet punch mega metagross, mega lopunny, volcanion, bisharp, skarmory and talonflame all of which either cannot switch in without losing their item and thus getting crippled (volcanion) taking at least 70% (lop, meta, talon) or straight up dying to flinch (skarmory) barring bisharp who suffers the same fate of keldeo
the only weavile counter is mega scizor. everything else is a check and cannot beat weavile over the course of a game but rather hope to slow it down
UltraSword said:Finally there is weavile's obvious weakness to stealth rock (and the biggest difference between oras and ss weavile) which makes it go from already frail to needing life support.
do not be deceived. firstly, weavile doesn't switch that much which limits it's susceptibility to being ruined by hazards and this coupled with the fact that hazard removal is not difficult to fit into oras (excadrill and zapdos and latias for offense teams do a fine job) makes weaviles life even easier and allows it more opportunities to abuse it's punisher role in the tier to broken levels
overall while yes you've made theorised good points as to why weavile shouldn't be considered broken, they do not hold up to the reality of the situation that time and time again shows where there is a weavile there is a way