Just A Seaking said:My take on HMs is that their removal in Gen 7 was a massive overreaction on Game Freak's part to criticism that could have easily been resolved just by making their requirements less harsh. It honestly baffles me that they immediately nixed them altogether after years of sticking with the same old rigid system rather than try to compromise on how they work even once.
Like Bakugames said, HMs were at their best in Gen 1. Each move had clear niches and were designed around specific thresholds in the game. The lack of HM removal was a problem since it was easy to saddle a carry like your starter with a crappy move for eternity, but other than that they were implemented perfectly well. Yet after that, besides adding an HM remover in Gen 3 (and I guess Stadium 2), HMs stayed rigidly fixed in place, while the number of HMs kept ballooning, culminating in dumb bullshit like Defog and Rock Climb in Gen 4. Even in Gen 5 and 6, where the reliance on HMs was heavily decreased (except Kalos Victory Road requiring Strength at the very last minute - that was a nasty surprise back in 2013), they never altered the moves themselves or alleviated the strict rules of "this move must take a move slot and you cannot forget it without going out of your way to do so". Then Gen 7 rolled around, and they were gone with no fanfare.
HMs implement two things that I regard as important: immersion, and friction. Poke Ride and other similar mechanics offer neither, because you're essentially handed the keys to someone else's Pokemon - one that appears after nowhere and vanishes as soon as the job is done. The actual progression is similar enough to HMs, but it makes all the difference that it's not your 'mon doing it. As for friction: I think it's not only fine but good that HMs take up moveslots, because it introduces opportunity cost. I need to use this move to progress - do I give it to a team member in place of a stronger 4th move, or do I hand it off to a weaker 'mon I've caught and have them take up a team slot? Friction isn't necessarily a bad thing - I think these kinds of restrictions can be interesting and lead to some neat player expression if handled properly. There is no such decision making to be had with Ride 'mons. The best form of it are the Raidons in SV, just because they're seamlessly implemented into the flow of the game and because the Raidons are distinctly your 'mon, but I just don't think it's as interesting.
So the problem the friction argument runs into for me is that it continues a trend I've felt since branching out from Pokemon into other RPG's when I was a Teenager: Pokemon teaches bad habits if you play it as an RPG or try to transplant habits from one to the other.
The most famous example of this is how most kids play the game: all attack moves, use every mon as a beater, probably just power leveling a few that hit hard already like their starter. Beaters win faster, so you're inclined to use them more immediately, they get more EXP, and it becomes a feedback loop. Meanwhile if you try to play an RPG like Dragon Quest, certain Final Fantasy entries, or something from Atlus in this manner (Persona or SMT), you're not going to get very far without using buffs and status effects to deal with asymmetrical stat systems that Pokemon lacks by nature. If you want proof, look at Tera Raids: players who bring full Support Pokemon (some of which can't inflict damage themselves) contribute significantly more than random players jumping in with their Level 100 Main story legendary or a fresh caught Mightiest Mark Pokemon when the battle has 4 much weaker targets up against a much stronger Tower.
HMs work in a similar manner, trying to have a give-and-take by tying your ability to progress to a handicap in battle for the areas where the field moves are required. The problem here becomes that kneecapping your Pokemon or having to constantly rotate the HM carriers in and out of your team isn't strategic so much as an inconvenience, which just led to running HM mules (find me a Sinnoh playthrough that doesn't run Bibarel and wouldn't be smoother if it did) and doubling down on the above mentioned "small team Unga EXP" loop to make up for being down a slot. The HMs are a failed system in that as designed they're not a crossroads for decision making, the optimal strategy is always just to compartmentalize and completely ignore the resources the system takes away from you because the moves are such garbage and so stuck to the user that you're just flat out making them worse than designed outside of Surf and some Strength/Waterfall users (and in that case it's mostly down to Water being a horribly balanced and overly abundant type which minimizes the "I'm not running one of these" scenario).
I have a particular comparison to make on this point as well: Final Fantasy 3 (original numbering, the NES game) was groundbreaking for many aspects such as the Job system that in several ways feels like what Pokemon was trying to emulate with Kanto's original design ethos: a spread of character types to build a team of multiple units from that you could rotate or replace on the fly (in some cases being strict upgrades over prior versions) at the expense of having to do additional grinding/leveling up to maintain more options for build flexibility. One of FF3's more infamous aspects is several sections in which you're made to utilize particular classes to continue (dungeons requiring the Physical-nerfing Mini status, casting Toad to enter certain areas, Garuda essentially saying "Dragoons or GTFO," the Dark Cave enemies that just multiply without a Mystic/Dark Knight weapon specifically) because it actively punishes you for not playing with the pieces the game wants you to use, and in several cases does not permit you to attempt unless you're going the one specific method they tell you to use (i.e. Mages for the Mini Dungeon). It even manages to encompass both HM situations because the Mini dungeons require being stuck playing it, Dark Cave has alternatives that are possible but significantly more tedious, and the Toad gates can also just be done by switching, casting Toad to go through, and then switching back (albeit with some trash grinding to get the Points to swap Jobs).
Ironically, despite Gen 1 being touted as the best usage of the mechanic overall (non-deletion aside), it's also the entry that scrapped what I think would have been the best compromise: using tools in your limited inventory vs an HM on your more flexible Pokemon slots. The tradeoff there instead is two different inconveniences rather than an inconvenience vs a straight nerf: do I carry an HM user, or give up a bag slot that I could use for TMs/Repels/Pokeballs during this dungeon visit? Mystery Dungeon had a similar approach where you could either bring a teammate with the move, or carry the HM and risk losing it to a failed run or trap in the Dungeon.