Soiramio3000 said:the rule against "double posting" vaguely says "do not double post";
this does not explain what "double posting" even is.
it is easy for someone to get the wrong idea that double posting is posting the same post twice, while in actuality the rule forbids two posts in a row.
so please rephrase the rule.
I got penalized for this and I know that other people have been penalized as well, so please re-phrase it so there will be less preventable penalizations.
The full rule in question:
Do not double post - edit your first one instead. Exceptions may occur if the thread you are posting on is a personal one such as an art thread, or if the thread is particularly inactive.
An interpretation of double post = repeat exact same post makes absolutely no sense with the context the rule adds beyond "do not double post". We always try our best to make our messaging clear for everyone, but we also feel it's fair to expect a little bit of reading comprehension on our users' end, and there gets to be a point where trying account for people reading only the first bit of a rule or otherwise removing the final 1% of potential for borderline intentional misreadings would take a disproportionate amount of staff's energy that we could use on much more relevant things. For the other penalised people you mentioned, it's more likely they were unaware of the rule outright so no amount of rephrasing would have saved them.
@ "civil double posts", the added context in the rule already makes it clear that the rule is not intended to punish people who are expressly not flooding or stream-of-consciousness posting, at least to the extent that it's not possible to take repeated reports in good faith. Codifying any and all specific exceptions is bad practice anyways, and it's better to let staff moderate with the rough circumstances in mind that a rule is meant to address.
Your third point is fair and we've tried to find ways to do it, but it's been impossible to pull off with the way xenforo handles bans. If at any point in the future something changes about the forum software to make it a practical option this will probably happen, but yea for now the current system is the only feasible one.
@ your fourth point / verbal warnings through alerts, like with any nudge/verbal warning both online and irl the idea is that you're supposed to (and can) simply memorise these, and even if alerts were saved for longer than they are now it does not seem exactly easier to remember to look there than to memorise the nudge in the first place. The way the system here works is simply one of very gradual increases; while you may be worried about an infraction if people do end up forgetting repeatedly, in a situation like that it'll just about always be a one-pointer which is in fact more in line with an on-the-record warning that does not at all affect people's forum experience, and the warning PM also doubles as the more permanent record of the warning that you seem to be asking for. If you as you say feel like a properly recorded warning is enough for people to learn for real, then this is also where things will end before anyone gets into any real trouble.