Magcargo said:So I'm probably not experienced in this format to say this, but it does feel like tiering action wise, we are at a stalemate.
Initial optics tell me that meta has largely settled around the same Garchomp / Corv / Gking / Dark (usually Samu) Core with 1 "broken" mega and a filler last. There are other team comps of course, but this one in particular seems like the easiest and most flexible one to build around.
As time passes, it does seem like Sneasler is becoming less & less of a problem with a fair blend of checks like Aegislash, Gking, and more underrated picks like Gliscoe serving aa a solid answer to it, on top of all the strong priority available from many Pokemon like Scizor. Espathra I think can be an OVERLY punishing mon if played poorly against but its various roadblocks like Dragapult or Aegislash are really tough nuts for it to crack and even if supported well, it does fluctuate between being busted and useless.
Easist mons to point as broken are Megas, but because a solid chunk of them feel about as broken as one another & mega competition is fierce, this too just feels more like a "given role" on a team where you can mix and match your busted mega of choice depending on what you want or vibe with. All of Floette, Charizard Y, Glimmora, and Meganium feel the same to me where - you won't have any really solid answers to them, but there are tools avaliable to play around them. I'd be lying if I said I thought any one was particularly more broken than the other.
The main mon I think might be broken in this format is Zard X because its better at outright sweeping + is just nuts all around with its power and speed for a DD sweeper (on top of Roost). However, I would still say its closer to the aforementioned tier of "broken megas" than to Ubers mon because it has the same fatal opportunity cost flaw & requires support for its own weaknesses like Rocks. I also dont even think its ban will change the meta at all because - by being a mega - its also competing for usage with other Pokemon heavily already. It is not as core of a tenant in the tier as much as a mon like - Corv or Chomp are.
I'm curious on hearing other people's opinions on this. Is there any tiering action that needs to or can be taken?
My read on the meta is similar. Most of the common megas (not just the ones you've mentioned, but also stuff like SD M-Lop, M-Phox, etc) distinctly lack sturdy counterplay and can often bulldoze past what options exist with appropriate team support/tech options. I also agree that Xard kinda stands out above the rest. Not only does it have limited defensive counterplay options, DD means there isn't much more in the way of offensive counterplay options, especially since even Adamant outruns Scarf Hamurott, and Roost helps with staying out of KO range from priority/scarfers. That said, it still doesn't feel unreasonable to keep around because between its hazard weakness, Flare Blitz recoil, and prominence of strong priority, even teams that are poorly prepped for it have options to outplay and win.
Espathra is dumb. I don't know that it's broken, but I still hate it. Speed Boost + Stored power is an inherently broken combo, and while there are hard answers, that just means Espathra is very matchup fishy. In some matches, there's a gambit in the back that you can't lure out, so it does nothing, while in other matches, it's given an inch and takes a mile. I like running Bold + Roost because it means chipping it down into priority range just doesn't work, and it gets freedom to set up on completely unreasonable things like SpDef Excadrill.
If I had to pick something to take action against, I'd say maybe hazards? With no boots and stuff like Hamurott and Glimmora running around, they can often feel overbearing, especially since options for removal are limited, and they often lose to common setters. I don't know what would be the best/most appropriate option, but banning mons for being too good at hazard vomit in pre-boots metas is hardly unprecedented.