SURVEY RESULTS
We received 45 responses this time around, 14 of them qualified. That's a great turnout, huge thanks to everyone who took the time to fill out the survey.
:happiny::happiny::happiny:
Enjoyment
Hide
- General: 7.33/10
- Qualified: 7.286/10
Overall reception of the metagame is comfortably positive, though there's still room for improvement.
:equilibra:
Competitiveness and Balance
Hide
- General: 6.822/10
- Qualified: 6.857/10
While reception leans positive, respondents clearly desire improvements. The scores, however, have improved since our last survey.
:deoxys-speed:
Deoxys-Speed
Hide
- General: 2.8/5
- Qualified: 2.93/5
The community remains divided, with no clear consensus emerging.
:garganacl:
Garganacl
Hide
- General: 2.244/5
- Qualified: 2.14/5
The playerbase generally believes Garganacl is acceptable in the metagame.
:Arceus-Ghost:
Arceus-Ghost
Hide
- General: 2.44/5
- Qualified: 2.57/5
Support for action exists, but it is not convincing enough to prioritize.
:Entei:
Entei
Hide
- General: 2.04/5
- Qualified: 2/5
Respondents overwhelmingly oppose taking action on Entei at this time.
:Archaludon:
Archaludon
Hide
- General: 3.2/5
- Qualified: 2.786/5
Opinion leans towards taking action, though consensus has not yet been reached. The qualified section in particular remains fairly split on Archaludon.
:Blissey::chansey:
Victreebellite
Hide
- General: 2.733/5
- Qualified: 2.28/5
There's a noticeable difference in opinion between the qualified respondents and the overall playerbase regarding this element, with qualified players being considerably less supportive of tiering action.
:zamazenta:
Zamazenta
Hide
- General: 2.31/5
- Qualified: 2.21/5
Most respondents do not currently favor tiering action on Zamazenta.
:gengar:
Gengar Retest
Hide
The playerbase has shown strong interest in revisiting this element. There is clear support for conducting a retest.
:gholdengo:
Gholdengo Retest
Hide
Although opinions differ on Gholdengo, nearly 70% of respondents expressed some level of openness to a retest. This suggests that revisiting Gholdengo in the future would not be unpopular, but it shouldn't be our priority.
:Red orb:
Red Orb Retest
Hide
A majority of respondents are open to a Red Orb retest. While only a third explicitly support one, many others indicated they would not oppose revisiting Red Orb despite believing it should ultimately remain banned.
:Giratina:
Giratina Retest
Hide
Too much blue.
:ursaluna bloodmoon:
Ursaluna-BM Retest
Hide
There is little appetite for an Ursaluna-BM retest at this time. While many respondents would not oppose revisiting it in the future, explicit support for a retest is significantly outweighed by those who believe it should remain banned.
:kyogre:
Kyogre Retest
Hide
Results are very mixed for Kyogre. A retest is not out of the question in the future, but now's not the correct time.
Note
You may have noticed I didn't post qualified charts for unban suspects bar Gengar. That's because a) they didn't receive noticeable support and b) I didn't want to upset Smogon by attaching too many charts (my draft got deleted the other day as I was writing this). If anyone wants detailed stats and graphs, however, feel free to ping/DM me and I'll send them to you)
Other Mentions (Comments section)
why are you reading this
don't read...
OK fine read it
Qualified People:
- Free Pidgeotite
- Suspect Last Respects
- Don't do anything until September 2
- Free Regigas
- Free Slaking
- Free Iron Bundle
- Playing mag tusk mirrors legit feel like brainrot
- Hiiii zastra and anyone else reading this, hope you have a good day! (This one's my favorite)
- Retest Koraidon
- Suspect Zygardite
- Suspect Tera
Others:
- Ban Zygardite (again)
- Suspect Extreme Speed
- Free Regigigas (again)
- Suspect Dragalgite
- Unban Last Respects
- Suspect zastra's OMPL record (This one's my least favorite)
- Pidgeotite suspect (again)
- If we're talking about Giratina, what about Lugia? (Sure feel free to talk about it #freedomofspeech)
- Suspect Walking Wake
- Suspect Solgaleo
- Unban Malamarite
So... What Next?
:bw/gengar:
| Gengar | QT | zastra | Sammy | seraphz | ass | Verdict |
|---|
:gengar: | Resuspect | Quick-unban | Resuspect | Resuspect | Resuspect | RESUSPECT |
We've decided to retest Gengar!
Ultimately, we didn't feel there was a clear standout for a ban or restriction. Archaludon was the only element to cross the 3.0 mark, though its support was noticeably lower among the experienced playerbase. Additionally, recent metagame developments such as the ban of Last Respects and the rise of Regenerator users, particularly Dragalgite Ting-Lus, have made life considerably difficult for Archaludon and rain. There was, however, overwhelming support for a Gengar retest, so we'll be moving forward with that for now.
(If you're wondering why I didn't vote for a resuspect like the rest of the council, I felt quick-unbanning Gengar and suspecting it later if it proved problematic was a better approach for saving time. A straight retest is completely reasonable though)
Expect the suspect to go up within the next few days. Thanks again for all the responses, have a great day