• Follow our Instagram!
  • Curious about what we're currently doing about bots? Check out the latest updates from staff in this thread.

Unpopular opinions

If we're discussing the decent-power basic moves as on the table for distribution nerfs, I think Shadow Ball should also be considered. Ghost feels like it's trying to have a status-focused identity, but the ability to run unconditional STAB with few resists detracts from that. Forcing a few more Ghosts to rely on Hex instead could help to swing that around. If that sort of coverage is desperately needed on a non-Ghost mon, you could just give them Dark Pulse instead (Dark definitely has its own problems with boring moves overshadowing interesting moves, but it's confined to the physical side).

I guess I'm still mad we got No Guard Hawlucha-Mega to use the "unviable" High Jump Kick instead of No Guard Chandelure-Mega with Inferno as its Hex enabler.
 
I still think Normal type should be buffed, and I think it resisting/being immune to Fairy has a lot of thematic sense to it, but I think that Normal type actually works the second you remove Focus Blast from the occasion. Ghost is a very overtuned type that only got better with the lost of Pursuit, but, just like Dragon being extremely spammable prior to gen 6, it having a single immunity in Fairy has hindered it immensely, and many Dragons do not have reasonably secondary coverage to use against them. Calyrex-S in VGC (and BDSP OU with the best Ghost there being Mismagius) feels like proof that, without Fighting coverage, Normal actually becomes a feasible option and simply significantly reducing the movepool of Focus Blast would help wonders with improving the viability of the Normal type.
 
1789693013079.png

I got some things about TM distribution and type identities I gotta get off my chest.
AztecCroc said:
That's because they're either objectively bad and saw no use even before Close Combat existed and was widespread (Superpower, Cross Chop) or may as well be unless the Pokémon's got a very specific combo of traits (Dynamic Punch) or else they're only available to basically no one (High Jump Kick, Axe Kick).
First of all, this is ridiculous. Superpower did see a noticeable amount of play because it got turned into a Tutor move in Gen 4. Most things that got Cross Chop also ran it because it's great coverage, despite being essentially Stone Edge.

Fighting coverage has always been in high demand, that's why mons still run Focus Blast.
Genuine_Angus_B33F said:
Fighting as a type had a sort of "every pokemon has a signature set of techniques" thing going on in earlier generations.
And this was good. The unfortunate part of it is that the moves themselves often had drawbacks without proper compensation, but you nailed it. Excellent post.

Superpower getting its toes stepped on by Close Combat shows why it was a good Tutor move. Every Fighting-type would rather run CC over it if they can, so for it to have a niche, it'd need better distribution than CC.

QuickBH said:
I still think Normal type should be buffed, and I think it resisting/being immune to Fairy has a lot of thematic sense to it, but I think that Normal type actually works the second you remove Focus Blast from the occasion. Ghost is a very overtuned type that only got better with the lost of Pursuit, but, just like Dragon being extremely spammable prior to gen 6, it having a single immunity in Fairy has hindered it immensely, and many Dragons do not have reasonably secondary coverage to use against them. Calyrex-S in VGC (and BDSP OU with the best Ghost there being Mismagius) feels like proof that, without Fighting coverage, Normal actually becomes a feasible option and simply significantly reducing the movepool of Focus Blast would help wonders with improving the viability of the Normal type.
Normal used to be a type with strong moves to compensate they couldn't ever hit SE, and insane coverage as their identity.

Then they lost their best physical STAB in Return, got zero compensation for it, everything got absurd coverage, and Close Combat is spammed everywhere.

Normal is getting smoked from all sides and is an underrated contender for worst type in the game.
Ironmage said:
If we're discussing the decent-power basic moves as on the table for distribution nerfs, I think Shadow Ball should also be considered.
I actually disagree on that one. 75~80BP is a good threshold for coverage moves. It's a hard sell to say that Ghost should get better moves, but this ties into my next point.



Types should have exclusive moves. Ice is a good example of this. Aurora Veil, Freeze-Dry... these give real niches to the type, it's something you can't get anywhere else. For years, the best Ice-type was a Water-type with Ice Beam. No more. They've slowly but surely been buffed. Still bad, but unique.

TMs should be bland, unimpressive coverage moves, not optimal options. Close Combat should NEVER have been a TM.
 
Has anyone mentioned Fire yet as a Type that might need some looking at? I don’t know how you would rebalance Fire’s matchups, but it’s quietly been arguably the most influential Type of Gen 9 even before then, I feel like Heavy-Duty Boots and weather push Fire over the edge. It helps that we’ve also gotten a ton of really strong Fire-Types in more recent generations and buffs to already existing ones.
 
bdt2002 said:
Has anyone mentioned Fire yet as a Type that might need some looking at? I don’t know how you would rebalance Fire’s matchups, but it’s quietly been arguably the most influential Type of Gen 9 even before then, I feel like Heavy-Duty Boots and weather push Fire over the edge. It helps that we’ve also gotten a ton of really strong Fire-Types in more recent generations and buffs to already existing ones.
Nah, Fire is fine. Plenty of common weaknesses.
 
Superpower is and always has been a completely fine move to use as Fighting coverage and was very good throughout Gens 4-7.

It's not as spammable as Close Combat and demands a more hit and run strategy but it's a very good power move that tended to be popular as coverage and even as STAB in some cases to deliver a powerful blow, even if the Attack drop weakens raw output per turn in consecutive hits. But it is by no means bad.

If anything I actually like it as a contrast flavor wise to Close Combat and I think both should have more limited but split distributions. Superpower is one hard blow of concentrated power which works for things like Emboar and Throh while Close Combat is a rapid flurry of punches and kicks, which fits things like Sawk and Infernape.

And that's not to mention the funny use of Contrary Superpower which is hilarious on things like Malamar, even if Malamar is kind of shit otherwise.
 
ScraftyIsTheBest said:
Superpower is and always has been a completely fine move to use as Fighting coverage and was very good throughout Gens 4-7.

It's not as spammable as Close Combat and demands a more hit and run strategy but it's a very good power move that tended to be popular as coverage and even as STAB in some cases to deliver a powerful blow, even if the Attack drop weakens raw output per turn in consecutive hits. But it is by no means bad.

If anything I actually like it as a contrast flavor wise to Close Combat and I think both should have more limited but split distributions. Superpower is one hard blow of concentrated power which works for things like Emboar and Throh while Close Combat is a rapid flurry of punches and kicks, which fits things like Sawk and Infernape.

And that's not to mention the funny use of Contrary Superpower which is hilarious on things like Malamar, even if Malamar is kind of shit otherwise.
I think Superpower would be a great "Generic Fighting" coverage TM. For actual Fighting types, I think they can get a bit spicier.

Angus mentioned this earlier, but Fighting used to have moves that would reflect the idea of different martial arts and how attacks were different. I think this could be leaned on to make Fighting mons stand out from one another. I'd consider making a Fighting move that works like Gyro Ball for slow, bulky grappler-type Pokémons to have a strong offense without sacrificing bulk with CC spam.
 
One other big issue I find with Close Combat is that giving it such a massive distribution really causes powercreep to become much worse.
If everyone can learn the same move and you need it you’ll just always default to whoever can use it the strongest just about every time.

It’s very much a case of ‘if everyone is super, nobody is’.

Plus it just kills off the flavour that is showing off the many fighting techniques the type embodies. Before it was dozens of different spices, now it’s all salt.
 
It doesn't really help that close combat is honestly a very generic move with generic applications. it's not a martial arts, its literally just going hail mary and attacking the foe with whatever you have in close proximity. anything can do that

so yknow what. close combat should be a normal type move
 
Close Combat I think should be closer to what Wild Charge and Volt Tackle are the Physical Electric types (albeit with better distribution than the latter gets as STAB). As in the generic coverage move ought to be more middle of the road power and the massive nuclear option reserved for level up or lore focused distribution.

CC as an 85-90 BP move with the debuffs that gets wide distribution would be significantly less gross to me, and compared to Electric, Fighting is a very strong Offensive type so it can survive on mediocre BP while hitting key targets. Where Wild Charge fails is that it's barely passable as a standard STAB move as it's distributed, having below average Power for a Main Drawback move, something Fighting damage struggles much less with.

Then the 120 BP version is reserved for Fighting Pokemon or those with very overt design motifs in Fighting styles like Incineroar maybe. A real fighter going for dangerous and desperate moves probably still hits more effectively than any old Joe on adrenaline flailing at an opponent.

It's the root of the issue in my eyes at least: Close Combat is designed as the gameplay "you just need a loose reason to get it" move akin to Thunderbolt/Flamethrower/Ice Beam on Special Attackers (which have their own questionable ease of access but one move at a time), but it has the high power and negligible drawback design of a signature or narrow distribution move compared to, say, Focus Blast on Special Attackers (Fairy, Ghost, Dark, in fact almost every Specially-biased type is resisted by Steel for example). It almost feels like the kind of sequence we had with VT -> Wild Charge except they just distributed the high power version instead of making a weaker-common one.
 
Bakugames said:
It doesn't really help that close combat is honestly a very generic move with generic applications. it's not a martial arts, its literally just going hail mary and attacking the foe with whatever you have in close proximity. anything can do that

so yknow what. close combat should be a normal type move
Genuinely that'd be kinda fire. Would give another strong Normal option for those who don't want recoil, while also not just being Return, which was very much "the Close Combat of Normal moves but even more egrigious"
 
DrPumpkinz said:
Genuinely that'd be kinda fire. Would give another strong Normal option for those who don't want recoil, while also not just being Return, which was very much "the Close Combat of Normal moves but even more egrigious"
thats what im saying, and its not like normal coverage is Good so it'd realistically only be used on normal types who are on life support rn if they don't have another good secondary type. It makes the lowered defenses much more drastic when you move it to a type that isn't going to ohko/2hko as much as fighting would. also means superpower will be the premier coverage which is more fun i loooove superpower
 
Bakugames said:
It doesn't really help that close combat is honestly a very generic move with generic applications. it's not a martial arts, its literally just going hail mary and attacking the foe with whatever you have in close proximity. anything can do that

so yknow what. close combat should be a normal type move
That's why Mega Punch and Mega Kick are Normal: they're attacks with a lot of power behind them, but they're untrained and unrefined (hence the miss chance). Given CC's defenses reduction, I think it would fit right in here.
 
Volt-Ikazuchi said:
Been telling y'all that Game Freak needs to go sicko mode with the nerf bat...
Thing is, it's not one or even a number of nerfs that are needed. I've been saying since Dexit, soft Dexit isn't enough. If they're going to reset everything, fully reset it. Start over with a fundamental understanding of what a fully-evolved stat spread should look like, what a "baseline attacking move for X type" should look like, etc, and then rebuild every mon/move/mechanic from the ground up to match that.

Fundamentally, and I see this a lot in esports, they are trying to balance the game with no clue what a balanced mon or balanced meta looks like. So instead the devs just make changes whenever something seems powerful or weak, and that can work, but it's slow and prone to mistakes. And slowly balancing isn't great when every few years you drop 100 new characters, revise everyone's kit, and introduce a new mechanic. Especially when a decent chunk of the changes are not "this was OP" but "this was balanced but less fun for viewers to watch".

Start over, wipe the board clean, and figure out what power level to shoot for on individual mons and what play pattern you want the meta to look like. And then build mons to that power level and to encourage those play patterns. That way, it can be very visually obvious when something is deviating from that mark and you can move things back in line. Instead they're just playing whack-a-mole with problems and half the time it's not even clear which mon on a 4-mon core is the actual thing to whack.
 
Hugin said:
Start over, wipe the board clean, and figure out what power level to shoot for on individual mons and what play pattern you want the meta to look like. And then build mons to that power level and to encourage those play patterns. That way, it can be very visually obvious when something is deviating from that mark and you can move things back in line. Instead they're just playing whack-a-mole with problems and half the time it's not even clear which mon on a 4-mon core is the actual thing to whack.
I couldn't think of a worse era to chrysalis competitive Pokemon in than gen 9 COMBINED with gen 6 megas. It's a level of power creep hell that's makes Yugioh look tame and they've put themselves in a corner where they have to use this as the example and need to push FURTHER from here. Interviews confirm that they intend to dripfeed as long as possible which means it will take a long time before they even begin actually adjusting things fundamentally. If Champions wants to hype up Gen 10 Pokemon they need to make gen 9 Pokemon look tame (or powercreep Pokemon like Incineroar) or esport watchers will just get extremely bored.
 
I mean, isn't this pretty much what they have done in both Legends games?

Both of them feature a independant combat system with significant rebalances and changes.

I don't think you can remotely do this with a ongoing e-sport: part of what makes it work is recognizability, I don't need to know anything of the current balance of the game to know what is strong against what and what each player is expected to do, but it works decently in sidegames.
 
Last edited:
Hugin said:
Thing is, it's not one or even a number of nerfs that are needed. I've been saying since Dexit, soft Dexit isn't enough. If they're going to reset everything, fully reset it. Start over with a fundamental understanding of what a fully-evolved stat spread should look like, what a "baseline attacking move for X type" should look like, etc, and then rebuild every mon/move/mechanic from the ground up to match that.

Fundamentally, and I see this a lot in esports, they are trying to balance the game with no clue what a balanced mon or balanced meta looks like. So instead the devs just make changes whenever something seems powerful or weak, and that can work, but it's slow and prone to mistakes. And slowly balancing isn't great when every few years you drop 100 new characters, revise everyone's kit, and introduce a new mechanic. Especially when a decent chunk of the changes are not "this was OP" but "this was balanced but less fun for viewers to watch".

Start over, wipe the board clean, and figure out what power level to shoot for on individual mons and what play pattern you want the meta to look like. And then build mons to that power level and to encourage those play patterns. That way, it can be very visually obvious when something is deviating from that mark and you can move things back in line. Instead they're just playing whack-a-mole with problems and half the time it's not even clear which mon on a 4-mon core is the actual thing to whack.
Yeah, honestly, that's what they need to do.

Start with moves and their distribution. Changing one move affects several mons. Removing one TM alters entire metagames.

Some mechanics also need to be changed, like evasion. Status conditions need a rework across the board.

Then we can start talking about Base Stats.

Drip-fed individual adjustments won't really work because there are too many mons and several of them are straight up busted.

And even then, you have to accept that the game won't ever be balanced, and the best you can realistically aim for is a tiered-approach, with many mons being relegated to having their niche be tied to in-game utility.
 
Made a crazy long Xerneas / Fairy / Dazzling Gleam Post here and have a thought I want to attach that didn't neatly fit.

Sylveon is an industry plant to such an absurd degree that I really do not like it despite it being a mostly inoffensive visual design and a contextually alright gameplay design. Pixilate Hyper Voice is head and shoulders above both anything the other Eeveelutions have out of the box and the standard non-Legendary Fairy types of each game. It isn't usually an overwhelming presence, but because it is in every single game past its introduction, the thorough outclassing of a majority of generic Fairy types is super lame to me, and it sets a really high power floor with its pretty much perfect stat allocation and high damage.
 
Genuine_Angus_B33F said:
Made a crazy long Xerneas / Fairy / Dazzling Gleam Post here and have a thought I want to attach that didn't neatly fit.

Sylveon is an industry plant to such an absurd degree that I really do not like it despite it being a mostly inoffensive visual design and a contextually alright gameplay design. Pixilate Hyper Voice is head and shoulders above both anything the other Eeveelutions have out of the box and the standard non-Legendary Fairy types of each game. It isn't usually an overwhelming presence, but because it is in every single game past its introduction, the thorough outclassing of a majority of generic Fairy types is super lame to me, and it sets a really high power floor with its pretty much perfect stat allocation and high damage.
The hilarious part to me there is the Champions hindsight, where Sylveon in most Gens is at best a lower-tier or niche pick, and then the Gen where it's a major option because of a limited roster, it's competing with a one-of-a-kind not-necessarily-but-basically Legendary Pokemon.

Like they made it a plant with a bunch of higher numbers and well distributed stats, and yet it rarely finds success in competitive (where it matters to be better instead of "good enough" against the opponents) because they did it in such a boring way of BIGGER instead of a toolkit (which remains a persistent shortcoming of how the Eeveelutions are designed in general).
 
TerrickTerran said:
People are always pleading for new Eeveelutions but they're just variations of each other. The restrictions on stats and moves is crippling at this point.


The restriction on Stats? Maybe, though if correctly distributed they are still serviceable. Clefable and Kingdra have worse Stats, but thanks to their abilities they have been viable from Gen 2 to Gen 9 (except in Gen 3, in which Clefable is almost unusable).

The restriction in movepool has been decreased in recent generation, especially 9th:

-Every Eeveelution gained Calm Mind, Weather Ball, Trailblaze, Roar and Alluring Voice. Of course, not all of them can use it equally well, but those are all good moves.

-Vaporeon didn,t gain much more than that, but retained Scald, while many Water Mons lost the move.

-Jolteon didn,t gain anything else, but CM + Alluring Voice was enough for some guy to peak the ladder with it: https://www.smogon.com/forums/threads/jolteons-rise-to-glory-peaked-1-2065-elo-and-88-5-gxe.3767669/

-Flareon lost Superpower and keeps being the worst of the bunch. There is little hope for it with that Stat distribution. However, its the only Pokemon in the whole Dex (excluding Smeargle) that learns Calm Mind, Lava Plume and Wish, so thats something.

-Espeon gained Thunder Wave and Psychic Noise. Many Mons have those, but Espeon keeps being one of the rare holders of the great Magic Bounce ability, it will always have some niche. I personally used this Mon and did pretty well in OU with it.

-Umbreon gained Thunder Wave and retained Toxic, a move almost the whole Dex lost, outside of Poison Mons. There is definetely room for improvement (Knock Off and Parting Shot could make Umbreon even better), but this is a very legit Mon and trusted it in the finals of Wcop of 2023 (it was a terrible game from both sides, but I still won).

-Nothing to be said about Leafeon. Stats and typing don,t allow it to do much, but the movepool is certainly good here.

-Glaceon gained Mud Shot. Weak as this move is, its relevant, because with 130 Special Attack, Fire and Steel types want to switch to take those Ice moves, but Mud Shot hits them hard.

-Sylveon gained Psychic, though it lost Mystical Fire. It already had Psyshock, but Psychic is stronger. It has been doing well in VGC.

I believe there is still big potential for both current and future Eeveelution. They have been improving, slowly but steadily and they still have some use after all these years. I do think that having a 3rd ability would help (especially when we consider that actual Eevee has 3). As long as movepool thing keeps getting well adressed, we can have new Eeveelution. Maybe regional variants for all 8 could introduce physical types.
 
Back
Top