I don't know if this fits the format of this thread but I'm still going to yap about the thoughts.
Xerneas is so incredibly depressing to me. The entire gameplay design of this pokemon in practice is just Fairy Aura and Geomancy. Fairy Aura as a damage multiplier on an already strong STAB type is a huge streamlining force on the design already, making any coverage move that doesn't actively deal Super Effective damage to a relevant foe completely worthless. Then Geomancy takes this already streamlined gameplay function and further streamlines it to the point of absurdity as it is rendered complete and utter 2 piece combo merchant with Power Herb. In singles it at least has situational benefits when running sets that utilize choice items, which by relative necessity run 4 distinct attacking moves, but even there it will often use filler like Sleep Talk or Aromatherapy to fill out moveslots because nobody is confused on the show they're here to see when they bring a Xerneas into battle. In doubles, it isn't even that vaired. You pretty much always run Moonblast, Dazzling Gleam, Protect, and Geomancy with the required Power Herb, and if the metagame produced something you couldn't bowl over with that exact set you sat in a corner and cried. I've complained before that I don't tend to like Mega Pokemon due to being restricted in variety by lacking an item and often being pigeon-holed into specific moves as a result of lacking an item, and Doubles Xerneas has less set variety than many Mega Pokemon in practice despite technically being allowed to hold other items. It is in my mind a significant step towards the general Offense creep of the game amongst legendary Pokemon, a line which divides the sometimes Offensive-leaning but usually just massively statted box-art legends of the older games from the BST Optimized, steroid boosted, deliberately manufactured, terminology juiced, big red button mashing modern game mascots. Even past beyond that trend though, it's not unreasonable to think that several of the future frontrunners were built to try and step up to Xerneas's obscenely high level or deliberately act as a metagame plant stopgap to it. (In XY, the only Pokemon above 600 BST that could resist Fairy attacks without holding a Mega Stone or Arceus Plate was Ho-oh!) Xerneas is at minimum a transcendentally defining gameplay design for the modern era of Pokemon, and I would personally go further in calling it the standout misstep.
But it didn't really have to be this way. When you take Geomancy and Fairy Aura out of Xerneas, you can start to see a picture form of a much more interesting gameplay design that could have been. Like for instance, did you know Xerneas has equal Attack and Special Attack? You'd never really think to see Physical Xerneas due to just how overbearingly dominant the influence of Moonblast / Dazzling Gleam / Geomancy is on Xerneas's gameplay but it does get Play Rough and has even teched moves like Close Combat and Rock Slide on some extremely rare occasions in Singles for Blissey and Ho-oh respectively. Even beyond just being a physical attacker, we almost had a little prototype Iron Valiant-esqe mixed attacker here with Moonblast and Close Combat as main attacking moves with a wide pool of coverage to pull from alongside decent utility and setup options. I wish that could have been Xerneas' ultimate focus, but I can also see that
just pulling Geomancy and Fairy Aura out from underneath it does leave a bit of a void. There is room for there to be something special about Xerneas aside from just absurd damage numbers.
Another disappointing thing in Generation 6, at least insofar as it existed at that point, was Terrains. It's fairly easy to forget that Grassy, Misty, and Electric Terrain were even in Generation 6 because they are so completely disjointed from any relevance in any realm the game is played in. The extremely obvious reason for this is simply that the Terrain Surge abilities are not in the game whatsoever, but there were no Terrain Seeds or Terrain Extender to utilize for additional synergies, and the users of manual terrain moves are sparse in number, poor in quality, and lacking in any kind of disjoint from their type's respective flavor base to give some kind of reason to use them outside of needlessly stacking a specific type. Thinking about how depreciated Terrains are as a mechanic in Gen 6, I've spent multiple nights awake wondering about what Terrains were meant to be in these games.
So today, a rare day where these two brainworm addled thoughts have come together to haunt me over my day, I have a lot of thoughts on how these two game elements may have had a deeply intertwined and tumultuous relationship during the Generation 6's development. What if Xerneas was initially meant to have a Terrain Setting ability? What if the reason it was shelved was due to the awkward gameplay dynamics in the games' final legendary triplet? And what is the connective tissue between all of this?
To establish this, I want to first look at the effects of Terrains
- Electric Terrain amplifies Electric Type damage and prevents Pokemon on the field from falling sleep.
- Grassy Terrain amplifies Grass Type damage, heals Pokemon for 1/16th of their Max HP each turn, and reduces the damage of Earthquake by half.
- Misty Terrain halves the damage of Dragon Type attacks and prevents Pokemon from being afflicted with status conditions.
These design choices, in my view, are all made with intention. As much as Terrains ended up a depreciated mechanic in the final product of Generation 6, it's clear they were drafted in response to the trends of Generation 5. Two of the terrains directly address Sleep specifically, which was extremely strong in Gen 5. Grassy Terrain directly addresses Earthquake, which was especially notable in the wake of a VGC format in Ground type offense was especially dominant thanks to Landorus-Therian, Garchomp, Mamoswine, and Excadrill among others. Misty Terrain blocking Confusion and Paralysis are especially relevant given the near ubiquitous use of Thunder Wave and Swagger sets in VGC formats.
Electric and Grass type damage multipliers are largely just functions which make these fields worth setting, similar to Rain and Sun. (This was prior to the Terrain Nerfs, so they were 1.5* multipliers) Both do hold a small amount of contextual relevance as buffs. By the time of Generation 5 in particular a noticeable quality gap had developed between the Electric types that were not grounded and the ones that were. Even ignoring the inherent synergy in throwing off usual ways to check Electric as a type by detaching their defensive weaknesses from their offensive shortcomings, Pokemon like the Rotom Appliances, Zapdos, and Thundurus were just
better than others like Raikou and Kantonian Raichu, and Electric Terrain acting as a tool to buff only the grounded Electric types without applying to the already strong Flying / Levitating ones was an important nuance. The idea with Grass types is a bit more loose, but a buff focusing on relatively weak Grass type damage rather than the already strong Grass type utility tools makes sense as a choice. (To some extent, even just applying to Grounded Pokemon was a notable choice - there were lots of powerful and defining Levitate Pokemon at the time!)
Which leads to Misty Terrain. Where Electric and Grassy Terrains give a damage boost to a relevant type, Misty Terrain gives a nerf to Dragon type damage... which Fairy, the type Misty Terrain is associated with, is already immune to. Being associated with the Fairy type and having threadbare flavor associations otherwise, the only pokemon to learn Misty Terrain without any extant connection to the Fairy type (to this day!) are Meowstic-Male, Alomomola, Volcanion, and the Quaxly line. As it would be used in Generation 6, Misty Terrain as a move is just... weird, complicated Safeguard. Today the Dragon Type damage debuff is third to using the move to cancel out opposing Terrain or activate an ally's Terrain Seed. At the time, I guess that would have been the selling point of the move? Without an attached damage multiplier to it, this move is uniquely useless, redundant, and obscure. I didn't really know how to understand it.
Then, someone pointed out to me that nothing about Misty Terrain requires the existence of the Fairy type. And that the Dragon type debuff portion of the mechanic would arguably make more sense in Generation 5, a game filled to the brim with game warping Dragon type offense, than in any generation afterwards... which all have the Fairy type, which not only directly fills the defensive function of taking Dragon type attacks but also does so without needing a damage reduction multiplier given they have an immunity, but also passively dissuades many of the greediest Dragon damage spamming strategies that were common prior to Fairy types existing. If the flavor disconnect was solved somehow, maybe by associating Misty Terrain with Flying, Ghost, or Ice types, the move could exist with 0 implementation issues and would be a reasonably fleshed out mechanic on it's own. That to me is a compelling idea! It's clear the design changes around Misty Terrain's implementation did not age well with the trends of the game, but such is the reality of introducing volleys of gameplay changes in bursts every few years.
This focus on existing without the Fairy type does lead me back to Xerneas, and whether or not Misty Surge Xerneas makes sense. Most obviously, it would be a very team-support focused ability, blocking status and disabling enemy Dragon offense for allies. Even just blocking Poison, Sleep, and Paralysis for itself is a boon though, and allowing it to start using Calm Mind without being crippled would be a big deal. But it would
also make some sense for Xerneas to get Grassy Surge instead. Flavorfully, it being an avatar of life does somewhat reflect growing a field of Grass that provides healing for allies, and it even appears in a wooded glade in the splash art of the game. It would also be a fairly unique gameplay effect, giving Xerneas a second Offensive typing and turn by turn healing. The fantasy and overall defensive properties in terms of gameplay make even more sense to me with Grassy Terrain, and while it definitely wasn't a part of the original concept, the idea of a Xerneas centralized around Grassy Seed + Calm Mind combo sets is much more appealing to me personally. Either angle has potential to me.
The big problem I am having with this thought, which I am guessing was also relevant to the designers, was fitting a dynamic with Yveltal and Zygarde into this framing. When introducing new field conditions, especially ones activated on Switch-In, it only really brings interesting dynamics when field conditions can overwrite one another and introduce push and pull. Neither Grassy and Electric Terrains really don't fit either of them, and being a Flying type anyway Yveltal doesn't really seem fit to usher in any kind of Terrain effect, at which point Zygarde would sort of struggle to find a way to be the negator of both of their things. Even if Zygarde utterly fails to act as a gameplay foil to Xerneas and Yveltal in practice, it on paper does have Aura Break which is designed to do
something to them, and I struggle to think of a way to organically include a negation interaction for Zygarde without making something up entirely and without a concrete thought about fitting Yveltal into this thought experiment I don't have enough to build with.
For another tangent, let's talk about Dazzling Gleam. Can we talk about Dazzling Gleam? I've been dying to talk about Dazzling Gleam. I've got a corkboard with this move on it because I'm trying really hard to understand its place in the game.
Like a lot of moves which are newly introduced to a game as TMs, Dazzling Gleam was exclusively learnable via TM in its introductory Generation. It acts as sort of a gap filler between Draining Kiss at 50 BP and Moonblast at 95 in singles, and is almost comically unremarkable. But in Doubles, it is kind of randomly the premier spread damage move. 80 BP on a spread move is just respectable, but that paired with 100% Accuracy is downright unheard of. The only move which really compares is... Hyper Voice.
So there's a weird thing with Fairy Types in Gen 6. Sylveon and Mega Gardevoir were both introduced in XY with Pixilate, and Mega Altaria followed in ORAS. For Sylveon and Mega Gardevoir in particular, their defining gameplay trait is Pixilate boosted Hyper Voices, which alongside Gen 6 Pixilate do damage equivalent to an absurd 117 BP for a move with STAB; in later Generations the Pixilate nerf would see this be toned down to a still remarkable 108 BP. In Singles, this is strong but not excessively overstated. In Doubles, this is by far the best combination of Strength and Consistency for a spread move in the entire game, and is an extreme outlier of hilarious proportions. For context, Make it Rain was introduced in Gen 9 at 120 BP and 100% Accuracy, making it easily the strongest non-conditional 100% accurate spread move in the game, even if it did come with a -1 SpAtk drop downside. This was later nerfed to 95% Accuracy and a -2 SpAtk drop after use in Champions. In my opinion, Make it Rain at it's best was arguably still worse than Pixilate Hyper Voice is now at its worst. And at the time it was introduced, it was a tool exclusive to a handful of the game's very strongest non-Xerneas Fairies - Mega Gardevoir is the game's strongest Fairy type attacker even without considering Pixilate Hyper Voice, and while there are a handful of non-Megas which eclipse Sylveon's raw Special Attack, the power of Pixilate + Hyper Voice ends up higher than those Fairies' Moonblast against single targets.
Basically, I wonder to what extent Pixilate Hyper Voice on these Fairies and Dazzling Gleam were considered in relation to each other. It's not like Hyper Voice isn't the most obvious move to look towards when considering a Special Attacker with an ability that benefits from having Normal moves, Hyper Voice was distributed to everything via tutor in earlier games. With Eevee you can at least understand that Sylveon with Pixilate is going to be a postgame only Hidden Ability and will work as a midgame option to boost Swift or Quick Attack, but for Gardevoir there is not even a tertiarily relevant Normal type attack that is learned by Level Up or Breeding or anything - it's just Hyper Beam and Hyper Voice from Tutors. That has to have been the point. There is no decisive evidence on the order of the creation of these two game elements, but if I had to make a guess I'd lean towards Pixilate Hyper Voice coming first and Dazzling Gleam being a later addition when it was realized that anything without Moonblast would be left without effective Special Fairy damage, in particular with Togekiss which probably has still not gotten Moonblast for Serene Grace balancing reasons. It would also sort of explain why Dazzling Gleam was made so strong, because if it was being measured in comparison to these Pixilate monsters it would need to reach a pretty high bar to not look pathetic. Also Dazzling Gleam is very nearly the final TM in the game, TM 99 out of 100.
Anyway, if any of that is the case, I don't think Dazzling Gleam on Xerneas was fully considered because it is what really makes it broken beyond belief in Doubles. Geomancy is a potent boosting tool, but if Xerneas was only able to target one foe at a time it would end up a lot more handleable than it ended up, being more reliant on predictions and more suspect to outplay. Boosting Sweepers with Strong, Consistent Spread Damage are only really kept in check by requiring Speed control support and having a low damage ceiling, and Geomancy alongside Xerneas' over the top Special Attack with Fairy Aura just shatter that paradigm. And if it was overlooked because it was suddenly changed into a multiplier stack exploiting fiend from something with a less offensive ability, I would not be all too surprised.
TL:DR; I hate Xerneas because it is dead simple. I think at one point it might have had Grassy Surge or Misty Surge as an ability. I think Dazzling Gleam probably wasn't considered in Xerneas' balance and was a very late addition to XY.
*
What about Dark Aura?
Dark Aura on Yveltal ends up not being as big of a problem as Fairy Aura is on Xerneas for several reasons - namely that it results in Yveltal's design being pulled in several different directions rather than it honing in on one specific thing. Oblivion Wing is an incredibly strong tool with a combination of a reasonable 80 BP and a 75% HP Drain. But it being a Special Flying move puts it in a bit of an odd spot in relation to Dark Aura. While it can run Dark Pulse, access to juiced up verisons of normally medium power utility Physical Dark Moves like Knock Off and Sucker Punch are a huge boon, so it tends to be pulled towards both Physical and Special investment. As a result, you see plenty of Yveltal sets that leverage its Defensive and Supportive capacity, being a huge bulky pivot with Roost and Defog in Singles and being an incredibly hard to remove bulky Tailwind setter with Foul Play and Snarl in Doubles. It sometimes even drops Oblivion Wing - the other major restriction it has is not having a way to scale its damage, so it doesn't have a way to become a setup win condition on its own. But it still maintains a mixed 131 Attacking threat with a very hard to handle STAB combo and a small but concise set of powerful coverage moves, so it can't be disrespected as a threat in that capacity... unless Xerneas is there to walk all over it having a Defensive role. Are you starting to see the problem?
Also, did you know Yveltal is to this day the only Pokemon to ever learn Focus Blast via Level Up?