mertyville said:I generally feel always divided on how effective the Johto Starters are in Colosseum. My opinion kinda keeps changing. I felt Gator was great due to having Surf, strong Normal Attacks and evolving incredibly early. But Surf gets halved (even with Mystic Water), physical attacks feel kinda underwhelming and its kinda slow. Typhosion seemed appealing because its fast, you can get Fire Blast pretty early and Fire is incredible. Also Dig is nice coverage as 80ish attack was ok for that game. But like you mentioned some of the major issues. It is still satisfying to SPAM Fire Blast but eh. Meganium evolves relatively early, you can pair it up with Entei to have a nice Grass Fire Sun Core and it has good utility for catching but then you realize you use Meganium and Razor Leaf also gets halved in doubles.
There seems to be no real Pokemon that alone is giving you the feel of an S rank Pokemon and thus really feeling each one is bad in its own way. No one really stands out. Even Espeon, which obviously is the best is stuck with Psychic type moves. If you use any other type for offense, its not even worth for 'catching utility'. But it has Helping Hand considering all of that.
I would probably pick Fire and Water starters over Meganium just to give their item to other Pokemon. But maybe even in that topic I might change my mind in a future run.
So... quite a bit to unpack here.
Croconaw was good because it was one of the few viable attackers you had at that point. Surf does get halved, yes, but it's also hitting two mons. That allows its partner to pick up KOs without committing to doubling. Rain Dance also set it up for full damage if it needed it. Rain Dance in general is stupid strong in this game with all the mons that benefit and enable it.
Bayleef is... quite possibly the worst Bayleef has ever gotten to be in this game. And that's before it got nerfed in HGSS.
Razor Leaf just does half of its regular damage, no frills about it. That means you'll need the Giga Drain TM, which is late, or set up Sunnybeam pretty much every battle, which is a chore of its own. It does have some upside with Body Slam and Screens, but that's not enough.
Quilava just plain old sucks.
Flame Wheel is nothing but pathetic, Fire Blast is after you get Entei, which begs the question of why not use Entei anyway. It takes the longest to evolve, Dig is NOT 80bp, it's
60, and lol Smokescreen.
Matter of fact, Typhlosion learns two moves on its own the entire game. Swift on Lv. 45, and Flamethrower on Lv. 60. Overheat is not available, Thunderpunch is not available, even goddamn Aerial Ace isn't available. The only coverage you get besides EQ is Brick Break, and you'd need to beat Lv. 54 mons for it because it's on rank 4 in Pyrite Colosseum. Also a TM btw, and there are better candidates for it.
Typhlosion genuinely does nothing but try to spam Fire Blast, and having to replenish PP in Colosseum is a problem because trainers reset if you leave dungeons.
As for your S-Tier point, Espeon is just RIDICULOUS in Colosseum. Even when it's not getting its own KOs, which it will get very, very often, it can handle Dark-types by simply clicking Helping Hand and letting its partner get rid of the problem. It also gets Reflect, which is very important against Shadow mons because it reduces Shadow Rush damage.
Btw, all that is
from the jump. It starts off very strong and continues to dominate the entire game.