just wanted to provide an update now that we've finished reassessing information privy to us (TDs), both old and new
First, we apologize for the time it has taken to provide a response. We understand the frustration surrounding the delay, but many of those involved in reviewing this matter have full-time jobs and other commitments outside the community. Properly investigating the situation, reviewing the available evidence, and reassessing information as it develops takes time, and we wanted to give this matter the attention it deserves. While we understand the desire for a quicker resolution, we ask that people recognize the work involved in handling these situations responsibly and allow us the time necessary to reach an informed conclusion rather than rushing to judgment.
Regarding King Billu and alidakiller:
The investigation identified a number of concerning circumstances surrounding the relationship between these accounts. Over an extended period, King Billu repeatedly logged into a static IP address associated with alidakiller, including in the days leading up to alidakiller's account registration. King Billu also challenged alidakiller on the day the account was created, despite the two not having previously played against each other in a ladder match. We also found no prior chat history establishing a relationship between the two. Their interactions over the first two years consisted of privately challenged RandBats rather than RBYOU.
Despite invitations to watch King Billu play RBYOU in September of this year, the accounts did not play the format against each other until mid-October, with the exception of one ladder game near the end of September, nearly a week after alidakiller had already signed up for RBYPL. There were no chatlogs associated with that game, either.
More significantly, statements made by King Billu during the investigation regarding how the two knew each other were demonstrably incorrect. These included claims that they had tested RBYOU before the tournament and had discussed the tournament together in these matches. No supporting digital records were provided, and the challenge history we could identify across the accounts King Billu supplied did not support the claims made about their prior interactions.
Taken together, the two users’ activity and the demonstrably false explanations provided to tournament directors warranted further scrutiny. Based on these findings, we determined that a tournament ban was an appropriate response to the false information provided. As with any infraction issued on the site, the decision is appealable, and we remain open to further investigation if and when additional information becomes available. However, our ability to reassess the situation is currently limited by the information uncovered through our own investigation and the claims we have already found to be contradicted by the available evidence.
Regarding alidakiller and kinguzi96:
As the initial investigation progressed and we moved away from the suspicion that King Billu and alidakiller were potential alts, we also identified circumstances warranting scrutiny of the relationship between alidakiller and kinguzi96. The two accounts had been active from the same location earlier this year, participated in overlapping activities—including signing up for another circuit tournament at approximately the same time—and appeared to play the same tiers. Based on these circumstances and additional evidence that will not be disclosed publicly, alidakiller was tournament banned for signing up for a circuit tournament on both their main account and a presumed alt.
Following additional verification of information provided after the infractions were issued, we established that alidakiller and kinguzi96 are separate users. As a result, the basis for the ban was no longer supported, and we will be reverting their bans immediately (though alidakiller will still receive an insulted other member infraction for unsportsmanlike behavior related to RBYPL). We acknowledge that our original decision was incorrect.
Ultimately, we recognize the importance of both making informed decisions and being willing to reassess them when new information emerges. Our responsibility is to protect the integrity of tournaments and the community while ensuring that our decisions are grounded in the available evidence. If you have any further questions regarding this matter, you're welcome to DM me at any time. I'll share any additional information that is appropriate for public disclosure while respecting the privacy of those involved and the integrity of the investigation.