Manga

there was a thread for comics so i'm trying one for manga. discuss manga here...

what i like the most about manga is the variety of audiences and themes it has. you can find manga based on just about everything.

most manga you can find "scanlated" (scanned + translated) on the internet, i put a short list of recommended sites at the bottom of this post

only recommending manga without an anime adaptation, or that is either different or superior to the animated version. there's a lot of "essential" manga i haven't read yet so maybe someone else can contribute :heart:

--

20th Century Boys by Naoki Urasawa, one of my personal favorites. this is a long Stephen King-style epic story about a bunch of regular guys (and one woman) saving the world from a masked dictator. to achieve this, they must look back at the silly fantasies they had back when they were children. like I said, the plot is very long, so it can fit a multitude of characters (all pretty well done), and a solid timeline with memorable scenes and interconnected events. there's also a lot of references to classic manga and rock n roll (title is a T-Rex song), which I find pretty cool and fits with the "looking at the past" theme. there's a live action movie trilogy adaptation coming out, with a cast of 300 characters...

Lone Wolf and Cub by Kazuo Koike (story) and Goseki Kojima (art) is a cult classic epic manga about a samurai who wanders around looking for revenge, while pushing his son in a baby cart (thus lone wolf and cub). lots of badass fights mixed with heartwarming moments involving the cub, plus the historical setting is very well researched and most interesting! also one of the best endings i've seen. there's other seemingly great (and more recent) samurai manga out there (that i haven't read yet) like Blade of the Immortal (with some fantasy inserted, and an apparently horrendous anime adaptation) and Vagabond (about the iconic figure Miyamoto Musashi)

Yokohama Kaidashi Kikou by Hitoshi Ashinano might as well be the calmest and also most melancholy story I have read. the setting as described by Wikipedia:

Yokohama Kaidashi Kikō is set in a peaceful, post-cataclysmic world where mankind is in decline after an environmental disaster. Exactly what happened is never explained, but sea levels have risen significantly, inundating coastal cities such as Yokohama, and Mount Fuji erupted in living memory. The reduced human population has reverted to a simpler life, and the reader is told this is the twilight of the human age. Instead of raging against their fate, humans are quietly accepting.
it actually gets a bit creepy when you realize the main character, Alpha, an immortal robot, is just doing her stuff as humanity approaches its end. see mono no aware. might not be for everyone, it's so mellow.

Uzumaki by Junji Ito is a horror story about spirals appearing everywhere in a town, which has bizarre consequences. it's short, only 3 volumes (like it should be). also check Gyo, by the same author, a similar tale except this is about... fish with legs. Ito has a lot of other good horror stuff of varying quality, but all recommended

Franken Fran by the new and unknown author Katsuhisa Kigitsu is also a horror manga, but that is combined with an very black comedy. basically it's an "episodic" (or whatever the equivalent word for chapters is) manga which involves body surgery of all sorts. my favorite one is "cosmetic surgery", about a whole school trying to improve their looks. also Fran is a very likeable character : ) lots of gore in this, the humor might not be for everyone, but i haven't seen anyone dislike this manga yet, it's so unique.

continuing with the horror genre there's Pet Shop of Horrors by Matsuri Akino. the main character is Count D, a mysterious flamboyant man who runs a pet shop in Chinatown. people of all sorts go there to find their perfect pet, but they have to follow D's rules or something terrible will happen. now this would become a dumb moralistic series if it weren't for the count's fucked up set of values. the other main character is an average dumbass american policeman who investigates D. the interplay between these characters is quite fun to see. also, the art style for this is very "stylized". kind of obvious when we consider that this is supposedly a josei series (for young adult women)

Zetman by Masakazu Katsura is an ongoing action manga about a dude who transforms into a monster thing to fight other monster things. it is WAY better than it sounds.

in manga a lot of one-shots also get published. however, not many of them are noteworthy. a very good one is The Town of Evening Calm; The Country of Cherry Blossoms, a short melancholy look at the effects of the atomic bombing.

speaking of one-shots...

Shintaro Kago: i really won't go into detail to describe any of this guy's work here. it's very bizarre and grotesque, but at the same time it can be hilarious and even thought-provoking. if you really want to read something by him go to gelbooru and search for "abstraction" (warning: really NSFW)

and how could I make a manga post without at least mentioning Osamu Tezuka, "the god of manga". now, most of his work is aimed at children (though it may contain "adult" themes), but i've heard good things about his more mature stuff. MW is about a priest and his homosexual relationship with a sadistic criminal. Adolf tells the story of three people named Adolf, a German/Japanese boy, his best friend, a Jewish/German guy, and the nazi dictator himself... Ode to Kirihito has two doctors trying to combat a mysterious disease that makes people turn into deformed beasts.
 
I'll second all of spies' recommendations, especially 20th Century Boys which is my personal favorite manga. Naoki Urasawa's other works (Monster and Pluto) and also necessary reads. Here's some more...

Berserk by Kentaro Miura is a dark fantasy manga with an epic scope and very impressive artwork. This is a virtually essential manga, but don't read it without being prepared for inordinate amounts of gore, torture and rape. It's over 300 chapters long and still publishing with no end in sight.

Yotsuba&! by Kiyohiko Azuma is the polar opposite of Berserk: a cute and uplifting manga about the daily life of the titular young heroine. It might seem a bit mundane to some people, but has irrestistable charm and humor. Currently still publishing.

Eden: It's An Endless World! by Hiroki Endo is an action thriller with a fairly complicated plot involving a global pandemic, among other things. It's done publishing, but unfortunately not all of the later chapters have been scanlated yet.

Nausicaa of the Valley of the Wind by Hayao Miyazaki, the mastermind of Studio Ghibli. Nausicaa showcases some of his trademarks, such as a strong female lead and a focus on environmentalism. It was also adapated into a film, but the manga features a longer and superior version of the plot.

Battle Angel Alita by Yukito Kishiro is all about a cybernetic warrior girl. The main reason to read this is the highly detailed cyberpunk aesthetic of the artwork, so the plot is mostly subservient to Alita kicking ass.

Akira by Katsushiro Otomo was adapted into a seminal film that many people are probably familiar with, but offers a more complete story in printed form. Just like Nausicaa...

Vinland Saga by Makoto Yukimara should appeal to fans of Berserk, but is shorter, much less morbid and focused on vikings. Currently still publishing.
 
I guess I'm one of "those" who likes the popular manga, i.e. Naruto. I don't like Naruto because it's just omg ninjas!!!!!111 I like some of the deeper themes and character development. (If anyone knows what the deal is with this week's chapter, I'm all ears). I also enjoy the many different characters in Naruto and viewing their interactions.

I'm also a fan of a few completed Mangas, like Yu-Gi-Oh, Yu Yu Hakusho, and Zatch Bell. One Piece is pretty cool too, though I've never gotten into the Manga because I can never find it :|

I like this thread :) I may look into some of the mangas you guys've posted.
 
I guess I'm one of "those" who likes the popular manga, i.e. Naruto. I don't like Naruto because it's just omg ninjas!!!!!111 I like some of the deeper themes and character development. (If anyone knows what the deal is with this week's chapter, I'm all ears). I also enjoy the many different characters in Naruto and viewing their interactions.

I'm also a fan of a few completed Mangas, like Yu-Gi-Oh, Yu Yu Hakusho, and Zatch Bell. One Piece is pretty cool too, though I've never gotten into the Manga because I can never find it :|

I like this thread :) I may look into some of the mangas you guys've posted.

The deal with this weeks chapter is that because of holidays, the scanlation is a very low priority, and the likelihood of it being released has been decreased. Source: narutofan.com

Ho ho ho! It's never too late for a Christmas present to arrive. Nope, never! I hope you have all had a magical, wonderful, fun, super, nifty, and awesome day. Hopefully you got everything you wanted, spent some quality time with family, and gained approximately 12 pounds from holiday cooking. It is now time, I suppose, to curl up in front of the fire, laptop in lap, and wind down from the excitement with a new episode from the Japanese Naruto: Shippuuden anime series. The 90th episode entitled: Shinobi's Decision - which has just happened to arrive courtesy of the jolly folks over at Dattebayo. Coming to you completely translated in to English via the usage of subtitles this episode is as usual available to absolutely anybody who wants to watch it. All you need to do to watch this episode is click on over to Dattebayo's Webpage to give the torrent file a download, to then open up in to your favorite BitTorrent program to begin the download of the actual video file. Or, if you should happen to prefer things quick and easy, this episode is up for a direct HTTP download on over 30 servers for the exclusive use of our super awesome animePLUS! Members (who get access to this, and hundreds of other series) on our Naruto: Shippuuden Anime Downloads page! Please note there will likely not be a chapter from the Japanese Naruto manga series this week :( See you again soon, have a Happy New Years!
 
When it comes to action series, anime is usually better than manga as a medium, for obvious reasons. Full Metal Panic and Black Lagoon are much better in animated form, and with good reason: it's much easier to understand action scenes when viewing them at 30 frames per second than it is when reading them at 1 frame per second.

The main problems that anime suffers from that manga doesn't is the episodic constraint. In some cases, you have a 15-minute read expanded to fill a 25-minute time window, forcing the writers to create 10 minutes of filler, usually in the form of useless dialog (since it's cheaper than animating action scenes). Toei Animation experimented with creating an anime that consisted ENTIRELY of this filler material, the result being the incredibly commercially successful Yu-Gi-Oh!. On the other side of the spectrum, you have a 35-minute read condensed into a 25-minute episode, meaning that sometimes vital plot elements are minimized or completely eliminated.

Detective Conan (aka Case Closed) is the most glaring example of an anime that fails to deliver on the same level as the manga. I've had the chance to do side-by-side comparisons of certain volumes of the manga and episodes of the anime which featured the same stories, and in every single case the manga has done a much better job in terms of storytelling. So many of the cases contain way too much material to cram into a 12-minute episode without losing anything. The manga doesn't suffer with pacing issues, which is very important because the manga presents the story such that it's easy for the reader to solve the mysteries along with the protagonist. (I often find myself flipping back every few pages to review everything that's happened so far.) Detective Conan is fun to watch but it's even more enjoyable to read, and whenever I read it I often find myself re-reading the same volumes and each time picking up subtleties that enhance my enjoyment of each case.

The same goes for Death Note, to a lesser extent. Like Detective Conan, it's really dialog centric and there aren't too many action scenes. However, because the anime is so well-executed, it would be hard for me to recommend one over the other and I think in the end it comes down to preference in format.

Azumanga Daioh has been adapted into an anime, but the two are so radically different that they aren't really comperable. Azumanga Daioh is hardly traditional manga; it takes the form of four-panel jokes, a format probably familiar to readers of the comics page. Some of the jokes are funny, some fall flat, some just don't make very much sense to western audiences, but it's definitely not a waste of your time considering that each page is such a quick read.

Yotsuba& is by the same author as Azumanga Daioh, and unlike Azumanga Daioh it's a more traditional-style manga. Each volume chronicles the adventures of a curious young girl who is discovering the many wonders of the world around her, and her innocence is the source of a significant amount of dramatic irony. It's very fun to read.
 
Hunter x Hunter is pretty much at the top of the heap as far as shonen action series go. In all honesty the anime is probably better but it's finished while the manga is ongoing, at least when the author isn't on hiatus.

JoJo's Bizarre Adventure is a good and extremely long-running action series split into seven different parts, all with different casts of characters (though the plotlines do tie together). The quality does vary a bit from part to part, but it's overall quite a good read.

Lucifer and the Biscuit Hammer (aka Wakusei no Samidare) seems like another basic action manga at first glance but has already proven to be a bit more. There isn't much translated at this point, though.

Yotsuba& is a simple story about the life of a young girl, and is, as others have said, great.
 
Fishin's avatar also brings Cromartie High School to mind. I personally find it to be hilarious, although the humor is kind of off-beat. It's about an otherwise normal Japanese youth who ends up attending a high school filled delinquents. Among his fellow students are a robot, a gorilla, and a mute Freddie Mercury. The show is absolutely rife with dramatic irony (all but two of the main characters seem completely oblivious to the fact that one of the characters is a robot) and non-sequitur (extraterrestrials tend to make periodic visits completely unannounced) It's very bizarre and I can't guarantee that you'll like it, but it's worth looking into if it seems like it might be relevant to your interests.

There is also an anime adaptation which is actually pretty good. There is no running plot and each episode is only 12 minutes so it doesn't really suffer from timing issues, and the first two episodes break the fourth wall; the protagonist addresses the fact that some elements of his introduction to the high school are unexplained ("If you want to know, you can just read the manga!") and also mentions the fact that some fans of the manga may not like his animation or voice casting. One reason that I do think that the manga may be preferable for some people is that sometimes the anime moves a little bit slowly, and not every single joke resonates well with every audience member. The manga is nice because you can read more quickly through the setup for jokes and characters that you don't like as much.
 
I guess I'm one of "those" who likes the popular manga, i.e. Naruto. I don't like Naruto because it's just omg ninjas!!!!!111 I like some of the deeper themes and character development. (If anyone knows what the deal is with this week's chapter, I'm all ears). I also enjoy the many different characters in Naruto and viewing their interactions.
Except everyone who likes Naruto claims this! Dunno, Naruto is just subpar considering the author has literally no idea what he is doing considering he is relying on cheap tricks to give his characters personality and "depth" and what not not to mention the overtly contrived plot that just keeps degenerating and getting more ridiculous :(

I would highly recommend things like
Rurouni Kenshin
Hunter x Hunter
Jojo's bizarre Adventure
One Piece

as good shounen. If you're into classics I recommend reading Dragonball - at least, the original (and "not Z"). Kenshin I believe is pretty much the best shounen jump serialized manga however.

Speaking of Series you should read half way through and drop, you should do that with Death Note. Death Note after a given point is just drawn out - the best part of Death note is the parodies it has spawned - and the fan ending of Death Note is miles better than the actual ending.

Speaking of being stretched out to its grave, Yakitate Japan is actually very good (up to CMAP anyway - CMAP is downright terrible), and it's a parody on all those shounen so it's worth checking out, and it is quite humorous.

Great Teacher Onizuka is also a very solid series - i love characters like Onizuka. highly recommended.

The Hajime no Ippo manga is brilliant - if you loved the Anime (which you should have!) you should definitely read it.

Check out FMA Manga, which is miles above the anime.

20th Century Boys is very solid, along with works like Monster. Worth checking out.

Also, if you're into Romance, Maison Ikkoku pretty much did it the best, although some claim Kimagure Orange Road is also on the top.
 
Gantz is great. If you like sci-fi, then this manga is great for you.

Has anyone read the manga for Trigun? I've only watched the anime and I'm wondering if the manga is any better.

Also already mentioned Akira.

Other than those, I read and watch the more well known ones like Naruto.
 
Kenshin is bad, with a repetitive and unfulfilling that even gives Inuyasha a run for its money, but Hunter X Hunter is the definition of 'kiddy'. It is not worth anyone's time. Beyond just the immaturity, the sheer unbelievability of the fight scenes (everyone is always seems to be williing to stop attacks to let someone explain something and, of course, recover in the meantime) makes it utter garbage.

Great Teacher Onizuka is kind of funny, but also really, really pointless because it is one of those 'could not get away with any of this in any real life situation' for most of all of it :(

EDIT: I only watched the Kenshin anime, so maybe the manga blows it away.
 
Great Teacher Onizuka is kind of funny, but also really, really pointless because it is one of those 'could not get away with any of this in any real life situation' for most of all of it :(
This is what I'd call a case of "not getting the joke." When Onizuka hijacks a semi-truck with a sleeping driver to get to an examination on time, it's funny exactly BECAUSE it is one of those 'could not get away with any of this in any real life situation.' There are two sources of entertainment in GTO: seeing the protagonist's willingness to do whatever is necessary to achieve his goal, and seeing his ability to do the same, however implausible it might be.

By the way, Great Teacher Onizuka is one great example of an excellent manga that spawned an anime that was pretty mediocre because they makers had to slow the pace or throw in useless filler to make each episode fill the time slot.
 
Personally, I love Fruits Basket. Great story and character development. And parts of it are just amazingly touching. Like when Yuki convinces Kisa to begin talking again and when Kisa says her first word to Tohru... And how Tohru's mom got beat up when she was in those gangs... Those always make me cry.
 
I'm not a huge fan of manga or manga-based anything for that matter.

But I quite like Crayon Shin Chan. It's a crude comedy about a 5 year old named Shin who gets into crazy antics. It's lighthearted and funny, and you can spot the occassional pop culture reference in it too.
 
Gantz is great. If you like sci-fi, then this manga is great for you.

Has anyone read the manga for Trigun? I've only watched the anime and I'm wondering if the manga is any better.

Also already mentioned Akira.

Other than those, I read and watch the more well known ones like Naruto.


Yeah I've read Trigun, it finished last year I believe.
I enjoyed it for a long while, and if you've started you should certainly finish it. I have to say there is too much contrast between the last few parts and the rest though, especially in the art style and direction of it.
 
I don't read a lot of manga, but I'm reading something called Franken Fran right now. It claims that it's black humor... if you can call it "humor". It's not great or anything, but it's interesting.
 
Back
Top