Gimmicky set, which found a place in Smogon Analyses. Indeed, gimmicky as hell... And this guy doesn't have bad support options also with access to Light Screen, T-Wave, etc. for a tank.Or you know use Rotom who doesn't need gimmicky EVs and stops it spamming Return.
I think it's really good idea, I didn't thought about it. Pokemon, which has physical defense on level close to Max HP/Max Def Gyarados is nothing to laugh at. Only one weakness to use against it and right now usefull resistance with all those Staraptors running around. I'm gonna try it in my stall team, it may be interesting.
It's hard to call something a counter when it's 2OHKOed by a move, which is on almost every Staraptor set on the most popular set (ok, many run Jolly Nature, so it has a chance to survive). But I need to agree that this guy makes a solid Staraptor check. Heck, even Metang makes a good check, but it's not counter. Someone found something like this in that Luxray or Bulky Arcanine, which someone posted here. I would say Bulky Granbull or Bulky Tauros, but those Close Combat weaknesses are troublesome.What proportion of Raptor are CB and Adamant? Considering that it can switch into all of its attacks bar one attack on a set that isn't the most popular, needs SR support for the 2HKO, and also isn't the initial attack of any Staraptor, I'd say its a good counter. Particularly as Rotom can actually wall other stuff like Fighters.