Legacy Raider said:And guys please, it's a generalisation! I've posted that at least 3 times in my original post, and twice since then. All pokemon are dissimilar, so there will always be some disrepetencies when grouping them. Yes, Staraptor is hurt by SR while Gallade is not, but in order to see the tier as a whole, and really the purpose of my argument, please look past these! Uggh.
I understand the idea behind the chart, and its a good chart at that. But i really dont think you can generalize pokemon into 4 catagories,
especially suspects. The Stealth Rock was just a side point, nothing more. While the point of the chart, i think, is to point out the upset in Balance when the Pokemon are banned, but i dont think it works like a food chain.
Bulky Waters, yes you can sort of sort them being that they are all, well, Bulky Water-types. The difference is though, Slowbro "counters"(being used loosely) Gallade and Staraptor, while Milotic does not.
Physical Attackers is not possible to generalize either. Maybe you could put Medicham, Gallade and Feraligatr into a group of somesort that is walled by Slowbro, and beat Milotic. But i dont think its right to put a CB Flying/Normal pokemon in the same group as a Swords Dance Sweeper(generalizing).
The same goes with Registeel and Steelix too. Steelix counters Raikou only, while it gets completely annihilated by any other special attacker, therefor is a bad special attacker counter which is the opposite of what your chart says. Registeel should be in that box alone, especially since Steelix can fairly effectively counter Staraptor.
To summarize:
Bulky Waters dont counter Physical Attackers, Slowbro does.
Steel-types dont counter special attackers, Registeel does(with the exception of Fires).
Staraptor and Gallade are played completely differently, Gallade is played like other pokemon such as SD Feraligatr, Blaziken or Drapion. While Staraptor is played like pokemon such as......well nothing really, but more like other Choicers(Azumaril, Typhlosion etc.).
Scuba Stevee said:I already posted this in the vote thread, but I'm going to post it here too.
But I think snover should stay UU. Really, putting snover in BL sounds like we're running away from it instead of trying to think of way to counter it. But of course people are going to use sealeo as mini walrein in UU, but I do not think it will break UU. Snover is pretty much the only thing keep hail teams alive in UU, and I think the UU is much better with hail in it.
Snover will allow Froslass and other things to unbalance the metagame, even without Walrein. Walrein isnt even broken, its ONLY because of endless hail.
Relictivity said:I agree, this doesn't necessarily group things all to well. However, Slowbro unfortunately cannot stop Gallade :(. It takes too much damage after a Swords Dance.
Slowbro is actually the best switch in to Gallade, i dont really know what your talking about.