Deucalion2 said:Yes, I don't think Scizor is Uber. The difference between Garchomp and Scizor was that Garchomp was used directly as a result of his own power - he was used because he was incredibly powerful (that said, I'm one the Garchomp to OU thinkers, I don't think he was too powerful). Scizor is used as a result of everything else's power - he happens to counter a lot of major threats extremely well. It isn't directly correlated to his own strength.
It has a ridiculously powerful priority move, one that can 2HKO a majority of pokemon. The fact that Scizor isn't even subject to Speed woes, the way Garchomp or even the DD users are, is an even greater advantage in the realm of sweeping. What about its utility as a scout via U-Turn? Its defensive prowess? (Scizor won't tank like Gyarados or Tyranitar but it's acceptably sturdy,
is Steel typed, and learns Roost.) Those are great strengths! The fact Scizor just so happens to counter many other major threats is also a strength even if it's metagame-dependent.
While Garchomp (and even others) has seen higher total usage percentages, Scizor has a higher usage relative to its peers than Garchomp ever had. Scizor is #1 by more than 50% over its closest competitor, which is pretty amazing, so it's actually quite a bit "more uber" than anything else we've ever seen viewed from this slightly different perception. However, some less intelligent people need to get over their incorrect thoughts that usage is in any way relevant to determining how "uber" a pokémon is.

It's merely interesting information.
SHUCKLE MAN said:I remember that some people were saying that allowing NFEs in lower tiers would cause 'OU-lite'-edness, but, this is obviously not the case in some examples. Hippopotas uses very different strategies to Hippowdon, as you can see below: ...
Both Hippopotas and Hippowdon are physically defensive pokemon used primarily for their Sand Stream. The only reason Hippopotas sees more usage of passive damage and status moves is because Hippopotas can't support direct attacking moves the way Hippowdon can with its much high base Attack. Protect is mostly a support move designed to aid Toxic or Yawn but it could also be because Hippopotas lacks Hippowdon's Defense/HP (though it is still good) and isn't as capable of out-healing incoming damage via Slack Off.
You'd also see similar "phenomena" with something like Dusclops or Magneton. Dusclops is the same as Dusknoir, it just lacks the base Attack to support elemental punches and whatnot, and Magneton is functionally identical to Magnezone. NFE pokémon only tend to significantly differ in usage from their fully-evolved forms when they actually do change significantly. e.g. Scyther, who is a different type to Scizor and much faster. These are pokémon who already tend to be listed separately from their evolution in the site's tier lists.
Pirika said:Sword Dance Scizor isn't as good as SD Lucario or SD Infernape. Steel isn't a good attaking type and Scizor's low speed prevent him from sweeping teams.
I lol'd.