FlareBlitz said:Is no one considering the possibility of it becoming Grass/Dark? The coloration of the evo in the sketch is, from what I can tell, getting darker, and the Pokemon has always looked "tricky" and confident, befitting a dark type. Grass/Dark is unfortunately walled by Steel (although not by Jirachi/Metagross) but at least it can get past Celebi and Dragons and fire types not named Heatran/Houndoom. It's not much to write home about defensively, but it's a bit better than Grass/Poison and doesn't come with a useless STAB so...
Sandstreamer said:What game do you guys play?
Mamoswine is great. Weavile has its uses (especially if it gets past Scizor). Rock is an awesome offensive type, as well as Ice. (Of course, Rock is also awesome defensively while Ice sucks beyond compare in this regard.) And if it wasn't for the odd Breloom and Smogon's not exactly well-designed tiers, our only OU Grass pokemon would be a Grass/Ice type. What does that tell us? lol
FlareBlitz said:Never thought about it, but seems entirely plausible. The typing actually has a good set of resistances, although it's nothing spectacular.Is no one considering the possibility of it becoming Grass/Dark? The coloration of the evo in the sketch is, from what I can tell, getting darker, and the Pokemon has always looked "tricky" and confident, befitting a dark type. Grass/Dark is unfortunately walled by Steel (although not by Jirachi/Metagross) but at least it can get past Celebi and Dragons and fire types not named Heatran/Houndoom. It's not much to write home about defensively, but it's a bit better than Grass/Poison and doesn't come with a useless STAB so...
Sandstreamer said:I was agreeing with what you had to say, but then stopped reading at this point... Rock is, in my opinion, the 2nd worst defensive typing (after Ice, of course). Resists Fire, Poison, Flying, and Normal... only Fire is ever used competitively. 5 weaknesses, to the omnipresent Water and Ground attacks, very common Fighting and Steel, and occasional Grass attack.What game do you guys play?
Mamoswine is great. Weavile has its uses (especially if it gets past Scizor). Rock is an awesome offensive type, as well as Ice. (Of course, Rock is also awesome defensively
Abomosnow isn't OU btw, Roserade and Celebi would also like to say something. Mamoswine really isn't that good, especially since ~30% of teams run Scizor or switch in any of the numerous Ground immunities, and even though Ice shard has great coverage with Ground attacks, its only 40 BP and isn't boosted and Choice Banded Ice types really Suck in OU. Weaviles uses are to kill Dragon Types that will just switch to a resist and laugh at your base 75 attacks.What game do you guys play?
Mamoswine is great. Weavile has its uses (especially if it gets past Scizor). Rock is an awesome offensive type, as well as Ice. (Of course, Rock is also awesome defensively while Ice sucks beyond compare in this regard.) And if it wasn't for the odd Breloom and Smogon's not exactly well-designed tiers, our only OU Grass pokemon would be a Grass/Ice type. What does that tell us? lol
FlareBlitz said:Is no one considering the possibility of it becoming Grass/Dark? The coloration of the evo in the sketch is, from what I can tell, getting darker, and the Pokemon has always looked "tricky" and confident, befitting a dark type. Grass/Dark is unfortunately walled by Steel (although not by Jirachi/Metagross) but at least it can get past Celebi and Dragons and fire types not named Heatran/Houndoom. It's not much to write home about defensively, but it's a bit better than Grass/Poison and doesn't come with a useless STAB so...
FlareBlitz said:Is no one considering the possibility of it becoming Grass/Dark? The coloration of the evo in the sketch is, from what I can tell, getting darker, and the Pokemon has always looked "tricky" and confident, befitting a dark type. Grass/Dark is unfortunately walled by Steel (although not by Jirachi/Metagross) but at least it can get past Celebi and Dragons and fire types not named Heatran/Houndoom. It's not much to write home about defensively, but it's a bit better than Grass/Poison and doesn't come with a useless STAB so...
Sandstreamer said:Smogon's not exactly well-designed tiers
The Pokemon Pimp said:I couldn't really follow the post after this :P I personally think that literally no tiering system in any video game is perfect but I couldn't come up with a better method than Smogon's. What would your proposed method be? Votes?
blasphemy1 said:Your vote is putting the Pokemon on your team and using it in a battle...
The Pokemon Pimp said:That's what I mean. I seriously can't think of another way to tier something, so why is Sandstreamer criticizing it?
Funnily enough, I'm not trying to be rude, I'm curious. It just makes sense to me that Pokemon that match the uber "definitions" are uber, the ones that are mostly used are "overused", the ones that aren't used as much are "underused", and the rest, which are never used, are aptly named "neverused".
blasphemy1 said:Anyway, I'm starting to think more and more Tsutaja may evolve into a Grass/Steel. I mean, its evolutions back has a lot of sharp leaves, which could translate into blades.
Master of the Six Kings said:o rly?@Sandstreamer: It tells us weather starters are good (kinda ironic given your username). Seriously, you think Yomamsnow would get anywhere if it had Snow Cloak? SR weak, x4 fire weak, only good for soaking up Water attacks and Ice Shard revenging, the latter of which Mamo or Weavile do better. Not to say it'd be completely useless ofcourse, just that is survives in OU ONLY because it starts Hail.
Mario With Lasers said:Don't trust your feelings, man. I'm just saying that you "see Grass types in OU" only because somebody on this site wanted them there, not because they are any good. Just like if Ho-oh was voted OU, you'd see a SUDDEN increase of Fire types in OU. (Note: This is an absurd comparison. I know about Ho-oh, ok?)Ok, so you are trying to say Smogon should have Shaymin and Celebi Uber and Abomasnow on OU based by "strength"? That's what I'm feeling here and I hope I'm wrong, otherwise you're just proving my point.
Shroomisaur said:And I agree with you thus far. But basically, rock has two things going for it:I was agreeing with what you had to say, but then stopped reading at this point... Rock is, in my opinion, the 2nd worst defensive typing (after Ice, of course). Resists Fire, Poison, Flying, and Normal... only Fire is ever used competitively. 5 weaknesses, to the omnipresent Water and Ground attacks, very common Fighting and Steel, and occasional Grass attack.
xdevo13 said:Yeah, I forgot Roserade. And I already talked to Celebi. lol Also, I don't know what you want to say about Mamoswine.... That's not new.Abomosnow isn't OU btw, Roserade and Celebi would also like to say something. Mamoswine really isn't that good, especially since ~30% of teams run Scizor or switch in any of the numerous Ground immunities, and even though Ice shard has great coverage with Ground attacks, its only 40 BP and isn't boosted and Choice Banded Ice types really Suck in OU. oh ya, I play OU and NU.
There also is basically no need to tier something at all. For 3 and a half (counting RS200 as a half) generations Nintendo had an obvious banlist and that was it. (Yeah, the names of the tiers were coined from the very beginning, but they were just abbreviations for the the actual word with its actual meaning. Smogon just took them for naming its ruleset this way.)That's what I mean. I seriously can't think of another way to tier something, so why is Sandstreamer criticizing it?
Shroomisaur said:Actually, Ice is a wonderful attacking type, and paired with Fighting, it is nearly unresisted: only Water/Bug (oh no, Surskit will wall you), Water/Poison (Tentacruel, Qwilfish), and Water/Psychic(Slowbro/king, Starmie) resist both. Pretty good coverage, plus both Fighting and Ice have tons of potential to hit SE, unlike Water/Normal, for example.
Sandstreamer said:There also is basically no need to tier something at all. For 3 and a half (counting RS200 as a half) generations Nintendo had an obvious banlist and that was it. (Yeah, the names of the tiers were coined from the very beginning, but they were just abbreviations for the the actual word with its actual meaning. Smogon just took them for naming its ruleset this way.)
Shock_wave said:Lucalibur kindly corrected my oversight 2-3 pages ago.Frosslass??
Sandstreamer said:Don't trust your feelings, man. I'm just saying that you "see Grass types in OU" only because somebody on this site wanted them there, not because they are any good. Just like if Ho-oh was voted OU, you'd see a SUDDEN increase of Fire types in OU. (Note: This is an absurd comparison. I know about Ho-oh, ok?)
Sandstreamer said:Really now? The "obvious banlist" isn't well-designed. Jirachi gets banned because it's an event Pokemon and Garchomp is allowed. You really think an arbitrary banlist by Nintendo beats one tested by thousands of people battling all the time?There also is basically no need to tier something at all. For 3 and a half (counting RS200 as a half) generations Nintendo had an obvious banlist and that was it. (Yeah, the names of the tiers were coined from the very beginning, but they were just abbreviations for the the actual word with its actual meaning. Smogon just took them for naming its ruleset this way.)
Sandstreamer said:(Of course, Rock is also awesome defensively
Lucalibur said:So? That means absolutely nothing. Simply saying "We've never had one" would have been a stronger argument.we wont be getting a pure flying for god sake. it would cause roost to make him become ???.
The Pokemon Pimp said:It would appreciate higher-powered STAB moves, too ;)
That's what really made it suffer. If Weavile got Crunch or something else and maybe Technician it'd be a whole different story. But it's not powerful or bulky enough to stay around for long. Which is a shame to be honest :(