shrang said:Consistently also depends on your team. You can easily go sleep Registeel and your SD Absol still won't sweep, or you can sleep Weezing and your NP Missy still won't sweep.
are we forgetting the term sufficiently easier? these two pokemon i mention because they really only have a few amount of counters. mismagius is my primary example - she is only countered by registeel and spiritomb and if we want to get technical we can go to the lower ranks; drapion and skuntank counters her as well but they are lesser used. with registeel placed in a deep slumber, you would think that mismagius will sweep your team sufficiently easier with one of its best counters removed from the match.
I'm also surprised that QC removed RestTalk Arcanine when people are crying foul over Venusaur, too, but whatever. Like I said in my final post in the horrible Salamence thread (located
here), incapacitating or severely damaging one Pokemon (Which your opponent GETS TO CHOOSE), does not necessarily equate to "Consistently creating opportunities for your teammates to sweep".
considering i wrote the set, i know how effective the set is. with the current metagame trend leaning towards the popularity of special venusaur, the effectiveness of that set has died. the resttalk set was used in the metagame where sd + power whip venusaur was extremely potent.
scenario
this is one of long post but i'll keep my response short and concise. you are overthinking this too much. you are stripping the definition of consistency to its flesh. we have no set stone percentage to what consistency is but experience speaks louder than percentages. if my venusaur is always sleeping the same two pokemon nearly every game i play, then i consider that consistent. the characteristics did not
guarantee a scot free sweep, nor did i mention this once; however, it did say it will provide a sufficiently easier sweep for insert pokemon. in this case, one of very few of mismagius' hard counters are removed from the match and you really cannot ignore the fact that it will sweep easier now whether you have swellow in the wings or not. the very fact is, registeel is still asleep and swellow can easily be switched out on. with swellow dead, mismagius is still alive! and can still sweep sufficiently easier with registeel sleeping. thanks to venusaur's consistency to place nearly the same two pokemon every game, it will help me other pokemon sweep. we may view things differently, but i still think this is support.
Fine. Don't underestimate Jumpluff, though, she will make you trip your balls (I've stalled out more teams with Jumpluff than I have "Support Characteristic"ed with Venusaur, though).
nah i don't underestimate it. it's potent for sure, just not my cup of tea pokemon and i win most games that have jumpluff on my opponent's side. its very very predictable.
No, it isn't. The Support Characteristic, in its purest form (Which you're using, by the way) is not affected by tier. It doesn't say "If a Pokemon is OU, the Support Characteristic doesn't apply". It doesn't matter that they are two completely different Pokemon, it matters that they end up doing what the Support Characteristic states that they do, and if you look at it from THAT perspective, Venusaur and Breloom have A LOT IN COMMON.
it is affected by the tier. we cannot compare two different tiers because the metagame trends are completely different. one has more steel-types, the other doesn't; one has more dragon-types, the other one doesn't. it's simple as that. while i will agree on the fact they can be similar in what they do, they are just not comparable due to different metagame trends.
Again, irrelevant. If they both end up doing what the Support Characteristic states it does, it should be banned (or not banned). Venusaur (Breloom) can put an opponent to sleep.
it is relevant. it makes venusaur a better illustration of the support characteristics. it shows that he is more potent and definitely not one sided and can do plenty things outside of simply sleep powdering + leaf storming stuff. but i straw away from stiff comparisons between uu and ou pokemon, i just can't do it because the pokemon switching in are different.
Venusaur (Breloom) can poke a huge hole into the opponent's team with Sludge Bomb, Leaf Storm and other moves (Seed Bomb, Focus Punch and other moves). I really hate it when people just point out some of the most irrelevant differences and home in on them while ignoring the big picture. Hey, Venusaur fits the Support Characteristic because it can run a bunch of sets!! Tell that to Wobbuffet (Yeh, I'm joking, but you get my point).
sigh, this is why i don't compare two pokemon from two different tiers. which is why i am not responding to this.
i don't care about breloom, i care about venusaur's performance in the uu tier, and the uu tier only. breloom being placed in comparison is completely arbitrary because the metagame trends are entirely different. i hate repeating myself. if you want to compare something, make it in the same tier so my arguments will actually have some substance.
Venusaur (Breloom) can poke a huge hole into the opponent's team with Sludge Bomb, Leaf Storm and other moves (Seed Bomb, Focus Punch and other moves). I really hate it when people just point out some of the most irrelevant differences and home in on them while ignoring the big picture. Hey, Venusaur fits the Support Characteristic because it can run a bunch of sets!! Tell that to Wobbuffet (Yeh, I'm joking, but you get my point).
the comparisons here are very broad. if you want a comparison, do exeggutor and venusaur - they both poke holes and sleep stuff. if you're going to respond with a breloom + venusaur comparison, i'd end it here right now. i'll be glad to justify the difference between exeggutor and venusaur however because they are in the same tier!
Grass/Fighting is a much better attacking type combo than Grass/Poison, wtf are you smoking. Focus Punch isn't exactly unreliable on Breloom either, since it gets one off a lot of the time. If you play OU, you really shouldn't be trying to sell that message, heh (Just a quite note, Breloom also has Superpower, Brick Break and Mach Punch if you don't like Focus Punch, just like how Venusaur also has Energy Ball and Power Whip if you don't like Leaf Storm).
lol. do you see why i don't compare two pokemon in the tier? grass/fighting is a much better attacking combo but THERE IS NO GRASS/FIGHTING pokemon in the uu tier, which makes the point irrelevant. grass/poison is pathetic in the ou tier, but it is surprisingly amazing in the uu tier. focus punch is an unreliable move to use from the get-go, so its secondary stab move is pretty weak (80 bp).