Melvni's original list of 100 cutoff pokemon for NU with my favorites bolded:
Normal - Swellow, Persian, Cinccino, Tauros, Braviary, Smeargle, Munchlax, Bouffalant, Ursaring, Lickilicky, Audino, Togetic, Slaking, Kangaskhan, Regigigas
Fighting - Emboar, Gurdurr, Sawk, Throh, Machoke, Combusken
Flying - Altaria, Swellow, Braviary, Archeops, Murkrow, Rotom-S, Tropius, Golbat, Jumpluff, Togetic, Ninjask, Butterfree, Masquerain
Poison - Golbat, Roselia, Vileplume, Muk, Haunter, Garbodor
Ground - Dugtrio, Golurk, Rhydon, Torterra, Golem, Piloswine, Stunfisk, Seismitoad
Rock - Regirock, Rhydon, Archeops, Kabutops, Golem, Cradily, Probopass, Rampardos, Magcargo, Armaldo, Gigalith, Shuckle
Bug - Accelgor, Pinsir, Ninjask, Butterfree, Armaldo, Masquerain, Shuckle
Ghost - Golurk, Rotom, Drifblim, Misdreavus, Haunter
Steel - Magneton, Klingklang, Probopass, Metang
Fire - Magmortar, Emboar, Torkoal, Rapidash, Flareon, Magcargo, Combusken
Water - Lanturn, Slowking, Crawdaunt, Walrein, Alomomola, Ludicolo, Samurott, Kabutops, Simipour, Lapras, Huntail, Seismitoad, Kingler, Golduck
Grass - Ludicolo, Torterra, Tropius, Leafeon, Exeggutor, Roselia, Jumpluff, Vileplume, Meganium, Serperior, Cradily
Electric - Lanturn, Eelektross, Electrode, Magneton, Rotom, Rotom-F, Rotom-S, Luxray, Stunfisk
Psychic - Slowking, Mesprit, Gardevoir, Exeggutor, Jynx, Duosion, Hypno, Metang
Ice - Cryogonal, Walrein, Regice, Rotom-F, Glaceon, Piloswine, Jynx, Sneasel, Lapras
Dragon - Altaria, Druddigon, Dragonair, Zweilous
Dark - Crawdaunt, Absol, Murkrow, Sneasel, Zweilous
This tier is full of powerful yet slow pokemon. Trick Room anyone?
There are around 80 or so pokemon in this tier (counted based on this list which seems to be based around fully evolved pokemon that arent banned from this tier)
So making a tier below NU would just be nothing but Eviolite.
All of my favorites are basically physical attackers but are rather slow. Judging from just how many I bolded my statement that this tier is going to be Physical tank + Trick Room looks about right.