Yes but how many people run Dual Screens+Memento Latios or Uxie in OU?
Regarding #1: It doesn't matter if Deoxys-S's occasional surprise offensive set plus two main support sets (hazards and screens) provide versatility, it only matters if this versatility makes (or contributes towards) Deoxys-S being broken. If it does, how? Is it actually impossible (or improbable) for teams to deal with all three sets without overspecialization? And if so, is the overspecialization that would be required to deal with Deoxys-S so specialized that it is actively bad against other strategies?
Regarding #2: It doesn't matter if Deoxys-S is the best at setting up 2 layers (SR + 1 spikes) before going down. Convince me that mostly guaranteed SR + Spikes + 5 Pokemon is consistently more powerful than a standard team of 6 Pokemon.
Regarding #3: It doesn't matter if Deoxys-S is the best screener. Convince me that ability to set up Screens is consistently breaking games (though good luck on that one).
Okay, people are saying Azelf and Deoxys-S aren't comparable when they clearly are. Azelf can't use Superpower and Spikes. That, and the speed Deoxys-s has separate them from each other. Azelf, can use Natural Gift with a Salac Berry (idk why no one did in DPP, tbh Azelf didn't need a focus sash to guarantee SR is up) to get rid of Ttar so Superpower goes out the window. Is the speed difference really that much? Azelf already outruns all of OU as it is right now, barring Starmie and Deoxys-S. Using Scarftar to kill Azelf before it can do anything is outright begging to get swept by Terrakion, Dragonite, Lucario, SD Scizor, [insert sweeper here].
Spikes aren't an issue. If you can't limit it to just one layer of Spikes and SR, then you have to look back at your team and see what you can change to deal with it instead of asking for a ban, because I honestly believe 1 layer of Spikes + Stealth Rocks + 5 Pokemon isn't as difficult to deal with as something like Rainstall or even Sun offense.
Since you don't seem to read what other have written in this thread here is a previous post i made that explains why Deoxys-S is leagues ahead of Azelf as a dual screener:The same can be said for the other Screeners, though. Latios and Uxie even have Memento as a bonus, and Uxie can set up SR.
I don't see the point of you making this statement, as it's equally "irrelevant" as you claim his argument to be, and it's also rude.Don't make such assumptions. I can easily target your English, but that's irrelevant just as your comment was. >.>
Sure, they're set-up fodders, but you act as if Lucario or Terrakion or whatever set-up sweeper doesn't have counters. Most to all battlers should know the risks of carrying a scarfed Pokemon, and will attempt to create a team that remedies the problem created by the scarfed Pokemon in the first place. You're also acting as if Azelf is the second fastest Pokemon in the OU metagame. The speed difference between Azelf and Deoxys is clear. Things like Jolteon can OHKO (2HKO if focus sash) Azelf before it can set up a screen. Starmie speed ties with Azelf, etc.The speed is not a huge difference. Yes, Deoxys outspeeds scarfers. Cool. They are set up fodder for the sweepers that come after Azelf. Is there anything you guys don't get about that? That Haxorus used Dual Chop. Cool. Azelf survived, and used SR/Reflect and then died next turn. Now Lucario gets to rampage on your team. Scarftar used Crunch on your Azelf. Cool. There are a number of sweepers that can set up on that. The fact you guys are resorting to Scarfers to solve your DS problems says something about it considering most teams only carry one if any at all (Stall teams usually won't).
More mockery. I'm pretty sure Alexwolf doesn't appreciate this, but anyways, there are viable Pokemon that outspeed and taunt, most notably of which are Azelf (which speed ties) and Deoxys.Also, Alexwolf, you mentioned somewhere about Taunting Azelf with something faster. What exactly are you taunting it with? lolaerodactyl or lolcrobat?
No, it's been mentioned before what Deoxys has over other Dual Screeners, which it would be a good idea to go back and read.But then there are Pokemon out there that can do the same thing: set up screens.
Alright, how about we try and figure something out here.
Is there any Pokemon, and I mean ANY Pokemon, that can go against Deoxys and win every single time, no matter the set? And by win, I mean no hazards, no screens, your Pokemon is still alive, and the Deoxys either switched out or died.
I'd venture to say that the answer is no. Whether it's a Magic Coat Deoxys or an all-out offensive Deoxys, nothing is guaranteed to be perfectly fine.
I don't see the point of you making this statement, as it's equally "irrelevant" as you claim his argument to be, and it's also rude.
I agree that it is irrelevant, and I didn't mean to be rude. I apologize if it came off that way. He shouldn't be rude either so leave it there.
Sure, they're set-up fodders, but you act as if Lucario or Terrakion or whatever set-up sweeper doesn't have counters. Most to all battlers should know the risks of carrying a scarfed Pokemon, and will attempt to create a team that remedies the problem created by the scarfed Pokemon in the first place. You're also acting as if Azelf is the second fastest Pokemon in the OU metagame. The speed difference between Azelf and Deoxys is clear. Things like Jolteon can OHKO (2HKO if focus sash) Azelf before it can set up a screen. Starmie speed ties with Azelf, etc.
Who builds a team around a Scarfpoke? js...
Azelf is not the second fastest in the OU tier (it itself isn't OU), but of all the Pokemon in OU it speed ties with Starmie which is second fastest.... The speed difference is clear, but Deoxys carries so much excess speed all it's good for is outspeeding scarfmons to get the screens up before taking a hit when other screeners are likely going to be doing the same with their speed. You guys are acting as if 115 base Speed is slow. >.>
Also, the sweepers have counters, but they also have moves specifically to get rid of their counters eg. Lucario with Ice Punch so you're leaving it up to chance. :/
More mockery. I'm pretty sure Alexwolf doesn't appreciate this, but anyways, there are viable Pokemon that outspeed and taunt, most notably of which are Azelf (which speed ties) and Deoxys.
I didn't mean to come of as rude, okay. Most of those Pokemon that do outspeed Azelf aren't common at all in OU, but are viable, yes.
No, it's been mentioned before what Deoxys has over other Dual Screeners, which it would be a good idea to go back and read.
First of all for who was the answer reffering to targeting english?Don't make such assumptions. I can easily target your English, but that's irrelevant just as your comment was. >.>
The speed is not a huge difference. Yes, Deoxys outspeeds scarfers. Cool. They are set up fodder for the sweepers that come after Azelf. Is there anything you guys don't get about that? That Haxorus used Dual Chop. Cool. Azelf survived, and used SR/Reflect and then died next turn. Now Lucario gets to rampage on your team. Scarftar used Crunch on your Azelf. Cool. There are a number of sweepers that can set up on that. The fact you guys are resorting to Scarfers to solve your DS problems says something about it considering most teams only carry one if any at all (Stall teams usually won't).
Also, Alexwolf, you mentioned somewhere about Taunting Azelf with something faster. What exactly are you taunting it with? lolaerodactyl or lolcrobat?
Also, Kefka, the Spiker set isn't what most people believe is making Deoxys broken. I think most of us can agree it's the Dual Screen set that makes Deoxys look Uber.
But then there are Pokemon out there that can do the same thing: set up screens. The only thing Deoxys has over them is his ability to outspeed scarfers. But then that's totally irrelevant if you are resorting to scarfers for killing the Dual Screener simply because they become set up fodder after the kill. Isn't that the purpose of Reflect, Light Screen, and taunt? To turn stuff into set up fodder for a sweeper?
Edit: Yes, I'm theorymoning. I'm going to go ahead and test the other DS users myself with a standard Deo+5 sweepers team and see how it fairs.
Bronzong is without a doubt, the best counter to deoxys in OU. The best life orb sweeper can do is 118-140 damage against the standard bronzong set (3HKO or 4HKO). What's he gonna do, taunt you?? Great, gyro ball to the face or set up trick room. HP fire again?? Once again, gyro ball. Reflect?? Haven't done calculations, but with deoxys-s's speed, it's most likely a 2HKO.
It is a 4hko behind Reflect.Bronzong is without a doubt, the best counter to deoxys in OU. The best life orb sweeper can do is 118-140 damage against the standard bronzong set (3HKO or 4HKO). What's he gonna do, taunt you?? Great, gyro ball to the face or set up trick room. HP fire again?? Once again, gyro ball. Reflect?? Haven't done calculations, but with deoxys-s's speed, it's most likely a 2HKO.
First of all for who was the answer reffering to targeting english?
Now let's get on to the main point...You keep saying that if a scarfer kills Azelf then something else is going to setup.
Well guess what this is always the case for scarfers.That's why every good team that carries a scarfer has answers for the pokes that can setup on its locked moves.
Also you compare the setup oportunities that the screens give to the setup oportunites that a locked move gives.
The big difference is that the wrong choice lcoked move only gives you 1 free turn,while the screens are up for effectively 5 or 6 whole turns.
Are you starting to get it now?
You cannot compare the enormous and longer setup oportunities that dual screens provide to the smaller and 1-turn lasting setup oportunity a choiced move gives.
So assuming i have a Scarftar or a Scarf Hydreigon and i ohko your Azelf while you switch to something that can setup on the locked move.
Do you seriously think that any decent team will not have an answer for pokes that can setup on its scarfers?
Do you seriously think that with just 1 turn of setup you will sweep my whole team when everything is at full life and you have no rocks up?
But with Deoxys-S this is possible!Just go and find in the previous page kd24's example of how difficult is to deal with a single lumddnite behind screens.
Finally about the Taunt thing i know that there are not many things that are faster than Azelf with Taunt(propably zero pokes in OU bar Deoxys-S)but at least having the option to Taunt is is better than not to have this option at all(see Deoxys-S).
somebody who hasn't seen a scarftar in a while said:Edit: Also, be honest. When was the last time you've seen a scarftar? >.<
Alright, how about we try and figure something out here.
Is there any Pokemon, and I mean ANY Pokemon, that can go against Deoxys and win every single time, no matter the set? And by win, I mean no hazards, no screens, your Pokemon is still alive, and the Deoxys either switched out or died.
I'd venture to say that the answer is no. Whether it's a Magic Coat Deoxys or an all-out offensive Deoxys, nothing is guaranteed to be perfectly fine.
The more I experiment with Deoxys and try interesting sets rather than the standards, the more I'm starting to lean towards Uber.
Like has been said before, hazards or screens are pretty much a guarantee. But people forget that Deoxys has a movepool out of the wazzoo. You can have your hazards, but then if there's something your team has problems with, you can slap that coverage move on and have almost a guaranteed killer waiting in the wings for the rest of the game. Gyarados troubles? You can run Thunderbolt and kill the damn thing for god sakes. Worried that CB Nite is gonna come get you? You can use Ice Beam. HP Fire for Scizor. Superpower for Heatran or Tyranitar. It's ridiculous. Tired of priority users coming in and getting 2ko's? Run Rocky Helmet and force them to lose like a third of their health in the process.
I've moved from thinking it's OU to being on the fence. I'm going to keep using it though and see what I start to think.
Although, Chople Tar stops the hazards set 100% of the time. I haven't done any calculations, but I'm sure he could be made to 2ko with reflect easily.
Scarftar's or any scarfer's usage is not relevant now.Generally, one free turn is all a sweeper needs to start wrecking a team, but I get what you're saying. The only problem is that you guys are resorting to scarfers to solve the problem. How common are scarfers in this metagame? From my experience there aren't many....You guys are assuming that if Deoxys-s gets banned and Azelf or some other Dual Screeners replace it there will suddenly be an increase in the number of scarftars. It could happen, but then remember that azelf isn't the only good DS user out there. There's also Deo-D who is pretty fast in its own right, and even Uxie, both of which have few issues with Scarfers due to their enormous bulk. Deo-D even has Taunt.
Edit: Also, be honest. When was the last time you've seen a scarftar? >.<
I think ToF and a few other players showed why versatility is extremely useful for Deoxys-S. When Deoxys-S can destroy the Pokemon that are on the short list of mons that straight up stop it by just switching around one or two moveslots, it's a real problem that is either going to make players afraid to stop Deoxys-S they way they think they should, or risk losing an important piece to dealing with a full Heavy Offense team.
This reminds me of when I was strict on UU paragraphs and made people show why easy spikes in DPP was so broken at the cost of one Pokemon heh (that one gave Heysup hell!). Once again I think this has been well shown that the amped up power of BW OU makes it that much harder to counter some of the stronger threats while hazards are up. Deoxys-S differentiates itself from the rest of the spikers/rockers in the game in that it can get SR/Spikes up in the first few turns, while potentially preventing your opponent from doing the same. Deoxys-S doing the spiking for heavy offense teams gives them the residual damage and the momentum that is just ridiculously hard to stop when you're taking some of the hardest hits in the game after Deoxys-S does its job.
I think kd24 did a perfect job here of showing that just Dragonite behind screens knocks its counters in OU down to a pitiful number. Just look at all the mons that are already somewhat difficult to counter such as Dnite, Mence, and Terrakion. Taking down those mons rely on being able to take them down in one or two hits. Without that ability, Terrakion now beats Gliscor, and Dnite and Mence now beat bulky waters every time, and on top of that are much harder to revenge kill.
This is kind of like what Aldaron is asking for, but I've seen the pro-uber side answer pretty convincingly that yes, Deoxys-S doing its job breaks the metagame. I want to see some evidence that it doesn't.
It is a 4hko behind Reflect.
So Deo-S will setup both screens and SR.And after Deo-S finally dies Bronzong is one of the biggest setup fodders for pokes like Volcarona and Dragonite.
So bronzong is out of the question.
kd24's argument is faulty - he assumes that Dual Screen Deoxys-S is setting up on a wall, letting Deoxys-S set up Screens + SR no problem and then Dragonite comes in unscathed and start setting up DD willy nilly.
One of the solid way to answer Dual Screen Deoxys-S is firing off your offense first. Send out your Volcarona. It wants to LSCreen? Volcarona's going to set up on you. You could switch to your Terrakion / Dragonite, but Volcarona's going to still put a dent on either of them, breaking MultiScale on Dragonite, and now Scizor can BP them out. Deoxys-S can Taunt instead of Screens, only to get knocked out by Bug Buzz with no screens. Putting up both screen is not a guarantee against a competent team with useful offense. The scenario above can be played with many Sweepers, since Deoxys-S can't do anything back.
kd24's Dragonite wont be getting free set-ups / sweeps in that scenario. And this illustration above is only one tactic, specifically for people using offensive teams. People with defensive teams can stall out the Reflect / Light Screen much easily, thanks to more dependable defensive pivots.