OK I decided Song comes first. This season he has been the most consistent player for Arsenal, and that is saying something considering there's the bloke from the Netherlands that has also done quite well. Song has strength, amazing reading of the game, wins almost every 1v1, and this season has added sublime passes to his weaponry. Half way through the season there was a ridiculous statistic that Song has made the most successful through balls in the PL, more than Silva and Mata and Modric! How many times have we heard pundits say Song has had a bad game? Or even got something wrong? Few or none is the sign of a great defensive player. On the other hand how many times have we heard pundits say 'what a sublime pass from Song to win the game!'? An unnaturally high amount of times! Song has developed into one of the best defensive mids in the world, and I wouldn't find it easy to argue against him being the best so he's on the list for me.
Cabaye comes next because he has been one of the most consistent and dependable players in the league. He kept being good and then producing moments of brilliance like free kicks into the top corner and stuff but it wasn't until his defence splitting pass to Cisse a few weeks ago that I thought this guy is bordering on ridiculous. When you've someone who has the vision and the ability to produce passes like that you know this guy is something special. He's more consistent than Modric this season, and I value consistency more than anything else but this guy has got bucketloads of magic on top. If he wasn't a cheese eating surrender monkey you could say he has everything.
Silva, very easy choice. Best left sided player in the league. Creative, elusive, you can never tell what he will do next. I love Cesc more but since the painful divorce Silva will have to do. Absolutely dripping with magic.
Valencia. If Silva was running the first half of the season, the second half is surely the Valencia show. OK he has been missing for a third of the season because of injury but when he has played he has been the best out and out winger in the PL. Intelligent, blazing fast, tricks, powerful shot, amazingly consistent cross, never makes a mistake, and most importantly, just gets on with his job! He happily plays right back with no fuss and still delivers crosses like a champ and has the energy to be solid in defence, and no moaning! SAF must be thinking he is dreaming because this guy plays like Ronaldo but without any of the baggage.