Danger Mouse said:As for Deoxys-D, I find that, though it does its job very well, it's not as good at laying hazards as Deoxys-S was. The massive difference in speed counts, and the prominence of scarf Genesect as a lead can make it difficult for Deoxys to get in safely. Despite its decent speed, there are faster taunters out there (anything with Prankster, Aerodactyl, Tornadus-T, etc.) and threats such as scarf Politoed that Deoxys-D can't tank a hit from. In addition to that, there are many viable spinners out there that can easily remove Deoxys' precious hazards, and Deoxys can't hope to beat all of them on its own.
So while I agree that Deoxys-D is very effective as a hazards setter, and might be the best hazard setter in OU right now, he is far from overcentralizing or broken. In fact, his ability to lay hazards is a fantastic deterrent to Volt-Turn, and stuff like Scizor and Genesect in general.
You just contradicted yourself there. Genesect really doesn't stop Deoxys-D anyway you look at it. It at best U-turns while Deoxys-D gets up Stealth Rock. Then Deoxy-D switches out and can be saved for, at worst, a sacrifice Pokemon to keep the momentum on your side. At worst it comes in on a slower Pokemon and still gets up Spikes which is its job.
alexwolf said:I just now saw Undisputed's post about Deoxys-D being broken, so here is my answer...
I don't believe that HO match-ups are up to a coinflip, as you are not forced to use Deoxys-D, because there are also other hazard and DS leads for HO teams, mianly Azelf and Espeon. Azelf wins vs Magic Coat-less Deoxys-D, still has SR and Taunt, while also having immense offensive pressence which he can abuse with Ice Punch, Fire Blast, Psychic, and Explosion. Espeon counters Deoxys-D no matter what, as well as setting up fast, un-Tauntable screens for your sweeprs to abuse, as well as having Yawn to prevent set-up and Baton Pass for momentum. Finally if you don't want to lead with one of those 2 pokes to deal with Deoxys-D, you can always lead with Scizor at turn 1, and immediately put the pressure on the opponent. If they use Taunt, while you use Bug Bite, they just lost any hope of hazards being up, and if they used SR as you used SD, then they are in for some serious pain. Or with your Volcarona. And the list goes on.
No offense, but I'm not sure how qualified you are to speak about Deoxys-D if you're bring up Azelf and Espeon as your first rebuttals.
I have been playing both Suspect OU and Normal OU off and on for the past couple weeks and have high rankings, and I don't think I've seen anyone use a Taunt lead Azelf other than myself. And if you're running Azelf, you're probably running a Screens Offense team, which is actually what I was doing.
Furthermore, very few people use Espeon. I've only seen it on Baton Pass teams. Suggesting Yawn is completely ludicrous as well.
I'd like to see list of Pokemon that stop Deoxys from getting Stealth Rock to open a match. Scizor runs the risk of taking HP Fire, so it doesn't count. No good player would take that risk unless there was a strong reason to believe Deoxy-D doesn't have HP Fire. Volcarona doesn't count either because it can just be Taunt/T-Waved and can't OHKO Deoxys with Bug Buzz.
Jimera0 said:Why? Because then I'm banning a single Pokemon instead of an entire play-style. It's not a hard choice for me to make. It'd be different if there were 4 or 5 Pokemon that were broken under it, but the vast majority of people don't think that's the case. Certainly, there are no 4 or 5 we can all agree on.
Arguments that rain TEAMS are, in and of themselves, unfair fall flat to me simply because I have never, at any point in this generation, had so much trouble with rain that I felt it was forcing me into a corner. This includes at the the start of my experience with BW, where I might as well have been a newbie considering how long I had been gone from the competitive scene and all the new stuff introduced in generation V. It's hard to sympathize with an opinion so foreign to me.
Weather is a part of generation V. This is not Generation IV, and I can't help but to think that people striving for a weatherless metagame are just reaching to have Gen IV with new Pokemon. The simple fact is that it's never been like that. Every generation has brought in not just new Pokemon, but new a whole new competitive environment. Generation II brought in entry hazards, Generation III brought in abilities, Generation IV brought in Stealth Rock and the physical special split. Generation V has brought in permanent weather conditions (fully I mean. Obviously Hail and Sandstorm were around before). You're not going to win playing as you would in generation IV, just as in generation IV you would not have won if you were playing like it was generation III. You have to adapt to change. Step out of your comfort zone and learn a new thing. I feel like some of us are still stuck in the past.
Please note that I'm not saying everyone should think the way I do. But I'd weep to see so much of what makes this generation special vanish because some people just don't want to adjust to it. I like the game the way it is, with all its competing and varied strategies, each one providing a unique but fair challenge to overcome.
If possible, can you make your posts more concise and to the point? They are very long and wordy and it makes them hard to read. I'm sure you have something constructive to add to the discussion, but I think most posters are intimidated by the length of your posts and how you bury your main points in the paragraphs. Attention span is pretty low on the internet, haha.