DoABarrelRoll said:Dusknoir also walls terrakion unless the musketeer's carrying a Choice Band or hits Dusk with Stone Edge on the switch, which is called prediction.
So how does predicting around the attack as opposed to just not caring about it equate to an advantage?
Dusk can switch in just as safely on Close Combat or X-Scissor, or even earthquake, and set up a sub.
Golurk, if EVed properly, can do the same, without losing any offensive power at all (and most likely, still being stronger than Dusknoir).
Dusknoir's access to will-o-wisp is imo a big reason why is it better than Golurk as a subpuncher
Most of the things you'd try to burn with Wisp, Golurk can already deal with just by punching their faces in. Iron Fist-boosted Ice Punch or Thunderpunch suffice in most situations where Wisp would save you from a Fighting-resistant poke (not that you should be SubPunching with Golurk since it has better things to do). If they dodge the Will-o-Wisp and set up Sub, there is little to nothing Dusknoir can do about it.
(the other reasons: 1. golurk can't set up as easily thanks to its ground-type, which makes it weak to water and grass, and 2. its worse bulk).
1: Its neutrailty to Water does little for it considering most Water attacks it encounters are too strong for it to face since they are boosted by Rain, most of the Water types don't even care about Dusknoir anyway. If there is no Rain there is most likely Sand, which Golurk does not care about while Dusknoir cannot gain HP made from Subs. The lack of Grass weakness is a bit more relevant since Bullet Seed Breloom and Ferrothorn do exist, but isn't a outright resist much better? I'd rather try Breloom or Toxicroak, both of which even have 12% per turn recovery. 2: Golurk's worse bulk is compensated by additional resistances (where the bulk would matter more) and greater offensive power. After all, isn't the point of a SubPuncher to punish foes with "free"
damage?
Also, dusk's ghost-typing and access to Will-o-Wisp make sure it isn't outclassed by Breloom and Toxicroak. landorus-t is afraid of Will-o-Wisp anyway and Gyarados can be hit with this move on the switch and won't sweep anytime soon.
Who cares about typing, what are you even trying to accomplish with Dusknoir? Kill Fighting-weak pokes? Then the Fighters are obviously better due to STAB, not to mention they aren't stuck with a piss weak 40 base power STAB to back up Focus Punch. Landorus-T can overcome Will-o-Wisp with Swords Dance while you do nothing in return; if Gyara isn't hit on the switch (which may not be easily telegraphed), Dusknoir has to get out of there and lose momentum for you.
DoABarrelRoll said:How? Focus Punch is a coverage move, not a move where you simply deal 100 damage because your offenses are just too weak. I think you are underestimating dusknoir's power.
Wait, now you claim Focus Punch is your coverage move?? So your main method to fight back is Shadow Sneak? By the looks of it, Dusknoir is almost completely dependant on unSTABed Focus Punch (lol) to do competent damage against neutral foes, while other SubPunchers can resort to their possible alternate STAB. We're not understimating Dusknoir's strength: 100 base Attack using an unSTABed 150 base power move is really unimpressive when you compare it to
walls like Ferrothorn's 94 base Attack using 120 base power STAB Power Whip, or Hippowdon's 112 base Attack using 100 base power STAB Earthquake. If you can't hit harder than that with your main offensive move, you know your power is really subpar for an offensive poke.
252+ Atk Dusknoir Focus Punch vs. 252 HP / 88+ Def Ferrothorn: 202-238 (57.38 - 67.61%) -- guaranteed 2HKO (What can Dusclops even do to Ferrothorn bar Will-o-Wisp? seismic toss is a contact move, meaning you take damage from the oh-so-annoying Iron Barbs)
252+ Atk Dusknoir Shadow Sneak vs. 0 HP / 0 Def Latios: 146-174 (48.5 - 57.8%) -- guaranteed 2HKO after Stealth Rock (what can 252 hp / 4 sdef dusclops do to it bar will-o-wisp? No leftovers means it's 2hkoed by Specs Draco Meteor)
You need to setup Sub on Ferro, which will easily break it with Power Whip, while going for Wisp means risking either Thunder Wave and/or Leech Seed. And another thing, Dusclops isn't really meant for taking on special attackers, but it can still attempt to outstall Latios with Pain Split after Draco Meteor. This Dusknoir on the other hand, takes 89.79 - 106.12% (37.5% chance to OHKO, guaranteed after SR) from Specs Draco Meteor, so....have fun.
And dusclops is complete setup bait for some dangerous special sweepers, like offensive volcarona (Dusknoir can at least put up a substitute and 3HKO it with Focus Punch). Magic Bounce and Taunt are huge problems for dusclops, while dusknoir can shadow sneak espeon and xatu for the 2HKO, while 2HKOing Azelf (which often carries Taunt) with Shadow Sneak.
Dusclops can use Curse (which at least combos well with Pain Split) to deter setup, and the Volcarona example is poor considering you could get burned by Flame Body, can't Focus Punch again after it breaks your Sub, and loses to Roost variants anyway. The Magic Bouncers and Azelf are rare in OU, better examples would be Taunt Terrakion and Gyarados, the former of which you actually lose to if you fail to set up a Substitute.
You shouldn't even compare dusclops to dusknoir, since Dusk's SubPunch set is imo viable in OU, while dusclops is complete trash because of how easily it becomes setup fodder.
We can compare them defensively (in which case Dusknoir would be eclipsed), while its "offensive niche" is better occupied by Golurk and other SubPunchers who can fight back with methods aside from Focus Punch (Golurk shouldn't even bother with Focus Punch). Of course, neither Dusclops or Dusknoir has any business at all in OU when something else could be doing their job better.