ArdentSun said:So... I'm confused by this. Lets look over them (Green is defensive, red is offensive):
Yzard:
Immune: Ground
Resistant: Bug, Grass, Fire, Steel, Fighting, Fairy
Weak: Water, Rock, Electric
STAB immunities: None
SE: Grass, Bug, Steel, Ice, Fighting
Neutral: 14 Types
Xzard:
Immune: None
Resistant: Bug, Grass, Fire, Steel, Electric
Weak: Rock, Ground, Dragon
STAB immunities: Fairy
SE: Grass, Steel, Bug, Ice, Dragon
Neutral: 18 Types
Yzard has resistance to fairy and fighting moves which is huge, while Xzard only has electric resistance. If you count water as a weakness on Yzard, then they have the same amount of weaknesses, if you don't count it (Which you shouldn't because not many Yzards are going to stay in if Drought goes away especially since the main other weather users hurt it badly) then he only has 2 weaknesses. Xzard's secondary stab is ineffective against fairy types, providing free switch ins occasionally (Especially if locked into Outrage). Additionally, Xzard has no immunities to any types, while Yzard has ground immunity. This gives it a distinct advantage when mega evolving because if the opponent's predictions are off it could lead to a free turn for Yzard, but not for Xzard. It also gives Yzard a distinct advantage on teams allowing for occasional free switch ins with good prediction.
Yzard has these advantages in relation to typing:
More resistances
Better resistances
Less weaknesses
Important immunity
No ineffective STAB
And these disadvantages:
4x weakness to Rock
Slightly less neutral coverage on STAB
...
Pretty sure that's it actually.
I don't know where you are coming from when you say that Xzard has better typing. Both of them are crippled by SR enough to where they need it removed before they go in. Both of them have dangerous weaknesses in Rock and Dragon/Earthquake. Yzard might have to watch out for being hit with an 80% accuracy Stone Miss or Head Smash, but Xzard has to watch out for 100% accuracy Earthquake and Dragon Pulse, and 90% accuracy Draco Meteor. Both of them and all pokemon have their respective counters, so saying that Yzard is scared when a TTar or Politoed jumps in is the same as saying that Xzard is scared when a bulky fairy comes in (Especially if during his Outrage, which mind you is much more dangerous to be locked into than Solarbeam Especially if they are resistant to fire, like Azumarill).
Bottom line is that Yzard has better defensive typing (Especially with Drought up, which should be always), and his offensive typing is only slightly worse. Fire/Flying is SE against 5 things, while Fire Dragon is also SE against 5 things. Neutral coverage is only in favor of Xzard by 4 types, which isn't a lot. Especially considering that most of Xzard's standard moves have a lower BP than Yzard's standard moves.
X doesn't have any 4x weaknesses and has more neutral coverage. He may not be resistant to as many things as Y but he has better STABs, can't be countered as easily due to his type and not having reliance on Drought, and will still be neutral to water moves even if there's no Drought on the field. (and Drought can be given to X with support from Ninetails anyway. That's actually one thing I prefer about X's ability - X can get sun support via something else, but nothing can give Char Y tough claws. Not that having Drought isn't amazing for Char Y)
Y struggles when you face an opponent with a SR'd controlled game -and- a weather mon, making the rock weakness stand out even worse. Char Y has to keep switching to fight this but because of his type, he is not suitable to be doing this. You can run defog and that -will- help, but you can't afford to fail. And Y can get OHKO'd by rock moves from pokemon -even without stab and average atk- due to that 4x weakness and mediocre def. It's been said a million times, but we know that both Char's have to worry about SR's before the MEvo, but at least Char X will be set once he's already MEvo'd, and doesn't have an ability that can get countered or run out and push him to switch later on.
The 4x weakness to Rock is what makes it a worse type, in my opinion. Not just because of SR's, either. And I would definitely still count water as a weakness, as Char X is neutral to it and doesn't need a weather ability out to make it so. Drought can be countered while X will always be neutral. Also, the same can be said both ways about the surprise factors for Char Y. If they think it's Y and use electric or a physical move(due to low def), that works in favor for X if they guess wrong. And Rock moves eliminate the need to guess, for the most part, against a Mega Char. But unlike Y, if the opponent has one and uses it as a way to ensure it's effective, at least he can survive it. It works for both of them, so I'd say that surprise factor is about equal for them anyway.