vox_amoris said:Is Baton Pass a problem for the development of the metagame?
No, because a metagame is not a static thing. It is like a Pokemon in that it evolves. Should a strategy or concept within a metagame become dominant or popular, then it is up to the players of that game to discover or brainstorm ways to counter the strategy. Simply banning something because it is considered to be "cheap" or "not take skill" is silly. This comes across as whining. Also, stating that Baton Pass is unhealthy for the metagame is only true if no counters to the Baton Pass strategy can be found.
Do you believe that banning individual Pokémon would make Baton Pass manageable?
Of course Baton Pass will become more manageable if you remove the things that make it a viable strategy! That's like saying Stall teams would be more manageable if you removed instant recovery.
Would you support a blanket ban on the move Baton Pass?
No, even if I were to agree that Baton Pass teams are bad for the metagame, banning a move that has other uses (escaping Pursuit trapping, giving a teammate a simple one off boost or Substitute) makes no sense. Imo, the only things that should ever be banned (other than individual Pokemon in the sense of legendaries being Uber) are issues which can only be fixed by GameFreak changing their mechanics. Drizzle/Swift Swim is a good example of proper banning.
Would you support the introduction of complex bans?
While a complex ban would do a better job of addressing the issue than simply banning a move or Pokemon, I stand by my answer to the first question. A metagame is meant to change over time, not be a constant entity. The tools necessary to counter Baton Pass (Haze, Clear Smog, Perish Song, phazing, etc) may be considered niche given the current state of the metagame, but if Baton Pass becomes the dominant strategy that people seem to be arguing it already is, then these "niche" moves will become standard. Teambuilding is an integral part of competitive Pokemon, and understanding the strengths and weaknesses of your team is crucial. No team is EVER going to be able to counter every possible strategy or Pokemon.
As you said early in your response, it is up to the players to decide how to counter a strategy. I agree. But, if the community of players (the ones smart enough to identify whether or not countering baton pass causes over-centralization of the metagame) eventually decides to employ a complex ban to nerf baton pass, would you support this? It is ultimately up to the players after all.
The metagame is meant to change over time. Once again, I agree. One thing I personally don't like about baton pass is that the strategy revolves around a pretty constant team with very little variation. While this is change from where the previous metagame was at, I don't quite see that as healthy. The metagame needs to be diverse, and the baton pass strategy uses one team and one team only (again, maybe someone might choose to swap around one or two mons, but the core team is essentially the same). This is the very definition of over centralizing.
One thing that I do not quite agree with is this "Baton Pass is unhealthy for the metagame is only true if no counters to the Baton Pass strategy can be found". That doesn't quite work. A true counter exists for nearly everything (e.g. Gastrodon walls Kyogre most the time), but some counters really are obscure or very few. Quaggy and Tentacruel with haze are obscure but reliable counters to baton pass. From what I've heard, Mega Pinsir and Mega Heracross can be quite dangerous too, but none of these are "hard counters" to the baton pass strategy. For example, Zapdos walls Mega Pinsir (unless the player is odd enough to let it SD four times) and Sylveon walls Mega Heracross - coming back to my point about baton pass revolving around a core team; Sylveon and Zapdos are almost always in this core.
Just my thoughts :)