Now that I have had a chance to test it out, both using and against, I think I've made my decision.
koolkranny said:I have been using Mega Salamence and the only time I have ever actually had a problem beating a team with it, was a bulky choice band Gyrados. And that isn't exactly the most common mon or set.
To fully understand what is going on with Mega Mence, I'm going to break down what makes people want to ban it.
A big problem is that Salamence is viable as either a mega or a non mega. And even if you know it is a mega, you can't be certain if it is the special set or a physical set. It's unpredictability is the first major qualm everyone has with it.
Then comes the abilities. Before it mega evolves it intimidates the opponents. When you factor in how much physical bulk it has (95/130/90, thats better than Skarmory) then you realize that it can switch into a physical opponent, mega evolve and set up a dragon dance while they switch out or futilely try to break him, and then proceed to sweep the opponents entire team, only getting out-sped by priority. Aerialate is mega Mence's ablility, which makes normal type moves become flying, and gives them a boost of 30% in addition to the stab gained. There have been enough calcs on this thread to emphasize the amount of power a return or double edge does.
Another problem is that Mence has menacing stats before he mega evolves, and even more menacing stats after. As a pseudo-legendary, Salamence starts off with a BST of 600. They are spread mostly evenly with an emphasis on ATK and SPA. 100 Speed allows it to tie with most of the XY megas. After Mega Evolution, its BST becomes 700, putting it above cover legendaries such as Ho-oh, Palkia, or Xerneas. It's ATK goes up, its DEF becomes tankish, and its speed (120) allows it to go faster than most of the meta.
The fun doesn't stop there however, its typing is the icing on the cake. Dragon/Flying gives it extraordinary coverage options, allowing it to hit most everything neutrally with stab. Or it can drop the dragon stab move and use earthquake instead, allowing it to hit steel types. This leaves only flying/electric or levitating electric types able to resist it's moves.
Down sides to Mega Mence:
4X weakness to Ice means that anyone who can go faster and has decent SPA investment can KO with an ice beam.
252 SpA Deoxys-A Ice Beam vs. 144 HP / 0 SpD Mega Salamence: 548-648 (149.3 - 176.5%) -- guaranteed OHKO
Fairy weakness means that most Hyper Voices OHKO even through a substitute. Some redirection on the opponents side plus specs Sylveon was a common strategy before ORAS, and still has the ability destroy teams.
252+ SpA Choice Specs Pixilate Sylveon Hyper Voice vs. 144 HP / 0 SpD Salamence: 612-720 (166.7 - 196.1%) -- guaranteed OHKO
Trick room completely shuts down Mence's ability to sweep, requiring teammates to stall or defeat the Trick room team. Prankster paralysis is also common and can also do the same thing.
I will hold out judgement until I can get a good handle on how Mega Salamence works in the new meta. It isn't invincible, but it is giving Mega Kangaskhan a run for her money.
Ok, I've had a chance to play with and against several Mega Mence teams, and I have come to the conclusion that the ladder doesn't help determine the viability of Mega Salamence. Now that that's out of the way, I did get the chance to play a few good players with and against MMence. And I'll be honest, Mega Mence Earthquake was underwhelming. It did only moderate damage to steel types (most of them were named Aegislash, Heatran was too much a coward to stay in when Mega Mence was on the field)
252 Atk Mega Salamence Earthquake vs. 252 HP / 0 Def Aegislash-Shield: 124-148 (38.2 - 45.6%) -- guaranteed 3HKO after Leftovers recovery
+1 252 Atk Mega Salamence Earthquake vs. 252 HP / 0 Def Aegislash-Shield: 186-220 (57.4 - 67.9%) -- guaranteed 2HKO after Leftovers recovery
252+ SpA Aegislash-Blade Shadow Ball vs. 0 HP / 0 SpD Salamence: 175-207 (52.8 - 62.5%) -- guaranteed 2HKO
Mega Salamence needs that Dragon Dance or help from a partner to actually do significant damage to Aegis. But the ability to use wide guard allowes a partner mon to wreak havoc on mences team, or to knock out the redirection, or any other number of things. By playing that kind of mind game, you can deal some significant damage to Mence or the rest of it's team. By itself, Physical Mega Salamence cannot take out a wide guard Aegislash. Aegislash isn't a hard counter to Mega Mence, but it does cause serious headaches for the mence player.
Another problem with Mence is the move pool. Aerialate return or double edge does serious damage, but then you have to have dragon dance and Sub/Tect. That leaves one moveslot for coverage. Dragon claw for Flying/Electric mons, EQ for Steel, or Aqua tail if you don't want Mence to live long.
Combined with all the other counters mentioned in previous posts, I do not believe that Mega Salamence is unbeatable. It loses to common threats like SPA invested ice beam, trick room (yes, trick room is a problem for Mega Mence, if you don't think it is, then I want to see a replay of you beating a good player using a good TR team without breaking a sweat) and Fariy types (Sylveon, MMawile, MDiancie)
I am leaning very heavily towards no ban at the moment. I will need some seriously good evidence or a very good argument to sway me back.