Uselesscrab said:• "Super annoying" — that isn't justification to ban something. I find Prankster Spore super annoying.
• "Beast move on Rayquaza" — So are a lot of moves. Gale Wings Rayquaza with Aeroblast or Oblivion Wing is also annoying, just for different reasons.
• "Shedinja remover without being useless and gimmicky" — Lum Shed still beats this provided it doesn't have to switch in to Chatter. I'd also like to point out that status, Leech Seed, Curse, hazards, partial trapping, etc., are not "useless and gimmicky."
I will admit my argument totally failed. I was trying to say something similar to what Rumour said, but i was tired and lost my ability to create genuine and understandable argument. But i felt that Smog needed to know of how much i hated chatter, so i posted regardless.
Still, even though i failed, that does not give you the right to paraphrase. Not once did i say leech seed, curse, hazards, partial trapping, etc, were useless and gimicky (in fact those are great moves that just happen to double as sheddy checks). Things that are gimmicky and useless are things like moldy pursuit and infestation.
Side note: Chatter is much more spammable (not sure if thats the right word) than status, since chatter does actual damage, so lum sheddy is much less safe from switching in if it has chatter as opposed to say toxic. And even if sheddy does get toxic'd, its not dead, sheddy can still act as a pivot somewhat, it can still endeavor something one last time, and is immune to sleep. But if sheddy gets chattered? Well, things arent looking too good for sheddy.
I think chatter is the best way to eliminate sheddy. Why? Sheddy can reliably pivot out of infestation/related trapping moves, leech seed, curse, and status (excluding paralysis and sleep). Hazards can be removed, and moldy pursuit is incedibly specialized and is ONLY useful for eliminating sheddy, plus it cant kill sheddy if its behind a sub (a rare situation but it has happened to me before). However, sheddy cannot reliably pivot out of chatter unless lum berry, and can kill sheddys behind a sub. And the best part about chatter is its obscurity, (unlike moldy pursuit) anything could potentially run chatter, you would have no clue it has chatter, and it has incredible utiliyy outside of buttraping sheddy. I mean, i have faced contrary MMY and regenerator Registeel with chatter before.
For these reasons, and reasons others have stated (Rumour and motherlove) i think chatter just has to go. Im not primarily banning it because its 'super annoying', i want it banned because it is guaranteed to hit he opponent, guarantees the opponent will only do something 50% of the time, it allows for easy set up and wall/stall breaking, does damage, can be slapped on basically ANY pokemon without 4MSS, and kills sheddy.
Can prankster spore, gale wings aeroblast or oblivion wing fill these categories Uselesscrab? Didnt think so.
Edit: Now THIS is an argument lol
Edit 2: rip Uselesscrab