Ok enormous post and update time so grab a snack. I'll be updating the rankings this time around so here we go. All the changes have been taken into account in the OP but if anything just let me know preferably on my wall and not here and I'll change it as soon as I can.
Rank Placements:
Manaphy:
stays in A
Torn-t:
stays in A-
Dragonite:
stays in B+
Kingdra:
stays in B+
Mew:
stays in B+
Mega Beedrill:
stays in B+
Mega Sceptile:
stays in B+
Volcarona:
moves up to B+
Togekiss:
stays in B
Victini:
stays in B
Mega Ampharos:
moves down to C-
Mega Lopunny:
stays in A+
Thundurus:
stays in A+
Charizard-Y:
stays in A
Mega Gardevoir:
stays in A
Garchomp:
stays in A
Mamoswine:
stays in A-
Dragalge:
moves up to B-
Crawdaunt:
moves down to B-
Sylveon:
stays in B-
Doublade:
moves down to C
Mega Camerupt:
moves down to C
Mega Latios:
moves down to C
Ok so I'm only going to explain Sylveon in terms of details since it was the more controversial one in regards to the feedback from the thread and everything else is more or less subject to change anyways. Sylveon was agreed upon by the ranking team to stay in B- because its offensive capabilities in regards to its Specs set is vastly exaggerated amongst the community at times. Sylveon is a prediction reliant mon that must not only predict the right coverage move but due to the nature of many balance minded teams, the popular archetype of our meta, teams pack enough tools at their disposable to have breathing room against Specs Sylveon. Specs Sylveon shines against offensive teams with no consistent switch in for the most part, however this is a double edged sword because the loss of bulk in comparison to its previous relevant set, the cleric set, is significant enough to wear Sylveon down and will find very few switch in opportunities coupled in with its low speed against various balanced and offensive cores.
As previously stated we worked on a lower ranking clean up that was done by the ranking team. Various Pokemon were moved around to accommodate meta game trends and to fix some of the very old rankings that simply do not apply anymore. They'll be put in hide tags as to not make the appearance of the post too large.
Lower Rank Clean Up
Absol: stays in C
Mega Aggron: moves down to C-
Alakazam: moves down to C-
Blastoise: stays in C
Ditto: moves down to C-
Entei: stays in C
Glalie Mega: moves down to D
Goodra: stays in C
Gourgeist XL: moves down to C-
Heracross: moves up to C+
Infernape: stays in C
Mienshao: goes unranked
Porygon 2: stays in C
Reuninclus: stays in C
Rotom-H: moves down to D
Sableye: moves down to D
Seismitoad: moves up to C+
Shuckle: stays in C
Slowking: moves up to C+
Thundurus-T: stays in C
Blissey: stays in C-
Cofagrigus: moves down to D
Diance: moves down to D
Dugtrio: stays in C-
Espeon: stays in C-
Exploud: moves down to D
Gourgeist Small: goes Unranked
Haxorus: moves down to D
Lanturn: goes unranked
Ludicolo: moves down to D
Noivern: stays in C-
Pangoro: stays in C-
Smeargle: stays in C-
Tornados: goes unranked
Whimsicott: stays in C-
Zygarde: stays in C-
Arcanine: Goes unranked
Cacturne: Goes unranked
Chandelure: Stays in D
Cloyster: Stays in D
Flygon: Goes unranked
Froslass: stays in D
Gorebyss: stays in D
Meloetta: goes unranked
Salamence: stays in D
Venomoth: goes unranked
Emboar: goes from unranked to D
Next Slate Up For Discussion:
Ok so this slate is gonna have some regular discussion in terms of meta game trends....and some more controversial cases as seen in the first two so please don't go bonkers when you look at them.
Lando-I: from A+ to S
M-Sableye: from S to A+
Raikou: from B+ to A-
Doublade: Doublades placement
Tyrantrum: from unranked to C+
Mienshao: Unranked to D
Starmie: from A- to A
Magnezone: from A- to B+
Hippowdon: from A- to A
Forretress from Unranked to D
Lando-I discussion is stemming from a couple months worth of hints by many top players, months of Lando-I adapting to the meta quite easily, along with its potency in the tier due to the variety of tools it has at its disposable, becoming one of the top tier threats in our meta at this point in time and a force to be reckoned with. These are the ideas established by those who feel it should be S rank, however those who will feel like it's A+ will emphasize its poor immediate match-up against fast paced offense, although Lando-I is known to utilize Rock Polish sets to mitigate this minor problem.
M-Sableye discussion is stemming from the same reasons as Lando-I, however it's on the premise that its effectiveness as a top tier threat has died down due to how the meta has adapted towards it with tools as SD Gliscor, Sub CM Keldeo, Unaware CM Clefable, etc. Is M-Sableyes defensive presence coupled with its utility enough to maintain its S rank position or are the flaws it exhibits apparent enough to where a ranking of A+ is more suitable?
Raikou raising a sub rank stems from discussion from a lot of individuals both here and outside the thread and has been discussed to death honestly but the rise from UU to OU sort of confirmed that it has shown effectiveness in the metagame for more focused discussion, so once again, you guys get to discuss this to death .-. be gentle though.
Doublade dropped a sub rank by virtue of how these rankings work at times however......it's established amongst the community to be a pretty bad Pokemon used to carve out a relatively small niche that has mostly become irrelevant from XY to ORAS. So this is on the chopping block for going unranked or w/e rank is found to be suitable based on good arguments that applies to its realistic practical use along with its defensive utility in comparison to other ranked Pokemon who serve defensive roles.
Tyrantrum we're going ahead to put a ranking on this, as soon it'll hold some relevancy in the tier anyways based off of its Band and Dragon Dance sets primarily. C+ was there as a starting point provided by the ranking team but if something lower is much more suitable feel free to elaborate why.
Mienshao was just unranked for the time being however I promised to give ben gay the benefit of the doubt that it's more along the lines of D rank, as it can realistically be used efficiently with various utility moves that can be utilized effectively as a stand alone Pokemon or part of a Volt-Turn core, think Raikou and Lando-T. So for those that have actually used it feel free to discuss it. For those that haven't keep an open mind and stop theorymonning and use it to give yourself an idea.
Reasoning for Magnezone can be found in
this post. Starmie and Hippowdon rises come from the consistency of their use in the tier as they are part of many strong foundations seen on a variety of builds. If you've been watching SPL or just have seen and used these effectively you'll get the idea so some discussion on this.
Let's get something straight before you guys discuss this. Forretress is being open for discussion based on its Custap set. Not its defense stat, not some weird set you saw in UU low ladder and thought "wow this is the future of competitive pokemon, Counter Sturdy for Flare Blitz Darmanitan!!", its custap variants is what is being discussed. We know it's outclassed by Skarmory in some aspects, don't state the obvious.
This post by TFL sums it up pretty well from earlier so feel free to discuss this.
You're free to discuss whatever as well but do realize this is a lot of stuff and some things we'll be looking at more heavily in terms of discussion over others who already have a solidified ranking.