kingmidas said:Phanphy's bulk is good but its not insanely good when you realize how shitty a defensive typing ground is. Its outclassed by sandshrew and drilbur, of which the former has knock off and greater physical bulk (which is more relevant) and higher attack to use EQ/rock slide/koff, and the latter has a very important benchmark speed hits much harder, has access to stuff like SD and can actually threaten stuff with its powerful stab from the get go. Ice shard is weak and doesn't hit anything important, why would you run it. The rest of the moves are just random coverage that doesn't accomplish much bar gunk shot which is decent for hitting grass types. It doesn't even get rapid spin, its just an SR mon that can't do much outside of it. D rank at best.
I find it hard to believe you ever used bulbasaur if you think its outclassed by bellsprout that badly. No one is gonna use it over foongus, that has nothing to do with it. What it has over bellsprout is actual bulk, it can tank hits from fighters and get in much easier, as well as wear down its answers with knock off before finishing them off, making up for its lack of power initially and its less useless outside of sun because of that. It doesn't rely on sludge bomb poison chances to break through vullaby n company. Weather ball would be cool to have but in return you have the added bulk to take priority from pawniard and I believe 21/12 with eviolite can take an acro from fletchling if it needs to. It works much better on sun balance than sun offense where bellsprout is superior because it doesn't just do its own thing with support from the rest of the team.
Meowth has 4mss and its a pick your poison on what you wanna lose to and hit. You cannot have koff and aerial ace if you want water pulse or u-turn instead of aerial ace, not to mention u-turn is not tech boosted. Meowth is a decent revenge killer, but even with tech he is weak, especially when fake out and feint have extremely low bp to begin with, theres issues there. Fire types and ferroseed are major problems, as they both switch in easy on (water pulse on ponyta doesn't hurt that badly to my knowledge but larvesta cannot as well) and ferroseed just sits in front of it. Its outclassed by aipom who has ways of getting past its answers and hits extremely hard, have a spammable stab, and an amazing movepool + the same speed tier, while it lacks priority its much more threatening, and suffers teh same issues as fires/ferroseed (except it can actually beat ferroseed).
Honedge's physical bulk is undermined by the slightly low hp so theres an issue there. Rock slide just hits larvesta and pony, and in return you give up SD or pursuit, which are its best parts. Abra can just run shadow ball and nuke you if it has its sash up its a strong check but not a counter, its an easy switch in for most mons because its stabs don't hit hard enough and swords dance relies on shadow sneak to do damage to anything faster to prevent an RK.
I agree that ground isn't fantastic, but Phanpy really deserves to be ranked somewhere.
You say that Bulbasaur can "wear down its answers with knock off before finishing them off" but Bellsprout also has access to Knock Off and has a great 75 Attack stat as opposed to Bulbasaur's sub-par 49. You also claim that Bulbasaur "doesn't rely on sludge bomb poison chances to break through vullaby n company" but how exactly is Bulbasaur supposed to break through Vullaby and "company" (I suppose this means walls like Porygon which are 2HKO'd by Solarbeam, but please feel free to explain what you meant) any better than Bellsprout can?
"You have the added bulk to take priority from Pawniard" so can Bellsprout ??
156 Atk Pawniard Sucker Punch vs. 36 HP / 76 Def Eviolite Bellsprout: 9-12 (40.9 - 54.5%) -- 68.4% chance to 2HKO after Stealth Rock
And you imply the added bulk makes up for not having Weather Ball but that really isn't true, since HP fire is a lot weaker.
Also, Bulbasaur can't take a Fletchling Acrobatics with 21/12 bulk, as you thought.
196+ Atk Fletchling Acrobatics (110 BP) vs. 0 HP / 44 Def Eviolite Bulbasaur: 20-26 (95.2 - 123.8%) -- 75% chance to OHKO
(and this is without Stealth Rock).
As for Meowth, it really isn't all that weak. Fake Out + Feint kills Fletch after rocks, and can pretty much revenge every Choice Scarf user. Also, Feint has +2 priority which is extremely valuable. Sure, Meowth has 4mss but each moveslot is extremely valuable and lets it plow through a ton of its checks (Water Pulse for Pony/Larv/Rock Types, Aerial Ace for fighters, U-turn for pivoting, various Hidden Powers).
"Water Pulse on Ponyta doesn't hurt that badly"
36 SpA Life Orb Technician Meowth Water Pulse vs. 0 HP / 0 SpD Eviolite Ponyta: 13-16 (61.9 - 76.1%) -- 6.3% chance to OHKO after Stealth Rock
Also Ferroseed does not just "sit in front of it," since it has technician-boosted hidden power to cripple it's checks as I've stated several times.
36 SpA Life Orb Technician Meowth Hidden Power Fire vs. 84 HP / 148+ SpD Eviolite Ferroseed: 16-21 (72.7 - 95.4%) -- 6.3% chance to OHKO after Stealth Rock
If you're really weak to Ferro, you can run HP Fire, but if you run the typical HP Fighting set, Ferroseed can only reliably switch in one time.
36 SpA Life Orb Technician Meowth Hidden Power Fighting vs. 84 HP / 148+ SpD Eviolite Ferroseed: 8-10 (36.3 - 45.4%) -- guaranteed 3HKO after Stealth Rock
It most certainly is not outclassed by Aipom, since their roles differ. You said Aipom can "actually beat Ferroseed" but Aipom really doesn't have a lot of room (Fake Out, Fury Swipes, Knock Off, U-turn - and it would probably prefer Brick Break over Fire Punch anyway) and Meowth has Technician Hidden Powers.
As for Honedge, it does obviously have it's flaws. However, Abra fails to ohko with Shadow Ball (240 SpA Abra Shadow Ball vs. 0 HP / 140 SpD Eviolite Honedge: 14-18 (66.6 - 85.7%) -- guaranteed 2HKO after Stealth Rock - you mentioned sash abra not life orb, since life orb abra is obviously OHKO'd by shadow sneak). It also serves as a fantastic check to normals, fairies, and some birds (not all of them - mainly Taillow and non-overheat fletch). Also Abra doesn't have room for Shadow Ball on the Sash set (psychic/dgleam/hp fighting/protect) and although Life Orb can run Shadow Ball it dies to Shadow Sneak, so Honedge is a pretty efficient check. However I do agree with what you said about it's low HP and I think it's lack of special bulk also does hold it back.
Also, you have no idea what mons I do and don't use, so feel free to never make that accusation again. Thanks for the reply, though!
