Xatu S –> A+ (tl;dr in the end)
Well, I know that Xatu is probably like a god to us alongside Sawk and Klinklang, but… It just isn’t a S-Rank nowadays imo. Don’t get me wrong, I know that Xatu’s capability to check Fight-types and prevent hazards is a god send to a tier like NU, but the way the metagame is developing right now isn’t doing him any good.
First, the cliché argument of the new drops: Shiftry and Skuntank just give Xatu the middle finger (Shiftry has to be aware of bug coverage tho!), while Hitmonchan is a Fight-type that don’t really mind Xatu due to Iron Fist + Ice Punch. Of those, maybe Shiftry is the one that may actually fear Xatu, as the bird can tank a Dark move (IF colbur!) and retaliate with U-Turn or Signal, whith the later having a good chance of OHKOing. "But Ren-chon, Xatu is hella fast. You can just bump his speed!" Yeah, you can, but at the cost of doing even worse against the things you were supposed to check (and a lot of them already has priority, is faster/scarfed or you can't switch in anyway)
Hide
252 Atk Life Orb Iron Fist Hitmonchan Ice Punch vs. 248 HP / 180 Def Xatu: 234-278 (70.2 - 83.4%) -- guaranteed 2HKO
252+ Atk Life Orb Iron Fist Hitmonchan Ice Punch vs. 248 HP / 180 Def Xatu: 257-304 (77.1 - 91.2%) -- guaranteed 2HKO
252 Atk Life Orb Shiftry Knock Off (97.5 BP) vs. 248 HP / 180 Def Colbur Berry Xatu: 185-218 (55.5 - 65.4%) -- guaranteed 2HKO
252 Atk Life Orb Shiftry Knock Off vs. 248 HP / 180 Def Xatu: 244-291 (73.2 - 87.3%) -- guaranteed 2HKO
252 SpA Life Orb Shiftry Dark Pulse vs. 248 HP / 0 SpD Colbur Berry Xatu: 177-211 (53.1 - 63.3%) -- guaranteed 2HKO
252 SpA Life Orb Shiftry Dark Pulse vs. 248 HP / 0 SpD Xatu: 354-421 (106.3 - 126.4%) -- guaranteed OHKO
224+ Atk Dread Plate Skuntank Sucker Punch vs. 248 HP / 180 Def Colbur Berry Xatu: 144-169 (43.2 - 50.7%) -- 2% chance to 2HKO
224+ Atk Dread Plate Skuntank Sucker Punch vs. 248 HP / 180 Def Xatu: 288-338 (86.4 - 101.5%) -- 6.3% chance to OHKO
224+ Atk Dread Plate Skuntank Pursuit vs. 248 HP / 180 Def Colbur Berry Xatu: 72-85 (21.6 - 25.5%) -- 0.5% chance to 4HKO
224+ Atk Dread Plate Skuntank Pursuit vs. 248 HP / 180 Def Xatu: 144-170 (43.2 - 51%) -- 3.1% chance to 2HKO
Phew, that was a lot of calcs for the same mons, but just showing how much of a problem Xatu has with the new drops. Oh, and remembering that while Colbur is a good option to let you be a one time check to Dark-types, it isn't a definitive one and still doesn't allow you to switch in said Dark-types! Now, speaking about the meta itself, it too isn't doing good to the poor totem: Primeape is becoming more common, and is able to deal with Xatu via Ice Punch/Stone Miss or U-Turning to the Skuntank he's often used with; Rotom-Fan is getting more usage as a offensive check to Fight-types, Sawk is still a problem to Xatu due to Knock Off and maybe Ice Punch; Ice-types are seeing some more usage since Sneasel left the tier; he has problems with some SR Setters like Rhydon, Archeops, Carracosta, offensive Thunderbolt Mesprit, lead Aurorus, Piloswine and, of course, the almighty lead Pinsir. Yes, it can deal with like half of this list depending of coverage, but now comes Xatu main problem: he can't fit all he wants in the same moveset. You'll ALWAYS miss something, be it Thunder Wave, Giga Drain, Heat Wave, you name it (and even Giga isn't a guaranteed KO on Rhydon, Carracosta and lol maybe a 3/4HKO on Regirock?). It still nulifies Ferroseed from using hazards and maybe "checks" Garbodor's (T)Spikes, even though the offensive set of the later isn't an as rare of a sight nowadays. And not really an argument against Xatu but in the current meta, Fight resists that aren't weak to Dark or are bulky enough to tank hits (let's be honest: Xatu isn't really too bulky, it depends way too much on his defensive typing to wall things) like defensive Mesprit.
And I'm just talking about the things that Xatu was supposed to do (bounce back hazards and check Fight-types), I won't even say a word about the things that were already a headache, and are still being used as the tier shift didn't really do anything bad to 'mons that were already hard for him to even switch in like Scyther, Fire-types, Lanturn and others. Well, now just reforcing the moveset argument: people seems to love Xatu by how you can tailor him to fit your team needs in the teambuilder, but it just can't nowadays: you need Giga Drain for SR Setters, you need Thunder Wave for setuppers, you need Heat Wave for Klinklang, you need Bug coverage for the Dark-types... This argument can be used for almost every mon, I know, but the fact that it's so huge on Xatu is a big problem, don't you think?
Oh, and before someone say that his moveset depends on what your team has problem against, let's remember that you can easily take advantage of Xatu with everything it doesn't packs the Super Effective coverage to hit @_@ (maybe not the U-Turn versions, but you understand what I'm trying to say) Well, sorry for the long as hell text, but only with a wall text one can show Xatu's bad points and argue against his supposedly good ones ;_; Also ffs not an argument but the fact that Xatu is 99% of the time poisoned by Poison Jab/Sludge Bomb/Gunk Shot makes me mad.
Don't get me wrong, folks: it can still check a lot of mons specially the new NU waifu Gurdurr, but in my opinion it just isn't as good as it was or people say it is
tl;dr (I don't know how to change spoiler tags, so deal with it n_n)
Hide
The tier shift and the way the metagame is developing affected Xatu way more than we would like to admit, with Dark-types becoming more common as well as the Skuntank+Fight-type core; NU nowadays has a preference for bulkier Fight resists or ones that aren't weak to Dark, like Rotom-Fan, Pelipper and Poison-types; he still has problem with common SR Setters if not running Giga Drain; his 4mss is unfortunately way too bad (maybe an exaggeration, sorry); depends way too much on his typing to wall things; and still has problem with the same 'mons as he did in the last metas. In general, Xatu is still really good, but not S-Rank ;_;