yourDeadGrandad said:I think HMs could be fixed in a couple of ways:
1) Making them an innate part of a Pokemon rather than a move they can learn. If a Pokemon could learn Strength, then it can push boulders around in the overworld regardless of its moves. Got a Tyranitar? Then you can push boulders, smash rocks, cut bushes and surf in the water.
2) Give HM effects to different moves. Golbat has Air Cutter? Then you can get through that bush!
3) As normal, but their power depends on the level of the user. You get Cut fairly early in most games, so if it were powerful enough to be competitive it would probably break the game. But give your starter this BP 50 move at the beginning of the game, and by the time you face the Elite 4 it's maxed out at 120 BP? That might make it more worthwhile?
Edit: I would love for Cut to regain its ability to cut long grass. No idea why they got rid of that feature. It at least made the move slightly more worthwhile.
1) I had a similar idea, though instead of it being natural to the Pokemon how about once you get the HM (and the Badge to use if it required) you can simply select to use the HM from your bag, select a Pokemon who can use the HM, and the Pokemon would then use the HM without needing to learn it.
2) Slash, Night Slash, Psycho Cut, Leaf Blade, Fury Cutter... and this is just for Cut. Now for some moves like Surf and Dive you can't really replace it, but moves like Cut & Strength you can other moves also so (heck, you can probably use Bounce as a pseudo Fly).
3) Maybe not that powerful, but I do agree that maybe the HM moves should become better the more Badges you get. Now that'll nerf some HMs at the start like Surf and Fly, though that just means you can get those HMs early. Also they should be given additional effects, like maybe having Cut break Light Screen and Reflect.
Siggu said:"What do you mean I can't have my Scyther cut this bush without Cut?"
At least Scyther can learn Cut
stage7_4 said:While some HM's being pretty useless moves to force on pokemon that can only have 4 is a definite criticism, I think the main problem is that HM's aren't really utilized for more than "key & lock" puzzles.
A key and lock puzzle is what it sounds like, you put the key in the lock. The "puzzle" is what key to use on which lock, like using cut on certain trees, rock smash on certain rocks, surf to get over water, etc. In essence they add nothing to the gameplay and only exist to limit the player's exploration until certain requirements are met. They aren't a puzzle, they aren't fun. If you could replace the HM and it's use with a keychain and a bunch of locks and lose nothing, then you've got a key and lock puzzle.
Strength isn't a key and lock puzzle, or at least it wasn't originally. They had a couple of strength specific puzzles in the early games, making the Strength HM adding to gameplay beyond creating a player barrier. If they could get more creative with this (like how Golden Sun uses the Psyenergy puzzles) then I could maybe see the worth in HM's (besides as purely competitive moves). They would have to fix the moveslot issues, but if there was a will there would be a way.
That's an interesting idea, honestly they limit what you can use the HMs possibilities for puzzles:
Cut: Why are trees the only things we can cut? How about ropes/wires, imagine a puzzle where we need to cut certain wires in order to open a door or certain maybe ropes which are holding things together (you'd need to cut the right to keep things together while also removing what's in your way).
Strength: The Strength puzzles are okay as they are now, honestly the only addition I could give to Strength would be a "key & lock" challenge like forcing a door open.
Surf/Waterfall/Dive/Whirlpool: Honestly to make an effective challenge for the water HMs you'll need to incorporate multiple of them into the puzzle. Surf would be mandetory but honestly Surf is just a way to walk over a different terrain. You'd need to add things like moving to different levels with Waterfall, accessing different locations with Dive, or Whirlpool to get pass rough water (Whirlpool is limited in that regard, honestly for Whirlpool the challenge would probably trying to find a way to weaken rough waters just enough so Whirlpool can be used to pass them. Or maybe add new functions to Whirlpool like maybe the stronger the Whirlpool the faster and further it'll move you through rough waters/tides).
Fly: Fly has only ever been treated as a convenience more than something that's needed. Honestly Bounce would probably have more puzzle use than Fly would. But sticking with Fly, maybe they could have places where you can use Fly to get to a higher ledge. At first this sounds like a "key and lock" challenge, which it could be, or it could just be used as a tool for part of a puzzle (like you need to get to a higher place in order to see something or access a button/lever/etc.).
Rock Smash: I can see this being used in weight puzzles, like there's a weight mechanism that has too many objects on it and you need to break the right objects to get the weight needed. Maybe even combine it with a Strength puzzle.
Rock Climb: Same us as with Waterfall & even Fly, accessing a different height though probably inside a cave where you can't fly easily or there's no water to go up. Would be combined with other HMs for more complex puzzles.
Defog: Maybe have it spin fans/turbines to create power through a facility and you need to control where the power goes and how much power is being diverted.
Flash: Erm, maybe a puzzle that evolves controlling the level of light in the room? Like maybe have plants which are sensitive to light and depending on how strong the light is they can be used in different ways (like low light they do nothing thus can be passed over, normal light they grow and can be climbed up but now can't be passed, and bright light their flower opens and it can be crossed like a platform though now can't be climbed or passed)