When you think about it, you're just some kid that's going around logging all the Pokemon. None of these Pokedex entries are official (in-game, I mean, they're totally official on a meta level) or even backed up by data, it's just some excited ten year old writing down what they thought they saw. Of course they're not going to make any sense.
Oh boy unpopular opinions time.
Ugh, I did the thing where I typed way way way too much again. I'll be spoilering all of these just so that my post doesn't take up like half a webpage. You're welcome, I think?
Topic: Pikachu's Design
Not only does Pikachu look kinda meh (not too popular an opinion, but certainly not nonexistent), but Raichu looks straight up better in almost every conceivable way, from the elongated ears to the streamlined tail to just overall being bigger. The only things I maybe don't like about Raichu is that it looks too fat to be taken seriously as a "bigger better faster stronger Pikachu" (which is kinda the point of evolutions), and that its colors don't contrast nearly as well as Pikachu's yellow, red, and black. Oh well, a small price to pay for getting to have a cool evo, and certainly nothing that'll make me hesitate to Thunderstone a Pikachu the moment it learns thunderbolt. Now if only they would just bite the bullet and give it a mega...
Topic: While you guys are on the subject of HMs...
Idk if this is a popular opinion or not, but I really really want HMs to go away. I do agree that they add to exploration and such, but from a world-building standpoint there is no reason you shouldn't just be able to:
- burn small trees down with any fire or cutting move
- surf with any Pokemon that would logically be big enough to carry you and should logically be able to swim
- break any of those rock smash rocks with any move that should logically be capable of breaking rocks (Ex: Brick Break; if it can break bricks, there's no reason it can't break rocks)
And so on.
The part I think is silly is not the existence of HMs, but that HMs are the ONLY moves that let you do a certain action. As a programmer myself, I can guarantee you that this is not a difficult problem to fix, especially if this is a freshly created Pokemon game and not a ROM hack. Wherever it is that you're coding the moves, you can just add a property of "what sh*t can I do in the overworld with this move." If that proves too infeasible, you could always associate each obstacle with a list of moves and/or Pokemon that are capable of passing that obstacle. There are a lot of moves and Pokemon, but not nearly a large enough number for either option to take up any significant amount of space, especially with modern 3DS cartridges. The only potential issue I can think of is that it may take like three days to look through every single move or Pokemon and figure out what it can do, but given that they change damages and stuff all the time, which would imply that they already do this, I can't see that being a significant issue.
It might also not let them put as many progress limiters in their game (such as needing to beat Gym X to be able to get past obstacle Y), but I fully welcome the loss of that crutch. They've let this kind of thing limit their creativity for too long anyway. Why is Pokemon a linear game again? The entire point of the game, as far as I can tell, is that you explore a massive world and catch a bunch of cool creatures. The kind of linearity that currently exists in Pokemon makes little sense. If you really want to make sure the player clears a gym first, just have some guy stand near the area the player is gonna go next, and have 'em be like "you should probably make sure you can beat the gym leader before you go this way, because the Pokemon in this next area are tough." You know how there was some NPC by Pewter City that stopped you from progressing until you beat Brock? That was annoying, but at least it made more sense than not being able to use ember on a small tree to clear it out of the way.
S/M Spoilers
Then again they're apparently getting rid of gyms in Sun/Moon, so they can't rely on that kind of limitation anyway. Maybe this will force Pokemon to be less linear.
Topic: Gen V's Pokemon
Gen V's Pokemon selection might actually be my favorite in the entire series. As far as sheer numbers go, I can remember more Pokemon introduced in Gen V than for any other region. It's not even because some designs are so bad that they can't help but stick out either; I LIKE a ton of them, even the ones people don't like. Yeah I like Zorua, Archen, Snivy, Joltik, and their evolutions, but I also like Vanillite, Druddigon, Pansage/sear/pour, Emolga, Trubbish, Pidove, Roggenrola, and their evolutions. I would go so far as to say I like the Roggenrola family more than the Geodude family, and the Pidove family more than the Pidgey family. The same applies for almost every single Gen V family that looks like a family from a previous generation.
Actually, I'm looking through the Pokemon that were introduced in Gen V, and...honestly? Other than the Tepig and Oshawott lines, I think I like every single one of them. And the only reason I don't like the Tepig line is because it's another fire/fighting starter, and the only reason I don't like the Oshawott line is because it switches from a ninja theme to the samurai theme for no reason. Other than that, I can say with around 95% confidence that I like every single Gen V Pokemon.
I don't think I can say the same thing for any other generation of Pokemon. Not Gen III. Not Gen II. Not even Gen I. Even Gen VI, with its quality over quantity approach, still has more Pokemon proportionally that I don't like. I might be able to get away with saying that I like just about every Gen IV Pokemon, but I can only give maybe a 70% confidence rating on that claim. I might be forgetting a few Pokemon that I really can't stand or something.
So not only do I like Gen V's Pokemon more sheer number wise, I also like a higher proportion of them! Not that I don't have a ton of Pokemon from every generation, just that Gen V might be the only one that has consistently me with Pokemon that I like.
I also like how you can't get any Pokemon other than Gen V Pokemon in Black and White. This is a far away region, not near those previous four regions that are relatively close together. It shouldn't have any of the same Pokemon. And on a gameplay level, not having any old Pokemon to rely on forces the player to interact with the new ones. On an aesthetic level, this also makes Black and White feel very foreign, even scary, in a way that no Pokemon game could feel since Gen I. It's a technique that I think they can only pull off once, only because adding so many Pokemon so quickly will just overflow the pokedex, but for that one time, I really did enjoy it. Black2/White2 lost that appeal the moment they added Pokemon from older regions again. Now it wasn't a new experience. It was just like every other Pokemon game. Which I feel misses the entire point of Gen V.
Topic: Tall Grass
I don't like the random encounter system that goes on inside tall grass, or any equivalent throughout the Pokemon series. I feel like the only reason it was done this way in the past was because older systems did not have the capacity to render Pokemon on the overworld walking through the tall grass, and so they had to make them invisible. But if that's the reason, then it's an outdated archaic mechanic that I would not mind seeing replaced. Especially now that Pokemon is a 3D model game, having Pokemon be invisible on the overworld and suddenly appearing out of nowhere feels even more jarring than it did back in the sprite days. And mechanics wise...how many times have you guys run into a Pokemon encounter you didn't want to deal with? Wouldn't that have been so much more tolerable if you just saw the Pokemon some distance away and decided to walk around it? Suddenly surfing around in Hoenn becomes bearable!