R_N said:1. The symbol system isn't just for the hacking thing (like you can just hack in the symbol, or hack a symboled pokemon), it's for specifically limiting the pokemon you can use to *this generation*. It means you are forced to discard old tutors, tms, etc. For some pokemon they discard abilities.
2. That VGC, iirc, allowed *all* legendary pokemon, which was the problem. It included the 680 legendaries. They clearly have no problem having lower level legends
3b. This is completely irrelevant? Nat Dex pokemon wouldn't be available (beyond the island scans) until post game so the main game reasoning doesn't stick. The symbol limiter would ignore it in the first place in competitive play (see also: XY). But also we know they're allowing the national dex for next year so...
1. Yes, that's true in some way (I don't recall which pokemon is heavily nerfed by tutor moves cross-gen tho, except Gengar which is the only notable nerfed poke in SM which is the first time apart from the Kanto doggos), but in Gen 4 and Gen 5 hacking into the game is essentially as easy as a cakewalk because the anti-hack of DS games sucked - Woe betide BW2 which is cracked almost day-one and hacks are readily available. There are still toys for you to gen pokes in Gen 6 onwards, except it is made much more complicated because of firmware updates even tho some bad players still did that.
(Still, when all you can do is hack normal pokes, why would anyone still hack pokes apart from getting a "legit" shiny and save time SR-ing the game?)
2. The thing is some of the legendaries have a lot of BST in their belt which grants them a lot of power/spare EVs. Though yes most of them aren't super game breaking, so it's probably good if they don't allow big guys to ruin the game.
3. Whoops, I did not know they are allowing National Dex in 2018 lol. Then yeah b is totally irrelevant now, thought they were sticking to the Alola rule.
Still it seems counter-productive if they aren't including a national dex when they are allowing every old poke to be in the game (bar some of the legendaries which they are probably mum about it until December), so maybe they will have a national dex but they will lower the qualifications needed to obtain the charms, say they only need to fill the USUM Alola dex?