NOC Greek Mythology Mafia [GAME OVER: SCUM WIN]

CaffeineBoost said:
I could say the same thing about your refusal to accept that the post you responded to were literally the thoughts I had on the game at that point. It's bad that I didn't respond to your response for discussion but there wasn't really much to say, you just repeated what you had previously said so no real discussion was going to happen. After that you actually started to push on me and we could get some discussion going. As a result of this discussion, I have a fairly large scumread on you much like you (seem to) have on me. It's good to understand where you're coming from though.
Click to expand...

Oh, so that was just your only thoughts on the game at that point? I doubt it, but at least it's an explanation. Do you actually have any thoughts on anyone else, or are we just going to keep up this little back and forth until one of us is dead?

Also MoodyCloud I await your return to this game eagerly.
 
Hitmonleet said:
Oh, so that was just your only thoughts on the game at that point? I doubt it, but at least it's an explanation. Do you actually have any thoughts on anyone else, or are we just going to keep up this little back and forth until one of us is dead?

Also MoodyCloud I await your return to this game eagerly.
Click to expand...
Nothing that makes me want to shift the spotlight off you. Sorry.
 
CaffeineBoost said:
Nothing that makes me want to shift the spotlight off you. Sorry.
Click to expand...
Coolio. So, uhhh, what are we supposed to badger each other with, then? There's no spotlight on me other than you being bizarrely lacking when it comes to accusing me of being suspicious. While I don't like your posts one bit, and would prefer your lynch, I'm going to move on and get more productive discussion today, if that's alright with you.
 
Former Hope said:
ngl I've also been pretty passive so far this game so let me list some gut reads thus far

I like CaffeineBoost, I kind of like leet? Or at least I thought blazade's(?) point was good early on.

Asek, idk. There are some sort of towny vibes mixed in but he's also been acting fairly strange regarding pushing me
Click to expand...

Would you mind clarifying all of these, if you would? This is all pretty nebulous and non-conductive to debate.
 
Empoof said:
The thread made a universal decision to not read empoof this day phase
Click to expand...

Hey, Empoof, old buddy old pal, it's a tad bit difficult to read you when all of your posts and thoughts are pretty spread out. Mind if I beg you for a full readslist with rationale? Overall, though, I'm leaning on the side of town atm.
 
ItzViper482 said:
may go more in depth later, lazy right now tho

apricity - I agree with dave that his aggressiveness leans town, him vs fh and caffeine shows where he was aggressive and I think the points he has brought up are solid. STILL dont see where he replied to leet but idt thats a reason to keep my vote on him tbh unvote: apricity (please some1 tell me where he replied tho, it will make me feel much better about this slot lmao)

my gut read on asek and dave is mostly gone, I like the way they have both been playing and tr them but if one is scum so is the other imo. they have buddied quietly in the background in the posts early on, not 100% yet

I find it weird how hitmonleet / former hope / me / 3p1k have all brought up that what apricity did earlier was fairly scummy yet 3p1k has not been questioned yet

texas looks fine to me, same with empoof but a little more than texas tbh, i want more from both

i like a lot of the posts against caffeine are solid but i still gut read him town. i want to see how he responds to this that he said himself
"Now I believe I need to remind myself about FH. I've seen a few SR's on FH pop up so I'm going to take a look at how they've played this game. "

i was p null on leet before but his actions in him vs caffeine lean town to me, dont have much here if im honest im finding it hard to pinpoint my gut reads with stuff he has said

"viper is kind of just scum but i'm not going to say anything about him until i actually want him lynched, he's the kind of player i don't give half assed reads on because if he knows why i'm reading him a certain way he's going to 180 and fuck up my radar. you can hold me accountable to this though, ask me again after a few more viper posts or maybe i'll post it as a serious day 1 lynch idk "

ill reply to this the best i can

i do kinda wish you would say why you scum read me so that there can be discussion about it but ill be patient. im not gonna lie here and say that if you said smth that i could fix later in my posts that made me seem scummy id probs keep that thing in mind when i made posts so take that as you want ig

also i like how he said to hold him accountable to this

lmk if i missed smth and ask me questions
Click to expand...

Interesting thoughts here - Can you point at a few in particular as to solid thoughts from Apricity? How do you feel about Empoof and Texas now that they've posted some more? If you had to lynch someone right now, who would it be and why?
 
Hitmonleet said:
Hey, Empoof, old buddy old pal, it's a tad bit difficult to read you when all of your posts and thoughts are pretty spread out. Mind if I beg you for a full readslist with rationale? Overall, though, I'm leaning on the side of town atm.
Click to expand...

My readslist is over there and my rationale for the top 3 I gave you. Maybe later I'll do that but for now nah.

Is there a read I have that you disagree with or want more explanation on? What were you hoping to accomplish by me posting a full rationale reads list?
 
Hitmonleet said:
Interesting thoughts here - Can you point at a few in particular as to solid thoughts from Apricity? How do you feel about Empoof and Texas now that they've posted some more? If you had to lynch someone right now, who would it be and why?
Click to expand...
Do you want to answer these questions yourself? Replace the first with how you feel about me now that we’ve fought it out
 
Hitmonleet said:
Interesting thoughts here - Can you point at a few in particular as to solid thoughts from Apricity? How do you feel about Empoof and Texas now that they've posted some more? If you had to lynch someone right now, who would it be and why?
Click to expand...

recent posts from empoof read town for sure, dont know how he plays scum tho, his playing fits in line with his style in islands. was looking for difference is tone compared to that game, havent found much. at most empoof is playing this one a little more serious

still not enough from texas, null on him

will point out stuff on apricity later when i have time, hold me accountable to this (yes, i just shamelessly stole from apricitys playbook, gg)

i dont think voting some1 rn is good as we still have time but if i had to i would probs vote former hope or 3p1k. i have mentioned why i think 3p1k is shady and agree with what most have said about former

i dislike this question cause i really would never vote some1 rn


CaffeineBoost said:
Now I believe I need to remind myself about FH. I've seen a few SR's on FH pop up so I'm going to take a look at how they've played this game.
Click to expand...

waiting to see this.
 
Empoof said:
My readslist is over there and my rationale for the top 3 I gave you. Maybe later I'll do that but for now nah.

Is there a read I have that you disagree with or want more explanation on? What were you hoping to accomplish by me posting a full rationale reads list?
Click to expand...

Yeah, I remembered the top three right after posting that, sorry. I'd personally like your thoughts on me, Coffee, Apricity, Viper, and 3P1K, since they've been topics of discussion as of late. Tbh I wanted all your thoughts and reasons so as to get a better read on you, since my current read is mostly gut.
 
ItzViper482 said:
recent posts from empoof read town for sure, dont know how he plays scum tho, his playing fits in line with his style in islands. was looking for difference is tone compared to that game, havent found much. at most empoof is playing this one a little more serious

still not enough from texas, null on him

will point out stuff on apricity later when i have time, hold me accountable to this (yes, i just shamelessly stole from apricitys playbook, gg)

i dont think voting some1 rn is good as we still have time but if i had to i would probs vote former hope or 3p1k. i have mentioned why i think 3p1k is shady and agree with what most have said about former

i dislike this question cause i really would never vote some1 rn




waiting to see this.
Click to expand...

Thanks, I just wanted to know who you felt most sus without saying it outright. Would you mind clarifying what it is that others have said that you agree with involving Former?
 
apricity ItzViper482 yeah you guys should just put it out there this whole "I don't want my read on them to change their behavior" thing is pretty lucrative and I have both of you as decent town. So if there's legitimate reasons either of you are scummy to the other I'd like to hear them
 
ItzViper482 said:
recent posts from empoof read town for sure, dont know how he plays scum tho, his playing fits in line with his style in islands. was looking for difference is tone compared to that game, havent found much. at most empoof is playing this one a little more serious

still not enough from texas, null on him

will point out stuff on apricity later when i have time, hold me accountable to this (yes, i just shamelessly stole from apricitys playbook, gg)

i dont think voting some1 rn is good as we still have time but if i had to i would probs vote former hope or 3p1k. i have mentioned why i think 3p1k is shady and agree with what most have said about former

i dislike this question cause i really would never vote some1 rn




waiting to see this.
Click to expand...
Thanks for reminding me actually. Doing that now.
 
Hitmonleet said:
Thanks, I just wanted to know who you felt most sus without saying it outright. Would you mind clarifying what it is that others have said that you agree with involving Former?
Click to expand...

apricity said:
This is the post that started all of this. You are scumreading me here: this is why you are agreeing with leet (who thinks i am straight up scum at this point), and why you are calling my push weird and unnatural. This post is not an endorsement of apricity being town

Next,

Here you say that my posts read as noob scum and you are considering whether or not I am actually scum because of the way my posts have come across


And now you have decided that I am town

There is a progression through these three posts. In the first one you call me scum for a post and in the last one you call me town for that same post

So this is a total 180 of your read on me and I am asking you why it took me and asek voting you in order for this 180 to happen
Click to expand...

he has also responded with a lot of filler, not fully explaining himself when he has had chances to do so

its not very solid but its smth atleast, same with my read on 3p1k
 
Hitmonleet said:
Yeah, I remembered the top three right after posting that, sorry. I'd personally like your thoughts on me, Coffee, Apricity, Viper, and 3P1K, since they've been topics of discussion as of late. Tbh I wanted all your thoughts and reasons so as to get a better read on you, since my current read is mostly gut.
Click to expand...

coffee dunno, sorta read your fight as v/v but i tuned a lot of it out.
apricity lean town on activity and playing with an in your face style. Weak read.
Viperz probably highest town of the people you listed, good thoughts and process feels good. Filler good adjectives here.
3p1k didn't look into heavily yet but I liked the post they had that included the asek/me bit at the bottom just because all the thoughts felt naturally flowing. Didn't feel like he forced himself to have a read on someone there. But I think I have a disconnect with how they post atm that makes me unsure about them. <- said this earlier fwiw
You idk you developed fine but I have this twitch that you really needed me to shake you for reads and said "idk i'm not good" but then started championing the thread. Sometimes when you talk about people it feels like you're trying to spew them a certain thing rather than an actual thought. These aren't things you can really combat or change my mind about so I didn't feel the need to bring them up and just let you go.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top