Magnus0 said:I finished my white run with Simisear, Leavanny, Minccino, Eelektross and Cobalion. I reset on most major battles to test all of my team members. I´ll try to be a bit more brief in my summary, so if you need some more details about matchups or whatever, I would be happy to elaborate.
Simisear: this thing was much better than expected. Early game was so-so, but not that bad because it had mostly good matchups against cilan and most of pinwheel forest, and after that it could already evolve. Once it does, it is crazy strong for the entirety of the mid game, and to my surprise its power didn't fall off at all in the late game (bulk kinda did though). Movepool is amazing, with dig, grass knot, brick break, acrobatics, rock slide etc. as coverage and even wisp and yawn for utility. Matchups are also amazing.
It destroys Cilan, Burgh, Skyla, Brycan and some more minor rival battles like chargestone cave N effortlesly. It also does very well against Elesa by virtue of stats and Clay by virtue of movepool (grass knot OHKO's both Krokorok and Palpatoad, and it outspeeds Excadrill and puts a major dent in it with flame burst). E4 is also decent. It does a lot of damage to Shauntal and Caitlin with shadow claw. Acrobatics ouspeeds and OHKO's Mienshao and puts heavy damage on the more bulky fighting types. Fire blast OHKO's bisharp and Liepard. Overall, it was extremely good ever since it evolved so I nominate Pansear for B tier
Leavanny: I don't know what you guys did to make Swadloon love you so much, but mine evolved quite late at level 32. It didn't matter too much because eviolite Swadloon held up well, and the evolution was right in time for Clay. Leavanny had some power issues, and it didn't have the bulk or defensive typing to make up for it. It died a lot to random fire or flying coverage. Movepool is decent, but I think it's lacking some utility that most other grass types offer. Leech seed, stun/sleep spore or earlier setup moves could have made it more useful in mid-game matchups, but alas. Matchups were honestly really bad until E4. Like it has 'worse bad matchups' than the other grass types.
Burgh is a mixed bag, dealing with dwebble and Leavanny decently but not reliably. Elesa, Skyla and Marshall are an absolute no go. Clay is good, but it can't break through Excadrill and dies to rock slide, so it wasn't any more useful here then Simisear. It can do some damage to Brycen and Iris but it does nothing very notable in either matchups. I hoped it would finally shine at the E4, but it really wasn't as rosy as it looks on paper. It can't set up on Cofagrigus because wisp. Even with a rawst berry, you can't pull of a setup because it failed to OHKO with shadow claw after TWO sword dances. If you can set up on Golurk you can clear the rest of Shauntals team so decent matchup I guess. Grimsley is same thing. You can't set up on Scafty because poison jab and sand-attack, and Liepard of all things actually beats Leavanny straight up with aerial ace. It misses a KO on Krook (even without intimidate) and it got outsped somehow. Pretty mediocre matchup honestly. Caitlin was easy. One SD and her entire team is dead. It dies to random rock moves on all of Marshals pokemon. Overall, it wasn't bad but not great either. It misses that unique bit of oomph that most other grasses have, like coil, sleep powder or curse + gyro ball combo. I think it wasn't bad enough to drop down to C, barely, so Sewaddle for staying in B tier. I do think the other grass types in B are a lot more reliable though, because they can force something even in bad matchups. So if anyone else thinks Sewaddle should drop, I would be happy to agree.
Minccino: I'm not really sure what to think of this. It has the potential to be great, but it often fails because bad RNG. It's movepool is great, but a lot of it is unreliable. All multi-hit moves are RNG based and have shaky accuracy. It gets PP problems as well, mostly as a result of missing a lot. It does have some good matchups though.
Elesa, Clay, Iris, and Caitlin are mostly neutral matchups. It can do well, but that is mostly based on getting 4 or 5 tail slaps in. It beats Skyla and Brycen easily with rock blast. In the E4, it's useless against Marshall. It can be decent against Grimsley, but wake-up-slap fails to OHKO Bisharp, hell, it failed to OHKO Liepard. It can use bullet seed and rock blast against Shauntal, but again, not reliable. If this thing had skill link, it would be much better. With technician though, I don't think it's reliable enough to make a case for B. So Minccino for staying in C tier. the Lilipup line also does pretty much everything Minccino wants to do better.
Eelektross: first off, it's very rare which doesn't help its case. The fact that it is absolute shit as tynamo and evolves late is actually not that big of a deal with some good planning. If you give it the Exp. share it should reach about level 32 after doing all of route 7 and celestial tower. That's enough for it to hold its own with a lucky egg in Skyla's gym. After clearing all the trainers on its own, its should be around level 36. It also cleared Skyla herself all by itself, which gave it two more levels. That's one rare candy away from having an Eelektross, because you can skip the Eelektric stage completely. I went from cathing Tynamo to having Eelektross in about an hour of gameplay. It then gets a great movepool right away and some great power. The only issue is speed.
Its matchups are decent. It soloes Skyla. It does well against Brycen and Marshall with rock slide and acrobatics respectively. All of the other matchups are basically neutral. It has super effective coverage on almost everything, so it hits very hard in most matchups. Overall, its tynamo stage wasn't nearly as painful as I thought it would be, but its Eelektross stage also wasn't as strong as I had hoped for. Its speed was too low to take advantage of its great power, movepool and typing. It was a bit dissapointing, but also not useless. That's why I nominate Tynamo for D tier
Cobalion: oh boy, this was dissapointing. First of all, it is a nightmare to catch. You need two HM's to even get to it, arguably three because you would rather fly to Driftveil than go through chargestone cave again. Then when you are inside, you also need repels and flash and a shit ton of timer/dusk balls. This all takes more effort than your typical detour. It takes luck to catch it, because its catch rate is bad. When you do get it, it has good stats, but nothing too extraordinary. Its offenses are actually quite modest, weaker than Cinccino even. Movepool is great though, as is its typing.
It destroys both Brycen and Drayden, but the E4 is actually really not great. It can't use its stabs well against shauntal, and it doesn't have enough coverage or power to anything noteworthy here. Grimsley is great overall, but you definitely need to watch out for Scrafty. Krook also lives a sacred sword (again, even without intimidate) and retaliates with a dangerous earthquake. It's useless against Caitlin, unless maybe you have swords dance already (mine didn't). Unboosted X-scissor didn't even 3-HKO Gothitelle. Everything on Marshals team kills it. If it is such a hassle to catch this thing, you at least expect it to destroy whatever is left there to destroy in the end game. However, it is definitely no world destroyer, so it should drop down to B, or even C tier
I can agree with most of these opinions. Deep down, I knew Leavanny wasn't the superstar I want it to be on paper. It could drop to C without me complaining too much.
D tier is just right for Tynamo.
I
knew Coballion was grossly overrated on the old tier list. I mean you can use it but it's not beating any other Fighting type not named Mienfoo in the listings.
Yeah, despite its advantages, I'm not putting Pansear in B unless Litwick goes there as well. I know Litwick has garbage stats but it pays off with some of the best stats in the game, the best Ghost type in the game, and in general the best Special Attacker despite coming late. Pansear in its base form never OHKOs anything. You likely go through 12
painful levels of awful before you become decent, and by then Darumaka is available. I know the game is lacking in Fire types, but Pansear is easily the weakest monkey of the three. I will concede almost sweeping Clay does help though. Also, the bosses you mentioned it beats effortlessly are some of the easiest sans Clay. Sweeping Skyla, Brycen, and the rivals can be done by
anything with as setup move because they all suck more than a vacuum cleaner. I'd sooner keep Snivy in B forever than raise Pansear there.
Exhibit A, old thread:
-Pansear LVL 12 >:(
I boxed this miserable pile of crap as soon as I found out you only need Cut ONCE.
Simply horrible.
Same guy:
Pansear: I boxed this thing as soon as I could. Incinerate is just a terrible move and he's so frail. Garbage Tier.
Exhibit B, old thread:
Fire Monkey (monkeys in general): Worth keeping in your party until you find a replacement, but definitely not past that. Ditched Pansear as soon as I had access to Darumaka and never looked back.
Exhibit C:
Pansear - It came in handy against the rival with just Incinerate, even when his Serperior was level 20~. Boxed in the big city place before route 4, never really used it but it sucked outside of hitting Grass types. Low-Mid Tier
Exhibit D, Colonel M:
Pansear:
Look man, Pansear fucking >6HKOed the first Gym's Pansage, which is... humiliating. STAB Incinerate is so weak it isn't even funny. Panpour and Pansage, while not "gods", at least have a good STAB move behind them (45 vs. 60), and to me they don't have much of a purpose to sticking around when they have a Slow EXP going against them. Pansear gets cursed being in a league worse than most Fire-types.
Exhibit E, in response to the above:
Can we have a tier below Bottom only for him?
Do I need to say any more? Yeah, Pansear is not a champion.
Also, these two comments:
I'd like to push forward the idea of ignoring the ice gym in tiering.
The gym is a cakewalk and the idea of needing a pokemon to win in it is absurd when one considers the
millions of weaknesses that ice has and the shittiness of his pokemon...
The ice gym only serves for Cobalion to roflstomp it while you use your 2 exp. shares to strengthen your party.
Even without Cobalion, Darmanitan, Mienfoo and Gurrdurr, heck, even Boldore. The last 3 are just near Icirrus as well.
Additionally, found this in the old thread courtesy of
The Cicada:
Dweble: Oh my god this little hermit crab is awesome. It has two decent STABS when you get it, and you catch it right before the electric gym, which Dweble solo'd for me. Just use Stealth Rock and watch Elesa's Emolga's commit suicide, while you also hit them with Smack Down/Rock Tomb. Dig Should take care of Zebstrika no problem. Dweble also rapes the Flying, Ice, and Dragon gyms (thats three in a row). Against the E-4 Crustle just pwned. Against Caitlin, set up Shell Smash, survive Reunciles (or whatever it's called) Psychic, due to Sturdy, then outpace and OHKO everything. Against Shauntal, Set up Shell Smash, get burned by confarigus, eat your Rawst Berry, rape everything with Shadow Claw and Rock Slide. Against Grimsly, set up Shell Smash, and rape. Against Marshal, don't you dare use Crustle against him. Against N, set up Shell Smash against Reshirma/ Zekrom, and then rape. Against Ghetsis i got in two Shell Smash against his confarigus, then OHKO'D it with Shadow Claw. After that i killed 3 more of his Pokemon (including Hydreigon), leaving him with only 2 Pokes left. The only reason i didn't sweep him with Crustle is cuz of Toxic killing me. How can something that owns boss battles so easily be anything but
High Tier.
Might have to retest Dwebble. Heck, I could even go get it now if I wanted.